RateBeer
overall
91
84
style
Serve in Thistle

bottling
unknown

on tap
unknown

distribution
unknown

Add Distribution Data
RATINGS: 138   WEIGHTED AVG: 3.5   EST. CALORIES: 270   ABV: 9%
Share this beer with friends!
COMMERCIAL DESCRIPTION
Collaboration with Dunedin Brewery


3.9
   AROMA 8/10   APPEARANCE 4/5   TASTE 7/10   PALATE 3/5   OVERALL 17/20
dantheman278 (1361) - SCOTLAND - APR 22, 2012
Bottle thanks to cgarvieuk. Deep, deep reddish brown, thin off-white head. Interesting nose, some Belgian influence, red fruits, raisin, some coffee notes, soft smoke, juniper? blackcurrant? Very complex. Sweet honeyed malts, again red fruits, sweet smokiness, very perfumed, earthy hops and soft smoke on the finish. Fascinating, well-balanced considering all the disparate elements, but a bit overfizzy.

3.6
   AROMA 7/10   APPEARANCE 4/5   TASTE 7/10   PALATE 4/5   OVERALL 14/20
TheAlum (6193) - Aurora, Illinois, USA - APR 22, 2012
750 ml bottle Matt. Thanks, man! A beer I didnít even know existed. Pours a rich dark brownish pour, dark with some ruby brown edges. A frothy tannish light brown head sits atop, laces well and sticks around as a firm layer. Aromas are touches of fruit, cherries and some toffee. Touches of gentle peat, caramel, and toffee. Toast, toffee, and crisp sweetness. Gentle dry hops. Initial is chocolatey up front, dry with toastiness, some caramel. Much less sweet than the nose let on. Dry and toasty finish, hoppy dryness and toast. Biscuits, bread, toast. Touches of cherries, red fruit, and mellow sweetness creep in, quickly drying out and getting toastu, gentle roast, peat. Some mellow dryness, toffee sweetness, lingering cocoa. Brown malts offer a great difference and good flavor. Wow, quite an interesting exeprience that offers a lot more flavor, balance, and palate experience in the actual beer. Nose was a bit sweet. Looks great. Solid beer.

3.3
   AROMA 6/10   APPEARANCE 4/5   TASTE 6/10   PALATE 3/5   OVERALL 14/20
drewbeerme (3897) - Chicago, Illinois, USA - APR 21, 2012
Bottle. Thanks Matt. Pours dark reddish brown with foamy beige head. Aroma has Brett, fig, and vanilla. Flavors tart fig, chocolate, toffee. Thin body. Odd beer, seems infected.

3.4
   AROMA 7/10   APPEARANCE 3/5   TASTE 7/10   PALATE 3/5   OVERALL 14/20
jredmond (6151) - Manhattan, New York, USA - APR 19, 2012
Bottle shared with Dallas, Andrew, Maggi, Sts and Brendad. Pours a deep, murky brown body with thin off white lacing. Aroma is smoke, sweet malt, and yeast. Mouthfeel is moderate with notes of smoke, roasted caramel malts, sweet sugar, peat, and wood.

3.9
   AROMA 7/10   APPEARANCE 4/5   TASTE 8/10   PALATE 4/5   OVERALL 16/20
DeputyAndy (636) - Ambler, Pennsylvania, USA - APR 19, 2012
Bottle with James, Andrew, and Maggi. Pours a brown with lots of mocha head. Flavoris great. Peat, smoke, chocolate. Finishes super smooth.

