grebs (71), Ohio, USA Aug 11, 2009 This beer is not good out of a bottle. It tastes sugary, overly malty, and has a distinct flavor of dirt. On top it is marginally better but by no means great. It really lacks the character and balance you would hop for from a brown ale, but it is a mass produced beer so you can hardly expect perfection. Very thin, too roasted, and way too carbonated. Pass. Herkybird (20), YORK, North Yorkshire, England Aug 9, 2009 Sickenly sweet flavour with masses of caramel malt but almost no hop flavours. Very unpleasant metallic aftertaste from bottle due to excessive carbonation - the gassist beer I have ever tried. Suits the Scottish and North East palate for obnoxiously sweet, malty beers perfectly, but not to my taste at all. TampaBrew (749), Tampa, Florida, USA Aug 8, 2009 Pours a clear Crayola brown. Nose os toasty malt and mild citrus. Flavor is a refreshing malt beverage with some crisp citrus notes. Not a terrible beer by any stretch. I can drink a dozen of these. One of my go-to gas station beers. otakuden (518), Vero Beach, Florida, USA Aug 8, 2009 A long time ago in a land far far away…
It’s been years, literally, since I last supped on a Newcastle Brown Ale from a clear bottle (Why clear?! Why?!) and I am ready to revisit this struggling classic.
After I warily popped the cap on my crystal clear bottle, I poured her equally crystal clear nut brown depths into my classic English nonic glass. A small off-white head fades quickly into bubbly globules and swirls with a surprisingly decent array of lace. As I swirl her unusually bright and clear nutty brown depths, a bouquet of lemon zest, crunchy maple and caramel brittle, shelled nuts, and melba toast burst forth with a helping cinnamon sticks on the side. No skunk to be found which always portends fortune. I’ve said it before and I’ve said it again: clear bottles are the nefarious enemy of all beers. If you happen to come across a bottle of Newcastle and it is sporting a hazy body and what looks like snowflakes, avoid it like the plague. My first un-skunked quaff is light with fresh lemons and a gentle bready background. I am pleasantly surprised with how brisk her palate is. Caramel and maple brittle crunches with each quaff, a perfect pairing with the heavily toasted melba. While our palates mingle, the most vibrant of characters is her dry, nutty, lemony fresh palate that breathes life into the top of my tongue. I was expecting far less than I actually received from my bottled Newcastle Brown Ale, and I better understand now why, at one time, she was one of my favorite English brown ales.
Since I have sailed further into the unknown seas of brown ales, Newcastle has fallen much further down my list. After this most recent of reunions, I am reminded of why she hasn’t fallen completely off the horizons. While she won’t shatter any records or win any awards, she is a solid performer who has struggled valiantly to survive clear glass bottles and mass production on a world-wide scale. txolo (19), Spain Aug 8, 2009 Lovely body, great flavor, intense, I like how it looks, how it smells, a like even the star on the label! GranvilleTim (467), Granville, Illinois, USA Aug 7, 2009 Reddish pour with a white head. Malt aroma, slightly roasted, little sweet. Tastes a little better than the aroma. Easy to drink, little carbonation. An easy to find beer in small areas. slipy120 (64), Michigan, USA Aug 7, 2009 Pours brown with a small frothy head that is fast to dissipate. Not bad for what it is. Many bars have this on tap and it is a better alternative to what your average bar would have on tap. Not great but not bad. An overall good drink for what it is. jmmino08 (3), Oatmeal Stout, New York, USA does not count Aug 7, 2009 Dynamic, articulate, perceptive, couragoues, outspoken, just a few of the adjectives that inadequately describe...NEWCASTLE!
|