Flanagan’s Stop and Shop

Feels like your average small town liquor store, but actually has a quite decent selection. Lots of local beer (WI, IL, MI), plenty of singles and 20% discount for a full 6-pack. Good place to pick up New Glarus’ better stuff.

Large bottle shop. The beer selection seems haphazard and poorly organized, but there is actually a decent selection with some less common things. I easily filled a six pack. Good selection of Green Bay beers which I was looking for as I will not be able to get there this trip. Prices are a bit high, but the 20% discount for getting six helps. My mixed six pack was just over $14. Not horrible. No assistance available in the beer section, but friendly cashier. Across the street from OB’s Brau Haus, so worth a stop.

Stopped here a few times now that I'm an Appleton resident. Original rating 3/18/17. The old review still mostly applies. But I'm downgrading the score for a couple reasons. First, the BYO six pack sections gives you a 20% discount if you get six, but they quite obviously jack up the prices on the singles by about the same amount. Fuck your shady business practices. Also, the staff is normally friendly, sometimes surly, and usually incompetent. It's an old school place with a good selection, but otherwise pretty meh. If this weren't near my office and my regular hangout (McFleshmans) I'd probably never come here. Old score was 64.

It was much bigger than I expected and there was a nice selection. The singles section was a decent size, but the prices were a tad high, so best to go with 6 to get the 20% off. Worth a stop if you are in the area.

Been in business throgh 2 generations that I have patronized. Excellant selection of beers, wines and liquors at a reasonable price.

Sometimes a bit disorganized and staff not overly helpful, but some decent selection of in and out-of-state brews. Mostly Wisconsin and regional stuff.

A respectable store. Nothing special. Pretty hit or miss in the singles section. Sometimes you find a gem other times is just a thrown together hodge podge of stock they are trying to get rid of. Usually nothing too rare or hard to find, but reliable for the regulars that you would expect in Wisconsin.

The great selection of beers is what makes this a good place to shop. It’s a bit cramped for space because of the selection. Pat (owner0 always seems to be around to help patrons locate what they’re looking for. A good place to go.

This place has a well rounded selection but without the peaks of beer hunting. New Glarus is well represented but they were sold out of any unpluggeds. Reasonable selection of Wisconsin beers but nothing that can’t be found elsewhere in the state. I was surprised by the lack of interesting Central Waters beers. Reasonable selection of Belgians and other brews. Decent singles selection. Good overall liquor store, decent location if you’re in the city (as I was) but it doesn’t deserve a detour if you’re a veteran beer hunter. The staff was helpful in trying to find things I asked about.

not nearly as bad as its been made out to be. yes indeed they have some chunky and dusty old beers but the majority are fine. the selection is pretty large, and i found some older NG unplugged beers. if you want to delve into wine and liquor you are definitely set, theyve got mountains of the stuff. but there are no short of 5-6 coolers of 6 packs, 2 more of 12 packs and a long row of warm 6 packs. around the corner from that are single 12ozs for make your own 6 pack, and plenty of bombers. then you have yet another shelf full of 750s. and none of this includes all the macro junk. id be happy if this store was in my hood!

I travel from Green Bay so I can purchase my Stone Ruination IPA. They have a nice selection of beer and every thing they have can be bought individually. This is the closest place the sell Stone brewing products so this is were I go. Staff is alright but not reallly eager to help.