scoobyluv (486), Chattanooga, Tennessee, USA May 23, 2008 dark brown color with a cherry smell. it tastes like cherries and alcohol and perfume. not a fan. badgerben (3587), Blaine, Minnesota, USA May 16, 2008 Lost Abbey bottling. Huge thanks to BDR for sharing this! Murky brown/red color with a medium head. Solid aroma of oak and slightly sour cherries. The taste is quite the mix of flavors... The sour and slightly tart cherries fade into a sweet, raisiny malt, all rounded out by light vanilla, oak and bourbon. The bourbon is very moderate; enough to say hello, but not enough to bash you over the head. Wicked good. RollinHard (750), Fort Worth, Texas, USA May 15, 2008 Updated: Jul 14, 2009Pours a very dark brown, slight crimson tinge to it, and a small bubbly tan head that sticks around a while. Upon smelling this, I wonder if there’s anything other than sourness and cherries. I was prepared for something less tart. Eventually, the sourness and cherries give way to a lot of wood, old books, slight bourbon, raisins, and the faintest hint of toasty brown sugar malt. Tastes as tart as the aroma suggest, but not as fruity. There’s a HUGE tannin drying sensation on the tongue. Beyond that, there’s some wood flavor, over-steeped tea. Finishes with lingering hints of vinegar, wood, toast, and red wiine. Strong flavors no doubt, but it’s just so woody dry and a lot more tart than I wanted. Creamy texture medium/full bodied and soft carbonation make this much chewier than any sour ale out there. It’s complex, but I could not get any malt flavors or balancing sweetness from this, so I’m left unsatisfied. Pass me some Judgement Day instead.
Wow, what a difference a different bottling makes! I’ll write more later, but the ’09 bottling is SO much nicer than before. The bourbon, base beer, wild yeast, and sour cherries all exist harmoniously without one dominant characteristic. Score = bumped. pepsican (884), The Student Ghetto, Iowa, USA May 13, 2008 Updated: Jul 7, 2008Dark brown with just a few bubbles floating on top. Aroma is musty bourbon. Flavor was bourbon, musty funk, some wood, cherry. Finishes slightly acidic, clean. Wish this had a bit more of everything.
OK...04 tomme was a completely different story. More everything, perfect acidity. Lots of cantaloupe, cherry, candy, white grapes. Holy hell this is great. 08’ gets a 3.5, 04 got a 4.2. Wow. bhensonb (4189), Woodland, California, USA May 13, 2008 Bottle shared by Marcus. Wonderful sour cherry aroma. Dark brown color with a head that left quickly. Near medium body with mild carbonation. Somewhat woody - like cherry pits. Lots of mild fruit flavors banging around. Perhaps a touch of cola. Extremely pleasant drink. This one could be to die for. after4ever (2711), Brier, Washington, USA May 10, 2008 Draft at Brouwer’s Sourfest. Opaque dark brown with honeyed toffee highlights. Big tart red wine vinegar and oak nose. Mild creamy body. Sharp tart vinegar attack. Oak and funk and vinegar mid-palate. Somehow this completely ties together into a lovelyl, harmonious, approachable, even quenching beer. Lots of dark fruits. Phenomenal. IrishBoy (2686), Bakersfield, California, USA May 7, 2008 Sinner’s Club bottle; Nose of cherries, very light tartness, a molasses note, oakiness, and a very slight butteriness; rusty color with a very slight beige head; flavor is cherries, brown sugar, molasses, and very light tartness. doubleo (1096), San Diego, California, USA May 5, 2008 On-tap at the 2nd Anniversary Party. I had 3 pints. Let me tell you, way too much. Pours dark red brown with minimal to head and no lace. Smells like dark, sour cherries with some dark maltiness as well. Tastes of dark sour cherries and dark sweet malts. Sweet and sour with a good bit of alcohol flavor as well. Medium body, alcohol bite, decent carbonation.
|