Colter Bay Grill, Buffalo, New York
RateBeer
Colter Bay Grill (716) 882-1330
561 Delaware Avenue Buffalo New York United States 14202
Places > United States > New York > Buffalo

Colter Bay Grill
Rating N/A - too few ratings
Type: Bar

561 Delaware Avenue
Buffalo, New York United States 14202 [ print map ]
(716) 882-1330


Taps: 25



WiFi
Children
Patio
Seasonals
Real Ales
Proper Glassware
Beer To Go/Growlers
BYO 6-Pack/Singles
Available At This Location (arranged by most recent)
Long Trail Brewmaster Series Winter White 77, Wagner Valley Caywood Station Oatmeal Stout 32
More Beers Available Here

Print out shelftags



8 reviews for Colter Bay Grill
 Ambiance 55%
 Service 65%
 Selection 55%
 Food 70%
 Value 18%
 Overall 66%
 Rating N/A



TheJester (22), Peterborough, Ontario
  72   Ambiance  Service  Selection  Food  Value  Overall 
3/58/1011/15N/A 7/1014/20

December 31, 2009
Spent an hour or three there drinking Arrogant Bastard and Hop Stoopid. Service was very friendly. Fairly busy, with the clientele being on the young side. Bar and restaurant areas were clean and bright enough. The men’s room was absolutely disgusting, however.

kasselrock (11),
  68   Ambiance  Service  Selection  Food  Value  Overall 
3/54/109/15 7/10 7/1018/20

December 29, 2009
Best time to go to this bar is the St Patties day parade....if you can get in...they try har but like most bars in that area needs a little of a face lift. But is has culture and love their beers!

rob897 (10), Buffalo, New York
  64   Ambiance  Service  Selection  Food  Value  Overall 
3/57/108/15 8/10N/A14/20

March 28, 2008
Nice bar with a good selection of different beers on tap. Food has always been good for me.

illinismitty (224), Nashville, Tennessee
  60   Ambiance  Service  Selection  Food  Value  Overall 
3/57/109/15N/AN/A11/20

July 21, 2006 [ Updated October 2, 2006 ]
Stopped here for a nightcap with Dickensonbeer.Crowd is mostly in the 25-30 age range. There are about 25 taps, but nothing really rare. But if you are from out of town, they do have some local and regional beers. During the summer, you can also sit outside. Like IPFreely said, worth stopping by if you are in the neighborhood. Coles and Goodbar are the best places to hit if you have a choice

spkldhenlvr24 (28), Newburgh/Buffalo, New York
  58   Ambiance  Service  Selection  Food  Value  Overall 
2/56/107/15 7/10N/A14/20

May 11, 2005
Nice place in downtown Buffalo. Ambiance wasn’t that great. I asked for the beer list and the waitress handed me a index card out of her server’s book. Lighting was dim. Had some good upstate NY stuff on tap like Flying Bison, Southern Tier HopSun, Ellicotville. Basically some decent available micros. Food was good, but a bit greasy. Bar was packed and loud around 11pm. Check it out if your in town.

rudolf (68), Buffalo, New York
  60   Ambiance  Service  Selection  Food  Value  Overall 
3/56/108/15 6/10N/A13/20

February 20, 2005
Food always seems a bit greasy for me. Beer list is ok with a lot more more available micros (think along the lines of Anchor) Still, they usually have one or two really nice things on tap like Lake Placid UBU

DYCSoccer17 (187), Davis, California
  58   Ambiance  Service  Selection  Food  Value  Overall 
3/58/107/15N/AN/A11/20

November 4, 2004
I enjoyed this bar because the people here were generally nice and it wasnt overly crowded. They have about 20 or so taps, with most being local and easily attainable "micros". The prices arent too bad. The bar area is not the largest. They have a few TVs if you want to watch a sports game. A nice chill place.

IPFreely (92), Lewiston, New York
  50   Ambiance  Service  Selection  Food  Value  Overall 
2/56/107/15N/AN/A10/20

March 5, 2004
A decent bar with 25 taps that aren't the hardest to find. Not worth going out of your way for but worth visiting if you're in the neighborhood.

Want to add your review?

Join us! RateBeer is made by beer enthusiasts for the craft beer community. Membership is free and allows you to add your beer and place reviews!

Sign Up Now



Proximity Map

View Proximity Map
Print Travel Map

Scene
A college bar

Noise
Moderate

Staff
Slightly knowledgable

Music
Juke Box

Food
Connecting restaurant

Parking
On the street