RateBeer
   Home Sign Up or Login Advanced Search
   People Ratings Events Places Forums Shop Magazine
      Top By Category  RateBeer Best  Latest Ratings  Top 50    

Home > Brewers > New York > Southampton Publick House >

Southampton Old Herb

Southampton Old Herb

* picture credits
copyright may apply

 Percentile 
96
overall
A Barley Wine brewed by
Southampton Publick House

Southampton, New York USA

bottled
common

on tap
unknown

Regional Distribution
Find this beer

Add Distribution Data
Send Corrections

 Ratings  Average  Score  Seasonal  ABV  Style Pctl  Serve in  Advanced 
1883.78/5.03.77/5.0Winter11%78.1 Snifter P  Stats

Commercial Description:
The Southampton Publick House now occupies the space that was once Herb McCarthy's Bowden Square Restaurant. Herb McCarthy's was the place to be in the Hamptons for more than two generations. Those who remember him still speak fondly of "old Herb", who held court at Bowden Square from 1936-1986. He was rarely seen without his Chef's coat and trademark kerchief.

Most RecentTop RatersHighest Ratings Who's Rated This?
 stoutlover72 (1314), NorCal, California, USA
3.5 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
7/104/57/103/514/20

May 8, 2008  
2006 vintage - I’ve had this beer stored for quite awhile now. In fact I forgot about the darned thing for so long, it was hidden behind several other taller bottles on my shelf so in a weekend of shuffling things around I saw it and thought...let’s drink!

The beer pours out a hazy reddish/brown (rust water) color with a two-finger thick head. Aromas were herbal/spicy hops, vegetative with some molasses-like notes. Flavor of stale malts, veggies with a strong toffee-candy finish. No notice of the alcohol, which was nice. Decent English barleywine, but nothing special.


 GAManiac (217), Atlanta, Georgia, USA
3.9 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
7/104/58/104/516/20
Jul 20, 2008  
2006 bottle, #255/500. Pours a super hazy orange amber with only a minimal head even with an aggressive pour. The head dissipates to a collar quickly leaving traces of lacing. The smell is really boozy, mainly rum, with some brown sugar and toffee in the nose as well. There is also the faintest hint of hops in the background. The taste is also sugary sweet with brown sugar and caramel malts with vanilla and some spices as well. The mouthfeel is full and super smooth with low carbonation. I’ve never had this one fresh, but I really enjoyed this beer and I imagine I probably caught it at about the right age. Thanks again to Steve for pulling this out of the cellar for me!


 thenick (509), North Bellmore, New York, USA
4 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
8/104/58/104/516/20
Jul 17, 2008  
Bottle - 2006 Vintage, many thanks to Brady from SPH for this one. Pours a bronze/amber color with a fluffy white head. Aroma is heavy spice and malt, with notes of chocolate, ginger,and candi sugar noticeable. Taste is spice as well, with ginger and candi sugar noticeable. There is a slight alcohol burn at the end, but it is very well hidden for a beer with this high an ABV. I sipped on this beer for a good long time, and it provided a very enjoyable experience.


 Brigadier (829), Chagrin Falls, Ohio, USA
3.8 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
7/104/58/104/515/20
Jul 15, 2008  
12 oz bottle

This came as a bonus in a long ago trade. I figured with three years on it the time was right to crack open the bottle (#264 of 500). I was not disappointed. My only regret is that because of the limited release it is going to be tough to track down another bottle barring a new batch being produced.

Aroma / Appearance - The carbonated bronze body sparkled as carbonation streamed up the sides of my snifter. A dense eggshell colored head left sticky trails of lacing as it receded into the viscous liquid below. The aroma was a bit stale but reminded me of ginger snap cookies, semisweet chocolate and caramel. It was a very mellow experience with little aggression.

Flavor / Palate - The warmth from the ABV is obvious at the start. It carries along with it caramel, molasses and vanilla. Hershey’s chocolate is next before a transition to a chocolately wheat finish. The mellowness shows here as well in the form of a very laid back sippable beer. You won’t be sessioning this one. It may be a little past its prime but not having had an earlier bottle it is hard to say for sure.


 Rciesla (712), Brick City, New Jersey, USA
3.9 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
7/105/57/104/516/20
Jul 8, 2008  
Bottle from SHPH. Pours an amber brown body with a light head. Sweet caramel candi sugar, some dark plum, a bit chewy some etoh and raisins. Real good with the 2 years on it.


 kramer17801 (1846), sunbury, Pennsylvania, USA
2.8 Aroma Appearance Flavor Palate Overall
7/103/56/102/510/20
Jun 28, 2008  
12 oz bottle, 2005 vintage, via jsquire. Pours a very ruddy and murky dark amber after gushing out of the bottle a bit. Light brown head that left lots of sticky lacing. Heavy toffee malt with a good bit of resiny hop for an 05 beer. A lot of paper like oxidation and brown sugar. The flavor doesn’t seem to be all there though. The toffee malt and fruitiness are overtaken by the papery oxidation and it’s a little thinned out. Light bitterness on the rather short cardboardy finish. Mouthfeel is thinner than expected with moderate fizzy carbonation. It just feels limp and tired. Sadly, this bottle did not age well at all. Bummer.




WOULD YOU LIKE TO READ MORE RATINGS?
Then join us! RateBeer is made by beer enthusiasts for the craft beer community. Your basic membership is free and allows you to read all beer ratings.

Desired User Name
*
Valid Email (Needed to verify your account)
*
Relax. RateBeer is 100%, guaranteed spam-free. That's our promise to you.

I agree to the terms of the RateBeer User Agreement

RATE THIS BEER

Aroma

rating assistance

Appearance

rating assistance

Flavor

rating assistance

Palate

rating assistance

Overall impression

rating assistance

TOTAL SCORE

Comments

More Barley Wines

Hair of the Dog Dave (4.46)

Lost Abbey The Angels Share (4.28)

Lost Abbey The Angels Share (Bourbon Barrel) (4.26)

North Coast Old Stock Cellar Reserve Brandy Barrel (4.18)

AleSmith Barrel Aged Old Numbskull (4.16)

21st Amendment Bourbon Barrel Lower da Boom Barleywine (4.13)

Three Floyds Behemoth Barleywine (4.11)

Kuhnhenn Bourbon Barrel Barley Wine (4.08)

Hair of the Dog Fred from the Wood (4.08)

Barley Johns Barrel-Aged Rosies Ale (Batch 2) (4.07)

More New York Brewers

Applewood Winery
  Warwick
Great Adirondack Brewing Co.
  Lake Placid
Greenpoint Beer Works
  Brooklyn
Brooklyn Brewery
  Brooklyn
Dalton''s Bar & Grill
  New York
Wagner Valley Brewing Company
  Lodi
Rooster Fish Brewing
  Watkins Glen
BrickHouse Brewery & Restaurant
  Patchogue
Empire Brewing Company
  Syracuse
Horseheads Brewing, Inc.
  Horseheads
Olde Saratoga Brewing (Mendocino Brewing Co.)
  Saratoga Springs
Skytop Brewery and Steakhouse
  Kingston
Black Forest Brew Haus
  Farmingdale
Defiant Brewing Company
  Pearl River
Buffalo Brewpub
  Williamsville

About RateBeer | Add A Beer | Add A Brewer | Edit Personal Info | 100 Beer Club | FAQ | Log out | Feedback? | Copyright 2000-2008, RateBeer LLC