January 2, 2011
Crowded for a Thursday night including a full bar but were seated at a table immediately. Good menu selection for both food and beer. Fairly priced, however some meals were slightly expensive. Had soup, pizza and a friend had chili which were all yummy. All wood inside and out with a cozy, woodsy feel. Western decorations, muskets, moose heads, antlers, saws etc! Cool feel, great place to grab a bite to eat and enjoy one of the 10 taps (7 appear to be dedicated to craft beer, the others are various of the "Big 3").

February 27, 2009
Good beer selection - no doubt. Pricey though. If you’re eating there food can be inconsistent as can the service and everything is ala carte - c’mon I have to pay for lettuce and tomato for my burger when you’re charging premium prices for the beer? Manager is a douche - never fails to let you know she is a recovering alcoholic. Great, may I have another round?

January 25, 2009
A really nice selection of beers on draft I would have given it more but I just came back from Philly and well I’m still reeling from that. Food is standard but tasty. Staff knows their beers and are enthusiastic about them which is great. Its an odd mix of locals and hipsters in a mountain jug band jamboree setting but a cool place with a chill vibe.

January 23, 2009
The Stirling Hotel has one of the best selections of beer in the state of New Jersey. I usually stop in once a week to see what new treasures they have on tap. The ONLY place I’ve ever had 120 min on draft. These guys know their stuff and the steaks are AMAZING.

May 15, 2008
The inside part of this place is very rustic, dark and kind of close quarters. The outside is where this place gets attention from customers. In reality it’s not really done up (cheap patio sets and a very large picnic tent), but the fact that you can sit out on a nice warm day and get lunch and a great beer is great. The beer selection is great and always changing. For some reason every beer I get on tap there tastes amazing - better than the same ones I’ve had bottled. The food is overpriced for the portions but there’s just something about enjoying a great beer at lunch outside that keeps me coming back. I might go there today if I can convince a coworker to join me. I have only been there at lunch so I can’t comment on evening atmosphere. Oh yeah, the service is decent and they know their beers well even if they are wearing cutoff jeans and a stained t-shirt.

February 24, 2007
The Stirling Hotel is located off the beat and track and from the outside (and inside) looks very rustic indeed.There is a bar that seats about 10-15 people,as well as a large seating area with additional rooms.Also in the warmer months there is a patio area located behind,which also has a small bar.The selection of beers is great,with some nice, constantly changing choices on draft.The last time there they had Corsendonk,Blue Point,Stone,Smithwicks on tap as well as a great choice in bottles.The service is nice and laid back, yet attentive to your needs.The food is excellent with a great variety of classic American cusine.I have personally been coming here for many years and have never been dissappointed.Give them a try!