 JF_GRIND (1209), Glenside, Pennsylvania, USA
Jan 17, 2005
I sampled the same bottle of 2001 thanks to Mullman. The strong aroma of smoked malts stood out as the dominate quality of the 2001 bottle. 2004’s aroma was toned down. Very nice blend of flavors in this smoked porter. I’ve only see this beer in Northern California, it was nice to sample one in PA at hopdog’s gathering.
blutt59 (679), Dallas, Texas, USA
Sep 4, 2008 bottle, black color with coffee colored head, malty campfire coffee nose, flavor is an oily smokey tar with some coffee and burnt toast, very nice
Nik925 (127), California, USA
Sep 2, 2008 2007 bottle. Dark yet thin in both taste and appearance. The smokiness ends up tasting fake to me (like liquid smoke used in cooking). A robust dark brew but the thinness destroys it. Very conservative. Gets better as it warms.
paiste2002 (24), Saugus, California, USA
Aug 31, 2008 2007 vintage 651ml bottle. Pours black as night with a nice off white head. Great smoky aroma. Taste is complex bittersweet chocolate, coffee, malt, smoked wood, vanilla with a bittersweet smoky finish. This is an incredible beer, I look forward to it every season.
Imperial-John (91), Mississauga, Ontario, Canada
Aug 28, 2008 651ml 2007 bottle courtesy of HogTownHarry. Black with small foamy tan head. Great hickory smoke alarm setting off aroma. Taste is complex but too mild. Bittersweet, dry, oily, woody, vanilla, malt in the taste. Bittersweet smokey wood after-taste.
pepperford (89), robbinsdale, Minnesota, USA
Aug 25, 2008 Pitch black like a stout with a medium brown head. Be aggressive with the pour and the head is quite impressive and worth a photo. A bit more carbonation than a stout. Loads of tobacco, chocolate, malt, and a thickness on the mouth feel, that again, teaters on being a stout. Fun beer, unfortunately, i live in bf egypt, so i may never get another chance.
|
