Columbus & Central Ohio: Barleys Smokehouse (Ale House #2)
RateBeer
   Home Sign Up or Login Advanced Search
   People Ratings Events Places Forums Shop Magazine
Places >  Brew Tours: Columbus & Central Ohio>

Barleys Smokehouse (Ale House #2)

Barleys Smokehouse (Ale House #2)


Type: Brewpub
beer info
Exceptional
 Ratings  Ambiance  Service  Selection  Food  Overall  Rating 
18 73%  73%  76%  78%  81%  81 

1130 Dublin Rd
Columbus, Ohio 43215 [ printable map ]
(614) 485-0227
http://www.barleysbrewing.com/enews/
Taps: 8-10
Bottles: 30+


Top Rated Beers Score/Ratings
Barleys Four Seas Imperial IPA 3.88/31
Barleys Barley Wine 3.82/31
Barleys Saint Joans Revenge Imperial Stout 3.8/37
Seasonals
Real Ales
Rare Beers
Macros
Patio
TV
Proper Glassware
Cigars
Smoking
Reservations
Games
Children



RateBeer Brew Tour Guide's Comments
The sister of Barley’s Ale House #1 downtown, the Smokehouse stocks a similar list of great beers while having its own identity. Hosts the annual Mini RAF, Oysters & Stout, and other events. You can’t go wrong with a visit.

Your Opinions - Place info very fresh - it's been rated recently
DragonStout Ambiance 4 Service 5 Selection 12 Food 9 Overall 18

7/1/2008 9:39:44 PM, tuesday, july 01, 2008
Stopped here on my visit to Buckeye country.Heard the food was excellet so I needed to see for myself. The peeps were right. Very good BBQ and there beers were delightful.Had their Oatmeal Porter and also sampled their Pint O Joe.Overall very goos and will definately return.thank you Dawn for taking me here.

Sammy Ambiance 4 Service 6 Selection 11 Food 8 Overall 14

6/18/2008 12:35:23 PM, wednesday, june 18, 2008
Both Barley’s locations are a short drive, relatively speaking. The smokehouse has free parking, has the same beers on rotation, is darker lighting, the food is better assuming you like BBQ. Service was slower, I think they were surprised how many people appeared and may have been caught short. But they are competent with knowledge of the basics of their beers. Booths were good for small groups. Music on the loud side. About 12 taps of micros,PLUS 2 CASKS mostly home taps but four good guest taps. Service was efficient. The beers are approachable, the stouts and barleys above average. Hops are rationed, and in the pales and scotch beers (at least 3 at both locations) an orangey like flavoring apparent, which the brewer says is not orange flavouring but was not more forthcoming. Worth a stop if in town.

Glouglouburp Ambiance 3 Service 7 Selection 11 Food Overall 13

5/16/2008 1:11:31 PM, friday, may 16, 2008 [ Updated friday, may 16, 2008 ]
Pretty big bug but thanks to the isolated sections you don’t feel like in a large commercial place. Some pool tables and pinball machines. The overall atmosphere of this place is that of a countryside restaurant brewpub. Rednecks will feel right at home in this resto-pub. The beer menu is more extensive at this location but I much preferred the other Barley’s location (AleHouse #1) to spend some time. This is a eat-drink-leave place. When I was they had 7 of their beers on tap (including one cask), 7 guest beers on tap (entry level beers from Bell’s, Founders, etc.) and 3 classic hoppy American beers.

crizay Ambiance 4 Service 9 Selection 12 Food 9 Overall 17

12/6/2007 11:36:52 AM, thursday, december 06, 2007
This place rocked very southern looking inside with old wood floors and just a country bbq style feel to it. The beer was very good although they had about 7 on with 6 or so guest taps it definitely beat what #1 had on hands down. The 2 IPA’s were great as was the imperial stout and cherry porter. The food here is straight up southern bbq a completely different menu from #1 and I loved it. Went on a Sunday where service was slow so we had 2 tables to ourselve’s and they put the Browns game on the projection screen along with the sound on the speakers. Stayed for the whole game and some. Just loved this place and would be worth driving 2 hours to again.

BeerVirgin72 Ambiance 3 Service 7 Selection 10 Food 6 Overall 16

3/2/2007 3:07:35 PM, friday, march 02, 2007
Went here for lunch today. First time. LOVED the beer...Food was very tasty and arrived very quickly. No crowd, really...Service was a bit slow, which makes no sense, seeing how they werent busy...When I was leaving though I stopped to get tickets for the Ale Fest and both the hostess and the manager were VERY friendly, so that made up for the server being less then enthusiastic. I would come back simply for the beer, but I prefer the atmosphere at Barley’s #1!!

RIS101 Ambiance 4 Service 9 Selection 13 Food 8 Overall 17

1/13/2007 12:18:02 PM, saturday, january 13, 2007
Good food good beer good fun. Stopped there for dinner and was crowded. Plenty of parking. Hostess were organized and efficient and seated us in a timely fashion. On an extra note Mildred’s Sauerkraut Balls with creamy chipotle sauce were worth the trip alone.

shigadeyo Ambiance 3 Service 6 Selection 8 Food 4 Overall 10

1/7/2007 7:47:23 PM, sunday, january 07, 2007 [ Updated sunday, january 07, 2007 ]
Visited on 11/08/2006... I was at Barleys Smokehouse (Ale House #2) once several years ago, but forgot all about the place until recently. Parking is plentiful and the place is pretty nice inside. However, I found the beers and food to be average - nothing too terribly great or unique. Actually, the food was pretty disappointing. I’ve heard that the Barleys Smokehouse (Ale House #1) is better...

spector Ambiance 4 Service 7 Selection 14 Food 9 Overall 18

11/13/2006 9:13:36 PM, monday, november 13, 2006 [ Updated monday, november 13, 2006 ]
Great place for good food and great beers.Very nice selection of house and guest beers.Last time I went they had Two hearted ale,Founders dirty bastard,and DFH 90 min IPA on tap.The food was really good and not over priced.Barleys is really easy to get to and there is plenty of parking

sliffy Ambiance 4 Service 8 Selection 13 Food 9 Overall 17

10/12/2006 2:38:32 PM, thursday, october 12, 2006
Very nice brew pub, service is usually pretty good, and the range of house brews and guest drafts is great. Usually a cask conditioned beer available as well. And firkin friday’s are great. The food at the smokehouse is quite predictably barbecue inspired. And really is quite good, the beef brisket nachos are a personal favorite. I’ve never seen that place get all that crowded, and there is plenty of parking.

Moggamn Ambiance 3 Service 7 Selection 10 Food 6 Overall 14

10/12/2006 12:00:14 PM, thursday, october 12, 2006
Great Place to sit and have some good local beer. Can sometimes be a little busy, but the local brews are always great. Pick up a Growler and take some home if you’re not from the area...or even if you are from the area.


View Page : 1 2

  Rate This Place
  Ambiance
  Service
  Selection
  Food
  Overall
  Comments

Scene
Smokehouse BBQ/Brewpub

Noise
Somewhat loud

Staff
Somewhat knowledgeable

Music
Local music on weekends

Food
BBQ/Pub Grub

Parking
Plenty of parking.

Events
Mini RAF, Robert Burns Dinner/Scottish Ale Tapping

About RateBeer | Add A Beer | Add A Brewer | Edit Personal Info | 100 Beer Club | FAQ | Log out | Feedback? | Copyright 2000-2008, RateBeer LLC