2.3
   AROMA 4/10   APPEARANCE 4/5   TASTE 3/10   PALATE 2/5   OVERALL 10/20
hellbilly (3249) - scottsdale Łber alles, Arizona, USA - APR 14, 2012
bomber 11/25/11. reddish scotch-y brown color with a creamy pale brown head. wow!...it smells and tastes like the infected shortís bottles... peanuts, sour raisins, vinegar and mild malt sugar. sharply carbonated and very un-scotch ale-like...4/4/3/2/10

3.5
   AROMA 7/10   APPEARANCE 4/5   TASTE 6/10   PALATE 4/5   OVERALL 14/20
michael-pollack (4960) - King of Prussia, Pennsylvania, USA - APR 9, 2012
750ml Bottle: Got in trade from Biggsbowler; THANKS Randall. Complex, sweet aroma of malt, dark ripe fruit, a hint of alcohol, raisins, plums, some cherry, and some Belgian yeast. Poured dark brown/very dark orange in color with a medium to large-sized, creamy, dense, brown head that diminished but lasted throughout. Cloudy. Lightly sparkling. Full of tiny particles throughout. Flavor is heavily sweet. Tastes of grape jelly, malt, slight chocolate, slight roasting, slight Belgian yeast, prune, plum, and alcohol. A bit of a peanut-butter and jelly flavor. Medium body. Slightly chalky texture. Soft to average carbonation. Malt, grape jelly, slight alcohol, plum finish is slightly chalky. 9%ABV is noticeable throughout though not hot.

2.5
   AROMA 5/10   APPEARANCE 3/5   TASTE 5/10   PALATE 3/5   OVERALL 9/20
MartinT (8492) - Montreal, Quebec, CANADA - MAR 31, 2012
My Bottom Line:
This puzzling brew shares a mish-mash of sugary and nearly tart flavors, ranging from aniseed, raisins and vinegar, before a charred roastiness rises in the finish.

Further Personal Perceptions:
-A healthy head of foam sits atop the dark red.
-Picklish, acidic connotations are perceived in the aroma. This doesnít bode well for this batch...
-The nose and flavor profile has nothing to do with a Scotch Ale. Moreover, the idea of marrying a Saison yeast with tons of caramel malts is just not a good one, for my palate anyway. I taste no harmony whatsoever in here.
-Intense carbonation does nothing to console the tastebuds.
-I donít know if Iíve been unlucky with Cigar City lately, but thatís quite the string of poorly fermented brews Iíve had from them.

Bottle.

3.5
   AROMA 7/10   APPEARANCE 4/5   TASTE 6/10   PALATE 3/5   OVERALL 15/20
rubbishystuff (1998) - Chicago, Illinois, USA - MAR 25, 2012
UPDATED: JUN 22, 2015 Thanks to Dad for this. Good stuff but a slightly burnt flavor came through and the bitterness was a bit off. Otherwise warming fruity malty goodness. Serving: Bottle

3.6
   AROMA 7/10   APPEARANCE 4/5   TASTE 7/10   PALATE 3/5   OVERALL 15/20
kp (10884) - Woodstock, Georgia, USA - MAR 17, 2012

Date: March 04, 2012
Mode: Bottle
Source: Tasting, Wrecking Bar
Appearance: clear dark brown, fine tan head, drippy lace
Aroma: sweet and fruity aroma, sweetness brings out chocolate
Flavor: rich and fruity flavor, rich chocolate, lots of fruityness
Aroma: 7/10; Appearance: 7/10; Flavor: 7/10; Palate: 6/10; Overall: 15/20
Rating: 3.6/5.0
Drinkability: 7/10
Score: *** /4


We Want To Hear From You



Join us! RateBeer is made by beer enthusiasts for the craft beer community. Your basic membership is free and allows you to read all beer ratings. Click here to create your account... and give your opinion!

Join Us »



Page  1 « 7 8 9  10  11 12 13


Tick this beer

for your profile
  • Currently 0/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Copyright © 2000-2015,
RateBeer LLC. All rights
reserved.
about us
About RateBeer
FAQ
Contact/Feedback
New Beers
add
Advanced Search
Add A Beer
Add A Brewer
Add A Place
Events
membership
Log In
Edit Personal Info
Buy Premium Membership
Your Messages
the best
RateBeer Best
100 Beer Club
The Top 50