RateBeer
   Home Sign Up or Login Advanced Search
   People Ratings Events Places Forums Shop Magazine
      Top By Category  RateBeer Best  Latest Ratings  Top 50    

Southampton Old Herb

Southampton Old Herb - Barley Wine

* picture credits
copyright may apply

 Percentile 
97
overall
Brewed by Southampton Publick House
Style: Barley Wine

Southampton, New York USA

bottling
unknown

on tap
unknown

distribution
unknown

Add Distribution Data
send corrections | shelftag |

 Ratings  Average  Score  Seasonal  ABV  Style Pctl  Serve in 
1933.79/5.03.76/5.0Winter11%83.9Snifter
View Statistics  P 

Commercial Description:
The Southampton Publick House now occupies the space that was once Herb McCarthy's Bowden Square Restaurant. Herb McCarthy's was the place to be in the Hamptons for more than two generations. Those who remember him still speak fondly of "old Herb", who held court at Bowden Square from 1936-1986. He was rarely seen without his Chef's coat and trademark kerchief.
 Most Recent Top Raters Highest Ratings Who's Rated This?  
 travita (1861), Frisco, Texas, USA
3.8 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
7/103/58/104/516/20
Apr 6, 2008  
Amber in color not a whole lot of head. Thick nice feel in the body of the beer. Nice alcohol warmth. Toffee and caramel. Touch of hops at the end.


 bu11zeye (5430), Frisco, Texas, USA
3.8 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
8/103/58/104/515/20
Apr 3, 2008  
(Bottle #454, 2005 vintage) Pours a cloudy amber body with a spare bubbly head. Aroma of biscuit, caramel, plastic, cherry, and oak. Flavor of bread, toffee, caramel malt, light spruce/herbal, and cherry.


 Swalden28 (1440), McKinney, Texas, USA
3.7 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
8/103/57/104/515/20
Mar 18, 2008  
Thanks to bu11zeye, Poured a cloudy amber with off white head. Flavor was sweet and malty with a slight bitter with nice soft alcohole spice. Very nice.


 Glouglouburp (2778), Montreal, Quebec, Canada
3.4 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
6/103/57/104/514/20
Feb 25, 2008  
In short: A whole lot of malt sweetness with some alcohol. Good beer, below average barley wine.
How: 2003 and 2004 bottles, tasting session with Montreal crew
The look: Cloudy amber body with a medium beige head
In long: Pleasant body with lots of caramel, butterscotch and toffee. A bit sugary. Might be the age but I thought the hopping was way too shy. A little dry grass in the finish but not nearly enough to balance it. Alcohol is apparent but feels a little less than 11%. Overall this is a pleasant sipper for those with a sweet tooth. But this is a small barley wine that doesn’t measure up with the legion of big american barley wines, so small in fact that that it can fit in little 250ml bottles.


 IEBAILI (123), San Diego, California, USA
3.6 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
8/103/56/104/515/20
Feb 3, 2008  
Murky brown beer, even with a hard pour I could barely work up any froth on this one. Smell is powerful and pretty enticing malt, brown sugar, dried fruit, caramel and a tough of spice - cinnamon? Taste is strong and malty, not too sweet, a bit hot but not unpleasant, a touch of citrus and bitterness, rich warm feeling from the lush texture. The finish seems a bit peppery, or is that just a slight alcohol burn? A well made barley wine, but for me this style just doen’t deliver as much enjoyment as others, the flavor always seems to be a bit hidden by alcohol.


 fiulijn (7150), Como; Lausanne (CH); Malmö (SWE), Italy
4.3 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
8/104/59/105/517/20
Jan 13, 2008  
Hazy amber color. Powerful malty aroma, with caramel, wood, light apples and lately some alcohol too. Good body strength, with powerful malty flavor and caramel/toffee, strong bitterness too; well balanced; the alcohol warms the mouth just a bit. The final too is well balanced, with a lot of sticky sugars and enough bitterness. Excellent.


 adrian910ss (1395), philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
4 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
8/104/58/104/516/20
Jan 10, 2008  
2005 vintage. #430/500. Pours a dark caramel color with a small foamy beige head. Unfiltered. Aroma of candied sugar, Sugar Daddy candy, caramel, and malt. Taste of caramel, candied malt, brown sugar, toffee and somewhat of a grapefruit hoppy flavor. A very nice barleywine.


 jsquire (2087), St. Marys, Ohio, USA
3.2 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
5/103/56/103/515/20
Dec 31, 2007  
2005 vintage, bottle 134 of 500. Murky orange brown color with a short lived cream colored head that quickly shrank to a ring. The aroma is marred by an oddly medicinal minty note, coupled with lots of alcohol. Flavors of raisen, candied grapefruit rind, toffee, toast, vanilla, some ash, and lots of alcohol in the finish. Not the blended depth of flavors that I like from the best Barley Wines, and this may be suffering from following the ’03 Doggie Claws, but it just didn’t seem that great.



CONSIDER FREE RATEBEER MEMBERSHIP



Join us! RateBeer is made by beer enthusiasts for the craft beer community. Your basic membership is free and allows you to read all beer ratings. Click here to create your account... and give your opinion!

SIGN UP NOW »

View Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

What's Your Opinion?
Tell us what you think of this beer. Start your free RateBeer account now.
» Click here.

More Barley Wines

Lost Abbey The Angels Share (Bourbon Barrel) (4.2)

AleSmith Barrel Aged Old Numbskull (4.14)

Lost Abbey The Angels Share (4.1)

Three Floyds Behemoth Barleywine (4.09)

Kuhnhenn Bourbon Barrel Barley Wine (4.06)

Hair of the Dog Fred from the Wood (4.06)

Victory Old Horizontal (4.04)

AleSmith Old Numbskull (4.03)

Hair of the Dog Doggie Claws (2003-) (4.02)

Flossmoor Station Wooden Hell (3.99)

Marin Old Dipsea Bourbon Barrel Aged Barleywine Style Ale (3.98)

Barley Johns Barrel-Aged Rosies Ale (Batch 2) (3.98)

Midnight Sun Arctic Devil Barley Wine (3.98)

Three Floyds Bourbon Behemoth (3.97)

Third Coast Old Ale (3.97)


About RateBeer | Add A Beer | Add A Brewer | Edit Personal Info | 100 Beer Club | FAQ | Log out | Feedback? | Copyright 2000-2009, RateBeer LLC