RateBeer
   Home Sign Up or Login Advanced Search
   People Ratings Events Places Forums Shop Magazine
      Top By Category  RateBeer Best  Latest Ratings  Top 50    

Southampton Old Herb

Southampton Old Herb - Barley Wine

* picture credits
copyright may apply

 Percentile 
97
overall
Brewed by Southampton Publick House
Style: Barley Wine

Southampton, New York USA

bottling
unknown

on tap
unknown

distribution
unknown

Add Distribution Data
send corrections | shelftag |

 Ratings  Average  Score  Seasonal  ABV  Style Pctl  Serve in 
1933.79/5.03.76/5.0Winter11%83.9Snifter
View Statistics  P 

Commercial Description:
The Southampton Publick House now occupies the space that was once Herb McCarthy's Bowden Square Restaurant. Herb McCarthy's was the place to be in the Hamptons for more than two generations. Those who remember him still speak fondly of "old Herb", who held court at Bowden Square from 1936-1986. He was rarely seen without his Chef's coat and trademark kerchief.
 Most Recent Top Raters Highest Ratings Who's Rated This?  
 JPDIPSO (4865), Wauwatosa, Wisconsin, USA
3.8 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
8/103/57/104/516/20
Jun 1, 2004  
(2004,Bottle # 414) hazed cloudy amber color with a small lid of light tan bubbles. Heavy caramel and sweet malt aromas, balanced with a touch of grapefruit hops. Initial tropical fruit flavors including pineapple, papaya, along with plums and plunes. Middle has dry orange pine and light oak. Finishes with pepper and alcohol, with a palate biting bitterness. Me thinks I was a bit impatient with this one, but I really did not want to wait for next winter. Warming, A light linger of malt and cinnamon.


 JoeM500 (1876), Chicago (little italy), Illinois, USA
4.2 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
9/104/58/104/517/20
Jun 1, 2004  
2004 bottle #432. Beautiful dark broze color with thick off-white head, great lacing and head retention. Powerful malty aroma with hints of alcohol, caramel, tobacco, strong hops. Complex taste never got too sweet or too alcoholic, nutty and bitter at the finish. Alcohol was at the perfect level, making it’s presence known but never overpowering the complexity of the beer. Aftertaste was caramelly after the dryness wore off. Another awesome beer from this brewer!!!


 Dorwart (1807), Robbinsville, New Jersey, USA
3.4 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
8/103/57/103/513/20
May 31, 2004  
Vintage 2002 Batch # 478. Thin head with little carbonation. Big caramel aroma with hops, malt and toffee. Color is a murky brown. Flavor is thick and syrupy with a strong alcohol kick. Tons of malts and a touch of hops. More caramel and sweetness. Finish is thick and coating and warms nicely as it goes down. A decent barleywine but could use some more hops to offset the the thick malt palate and alcohol.


 Jeppe (2638), Ølbutikken, Denmark
3.7 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
8/103/57/104/515/20
May 30, 2004  
Bottle #289. Fast disappearing light tan head on a hazy amber/orange body. Strong aroma of hop, fruit, nut, caramel and vanilla. Flavor is sweet malty with notes of caramel and chocolate with a spicy undertone. Somewhat bitter and dry. Thanks to austinpowers for giving me this as an extra bonus in a trade!!


 DYCSoccer17 (2187), Davis, California, USA
4.1 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
8/104/58/104/517/20
May 23, 2004    Updated: Dec 7, 2006
2002 Vintage. Bottle #94 out of 500. Fruity aroma, vinous and smells more like an SN Bigfoot and less malts in the nose than the just recently sampled Newport Storm ’02. Tiny head, murky cider-like appearance. Smooth citrusy bouquet to start. Pleasant alcohol burn. Not nearly as complex as the Newport Storm ’02 we just had. Good nonetheless.(7/4/7/4/15 3.7)-----re-rating----2004 bottle #409 (12/7/06). Very aromatic, vinous, pleasant, light oxidation. Murky amber color with small off-yellow head. Flavor is perfect. Vinous, sweet, mellow light oxidized flavors. Hops are definitely mellowed. Flavorful, extremely drinkable. Alcohol is non-apparent. If you have a 2004 bottle, DRINK IT NOW!!! (9/3/9/5/18 4.5) Overall score represents average of 2 vintages.


 argo0 (6861), Washington DC, USA
3.9 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
9/104/57/104/515/20
May 10, 2004  
(2004, bottle #431) Hazy copper body topped by a small beige head. Aroma is first and foremost that which I associate with barleywine. Individual components include medium sweet, caramel, plum/raisin, grapefruit, some orange peel, vanilla, alcohol. Taste is medium sweet, caramel/toffee, grapefruit, some herbal/spice. The finish is grapefruit and some pine, along with medium alcohol warming. Medium-full body, some stickiness. Good stuff.


 Ungstrup (14762), Frederiksberg, Denmark
4.1 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
8/103/58/104/518/20
May 9, 2004  
[Bottle 289 - the one pictured] An unclear dark red beer with no head. The aroma is sweet with notes of hops, grass, and alcohol. The flavor is sweet and very hoppy and grassy, so much that it bites the tongue. A very nice beer. Thanks to Jeppe (Bierkönig) for sharing this bottle.


 Hildigöltur (5109), København, Denmark
3.7 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
7/103/58/104/515/20
May 6, 2004  
Bottle no. 289, the one on the picture! <--. Amber coloured. Vanilla in the aroma. Sweet and hoppy flavour with a very bitter finish. Thanks Jeppe.



CONSIDER FREE RATEBEER MEMBERSHIP



Join us! RateBeer is made by beer enthusiasts for the craft beer community. Your basic membership is free and allows you to read all beer ratings. Click here to create your account... and give your opinion!

SIGN UP NOW »

View Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

What's Your Opinion?
Tell us what you think of this beer. Start your free RateBeer account now.
» Click here.

More Barley Wines

Lost Abbey The Angels Share (Bourbon Barrel) (4.2)

AleSmith Barrel Aged Old Numbskull (4.14)

Lost Abbey The Angels Share (4.1)

Three Floyds Behemoth Barleywine (4.09)

Kuhnhenn Bourbon Barrel Barley Wine (4.06)

Hair of the Dog Fred from the Wood (4.06)

Victory Old Horizontal (4.04)

AleSmith Old Numbskull (4.03)

Hair of the Dog Doggie Claws (2003-) (4.02)

Flossmoor Station Wooden Hell (3.99)

Marin Old Dipsea Bourbon Barrel Aged Barleywine Style Ale (3.98)

Barley Johns Barrel-Aged Rosies Ale (Batch 2) (3.98)

Midnight Sun Arctic Devil Barley Wine (3.98)

Three Floyds Bourbon Behemoth (3.97)

Third Coast Old Ale (3.97)


About RateBeer | Add A Beer | Add A Brewer | Edit Personal Info | 100 Beer Club | FAQ | Log out | Feedback? | Copyright 2000-2009, RateBeer LLC