Mr. Goodbar, Buffalo, New York
RateBeer
   Home Sign Up or Login Advanced Search
   People Ratings Events Places Forums Shop Magazine
Places >  United States of America > New York > Buffalo >

Mr. Goodbar


Type: Bar
Rating N/A - too few ratings
 Ratings  Ambiance  Service  Selection  Food  Value  Overall  Rating 
9 58%  79%  76%  75%  N/A  70%  N/A 

1110 Elmwood Ave
Buffalo, New York 14222 [ printable map ]
(716) 882-4000
http://www.mistergoodbarelmwood.com/
[Edit Info]
Taps: 27
Bottles: ?
Entered by: rudolf
Last edit: IPFreely

Seasonals
Real Ales
Rare Beers
Macros
Patio
TV
Proper Glassware
Cigars
Smoking
Reservations
Games
Children



Your Opinions - Last rating was 10 months ago
Sammy Ambiance 2 Service 6 Selection 12 Food Value N/A Overall 14

10/14/2007 10:37:03 PM, sunday, october 14, 2007 [ Updated monday, december 24, 2007 ]
A fairly basic bar, no present heat on a colder day, and a very good set of taps. Pales in comparison to its next door neighbour, Coles, but still has a variety of good taps from across the globe. Known as a college hangout, with lots of tables and pretty dark inside. Suggests to get your pint or two and move on, not hang out. The area itself is a relatively decent band convenient part of Buffalo. Only one server, but he hustled to serve a fairly good sized Sunday aft football crowd.At least two dozen taps on, Cask only on Fridays.

crushinat0r Ambiance 2 Service 8 Selection 12 Food 8 Value N/A Overall 17

2/14/2007 12:53:07 PM, wednesday, february 14, 2007
Well, it’s a divvy bar, no question about that. But we talked with the bartender Bobby for a long time about beer. We got to try a wide variety of GREAT beers and he even through us a few samples. The wings were good too (but definitely don’t get them until you’re done rating beer! They kill the taste buds with their deliciously hot sauce). If you like to try great beers, check this place out.

jerc Ambiance 3 Service 8 Selection 12 Food Value N/A Overall 13

7/16/2006 10:58:52 AM, sunday, july 16, 2006
Retardedly cheap. $3 for PINT of Rogue Imperial Pilsener! For american customers its a solid beer selection. For Canadian customers its an experience where you want to grab as much as you can before someone takes it away. Atmosphere is not as sunny as Cole’s next door but gets the job done. Patio is nice enough. I will be back for sure!

illinismitty Ambiance 2 Service 8 Selection 12 Food Value N/A Overall 13

5/4/2006 4:44:57 PM, thursday, may 04, 2006
Stopped in here before meeting Rudy and Tim on weeknight. There are around 30 taps of decent beer that cover a decent style spectrum. I had no trouble finding a few pints to rate. Plus, prices are cheap. Pretty much a dirty college bar type atmosphere, and lots of smokers. Music was too loud for conversation, and they don’t take credit cards! WTF? Given that it is right next to Coles and they offer some beers you can’t get at Cole’s, it’s worth stopping in....for the beer that is.

frylock Ambiance 3 Service 8 Selection 11 Food Value N/A Overall 14

1/29/2006 12:19:54 PM, sunday, january 29, 2006
Good selection of taps, which included the very rare Lost Coast Old Ale, the last time I was there. The crowd can really be hit or miss. If you go early or during the week and you will be good. Show up on a weekend night and the place will be packed drunken college kids, who aren’t there for the beer selection.

spkldhenlvr24 Ambiance 3 Service 8 Selection 11 Food Value N/A Overall 15

12/12/2005 12:13:37 AM, monday, december 12, 2005
Spacious bar with plenty of room to walk around. Dimly lit. 30 solid taps. Good range of beer. One bartender really knew his stuff. Themed food and beer tasting on Wednsday upstairs and you can but tickets for in advance. Go to Coles on a Friday for a burger than to Goodbar for $2.50 pints, cannot go wrong.

mds Ambiance 3 Service 7 Selection 11 Food Value N/A Overall 13

9/19/2005 12:21:20 PM, monday, september 19, 2005
As Tim and Rudy have mentioned, this is a very convenient spot since it’s right next door to Cole’s which is a can’t miss spot in Buffalo IMO. Though there is some overlap at Goodbar there are some exclusive taps that can’t be found at Cole’s such as the Kulmbacher Eisbock and Schwarzbier. I didn’t try the food. I’ll likely come back here just to see if they have anything interesting on tap...and I’m sure they will. The main area is a large room with pool tables and such, kind of strange that it was very empty on a Saturday night at around 21:00-22:00?

IPFreely Ambiance 3 Service 8 Selection 10 Food Value N/A Overall 13

2/22/2005 1:40:16 PM, tuesday, february 22, 2005
A pretty spacious place, long bar and lots of room otherwise. Actually kind of empty feeling but it’s not bad. Owner is a beer lover, the employees might not be but they’re friendly and accomidating. Usually a pretty good tap selection. Pair this with Cole’s next door and you have a very nice beer destination.

rudolf Ambiance 5 Service 10 Selection 12 Food 7 Value N/A Overall 14

2/20/2005 9:03:08 AM, sunday, february 20, 2005 [ Updated wednesday, may 16, 2007 ]
Mr. Goodbar is solid. Mr. Goodbar is my home away from home. Yes, they have a trough in the mens room. Yes, it can be loud on Friday and Saturday nights.
This place is the real deal.
Bobby & the rest of the staff are great (just be sure to enunciate when it gets loud, lest you end up with something you didn’t want) Beer club is a great event. Prices are ridiculously cheap, especially Friday nights. Casks on Fridays, Happy hour w. free food on Fridays.
DYCsoccer would call me a ’homer’ for saying this but this, especially combined with Cole’s next door, is one of the best beer destinations in the United States.
5/16/07
original rating: Always some solid taps here - bear republic, Lost Coast, southern tier, brooklyn and more. This place has no atmosphere, but if you want to play pool or darts with some friends and have a good beer while you do it this is the place to go. Avoid this place on Thurs, Fri and Saturday night as it is full of college kids rockin’ the 50 cent natty ice deal. Staff is friendly, they’ll pour a nice sized sample without any thought of charging you. Next door to Cole’s. All pints on Fridays are $2.50. Nice.


 
  Rate This Place
  Ambiance
  Service
  Selection
  Food
  Value
  Overall
  Comments

Scene
Nights can get crowded with kids from Buffalo State

Music
Crummy jukebox

Parking
On-street or in the city lot directly behind

Events
They do have a beer club but I’ve never attended

About RateBeer | Add A Beer | Add A Brewer | Edit Personal Info | 100 Beer Club | FAQ | Log out | Feedback? | Copyright 2000-2008, RateBeer LLC