RateBeer
   Home Sign Up or Login Advanced Search
   People Ratings Events Places Forums Shop Magazine
      Top By Category  RateBeer Best  Latest Ratings  Top 50    

Southampton Old Herb

Southampton Old Herb - Barley Wine

* picture credits
copyright may apply

 Percentile 
97
overall
Brewed by Southampton Publick House
Style: Barley Wine

Southampton, New York USA

bottling
unknown

on tap
unknown

distribution
unknown

Add Distribution Data
send corrections | shelftag |

 Ratings  Average  Score  Seasonal  ABV  Style Pctl  Serve in 
1933.79/5.03.76/5.0Winter11%83.9Snifter
View Statistics  P 

Commercial Description:
The Southampton Publick House now occupies the space that was once Herb McCarthy's Bowden Square Restaurant. Herb McCarthy's was the place to be in the Hamptons for more than two generations. Those who remember him still speak fondly of "old Herb", who held court at Bowden Square from 1936-1986. He was rarely seen without his Chef's coat and trademark kerchief.
 Most Recent Top Raters Highest Ratings Who's Rated This?  
 wunderbier (1264), Tampere, Finland
3.8 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
9/103/57/104/515/20
Jul 3, 2004  
12 oz bottle, snifter, #411 of 500. Cookie, caramel, toffee, toasted malt (H); flower and orange hops (M); light alcohol, pear, peach and brown sugar aromas. Average, creamy, off-white, lasting head is on a murky/cloudy, dark red-brown body. Heavily sweet, lightly acidic flavor becomes a moderately sweet, lightly acidic, moderately bitter finish with a sour/salty tang. Medium-ful body, creamy/slick texture, lively carbonation, metallic aftertaste. The bottom line is: strange tinny aftertaste, but that’s the only fault...could have used a little more complexity in the flavor.


 harlequinn (2745), Tacoma, Washington, USA
4 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
9/104/58/104/515/20
Jul 3, 2004  
Hazy amber appearance, with an amazing malty aroma that just reaches out and slaps you in the face, and take control of your nasal passages. Also quite citric, with a very zesty tangerine peel scent. The hop profile is also very interesting to me in the aroma. The mouthfeel is slightly thin then turns creamy with a bad aftertaste that is slightly metallic, salty and sweet and almost cola like. Flavor is still very nice and not overly complex. Very silky with some nice fresh lively acidity. Sugary soda sweetness in the finish, but still very very good.


 BückDich (4793), McCall, Idaho, USA
3.7 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
9/103/57/104/514/20
Jun 30, 2004  
Dark mahogany brown, low carbonation & lacing. The aroma has some molasses & sweet brown sugar. Sweet hops & lots of malts with sugar plums. The flavor has a good dose of dry sweetness & some alcohol, almost too much tang and seetness though. I don’t know where the herb comes from but this isn’t bad, lots of alcohol feel though. Thanks to <A HREF=http://www.ratebeer.com/ViewUser.asp?UserID=12798>DomiNate for the birthday beers!


 Eyedrinkale (3209), Astoria, New York, USA
4.2 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
7/104/58/105/518/20
Jun 20, 2004  
Cask, draft and vintage bottled versions. I have to say this stuff kicks ass. So nicely balanced without the big malt or alcohol taste that I get from most barleywines. I have to say I like the ’03 version most.


 CaptainCougar (5379), Rockville, Maryland, USA
3.7 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
8/103/57/104/515/20
Jun 14, 2004  
Year 2003, bottle 203: Thanks to Goldtwins for the bottle. Pours a dark murky copper brown with a thin cream-colored ring of foam. Aroma is full of caramel and butterscotch with a mild hop balance. Sweet syrupy malty body has lots of caramel flavor and touch of hops with a more bittering powerfully alcoholic finish. Very reminiscent of a young Thomas Hardys, a nice English barleywine.


 mkobes (2103), paramus, New Jersey, USA
3.9 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
7/105/57/105/515/20
Jun 13, 2004    Updated: Mar 11, 2005
2005 bottle. Bought at Half Time Beverage. Nice citrus aroma. Yeast nose and some hops. Malty and hoppy. Well balanced beer. Caramel notes. Roasty. Malty flavor. Smooth. Nice and warming character. Drinkable beer.


 MaiBockAddict (1499), Good Beer Bar Deprived, New Jersey, USA
4 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
7/105/58/105/515/20
Jun 13, 2004    Updated: Mar 11, 2005
Bottle 291, 2005. Orange, clear, tan head. Floral malty aroma, with hints of ripe fruit. Big sticky malty flavor with gentle hop flavor and aroma. This is English in style and very well done.

Bottle # 16 from 2004. This pisses me off. Infected and very disdappointing. Lactic aroma. Sour flavor, with yeast notes and some hops. Bottles purchased at Half Time Beverage. I also have # 19. This is deserving of its low rating for the infection. I expect better from pros. 4-2-4-3-5


 ChazyRPh (571), Chazy, New York, USA
3.3 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
6/105/55/104/513/20
Jun 1, 2004  
Vintage 2002, bottle #94 of 500. Pour is reminiscent of fresh apple cider. Very cloudy with very little head. Fruity sour alcoholic nose, aroma is quite harsh. Start is harsh also, strong alcohol with some carbonation in the middle. The finish is hoppy with a strange bitterness in the end. I don’t know if the name is skewing my senses, but I detect a definate herb presence in the finish. Definately not a barley wine for beginners.



CONSIDER FREE RATEBEER MEMBERSHIP



Join us! RateBeer is made by beer enthusiasts for the craft beer community. Your basic membership is free and allows you to read all beer ratings. Click here to create your account... and give your opinion!

SIGN UP NOW »

View Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

What's Your Opinion?
Tell us what you think of this beer. Start your free RateBeer account now.
» Click here.

More Barley Wines

Lost Abbey The Angels Share (Bourbon Barrel) (4.2)

AleSmith Barrel Aged Old Numbskull (4.14)

Lost Abbey The Angels Share (4.1)

Three Floyds Behemoth Barleywine (4.09)

Kuhnhenn Bourbon Barrel Barley Wine (4.06)

Hair of the Dog Fred from the Wood (4.06)

Victory Old Horizontal (4.04)

AleSmith Old Numbskull (4.03)

Hair of the Dog Doggie Claws (2003-) (4.02)

Flossmoor Station Wooden Hell (3.99)

Marin Old Dipsea Bourbon Barrel Aged Barleywine Style Ale (3.98)

Barley Johns Barrel-Aged Rosies Ale (Batch 2) (3.98)

Midnight Sun Arctic Devil Barley Wine (3.98)

Three Floyds Bourbon Behemoth (3.97)

Third Coast Old Ale (3.97)


About RateBeer | Add A Beer | Add A Brewer | Edit Personal Info | 100 Beer Club | FAQ | Log out | Feedback? | Copyright 2000-2009, RateBeer LLC