| Old Mill Stout - Imperial | 10 | 8/19/2017 | Rate | | | 0 |
| Old Mill 12-Mile Oatmeal Porter Porter | 6.4 | 4/8/2014 | Rate | 3.15 | | 5 |
| Old Mill Anthracite 9 Double Stout Stout | 9.2 | 5/30/2017 | Rate | 3.04 | | 2 |
| Old Mill Bale Breaker 2.0 IIPA DIPA - Imperial / Double IPA | 8.0 | 3/16/2017 | Rate | 3.16 | | 2 |
| Old Mill Bale Breaker Double IPA IIPA DIPA - Imperial / Double IPA | 9.0 | 4/8/2014 | Rate | 3.16 | | 2 |
| Old Mill Bourbon 12-Mile Oatmeal Porter Porter | 7.5 | 4/8/2014 | Rate | | | 0 |
| Old Mill Bourbon Barrel Aged Smoked Imperial Porter Porter - Imperial | 8.1 | 12/12/2016 | Rate | 3.11 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Bourbon Peach Wild Native Saison Saison / Farmhouse / Grisette | 6.7 | 12/12/2016 | Rate | | | 0 |
| Old Mill Brewpub Irish Red Red Ale - Irish | 6.0 | 1/22/2024 | Rate | 2.87 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Brewpub Lederhosen Grapefruit Bavarian Wheat Wheat Ale | 3.8 | 1/28/2024 | Rate | 2.92 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Citrix Wheat Wheat Ale | 4.5 | 7/10/2014 | Rate | 2.81 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Comet Rider Session IPA IPA | 5.0 | 5/30/2017 | Rate | 3 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Cookies and Cream Milk Stout Stout - Milk / Sweet | 6.1 | 10/22/2019 | Rate | 3 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Day Of The Dead Belgian Ale - Strong Pale | 7.8 | 11/3/2014 | Rate | 2.91 | | 2 |
| Old Mill Erosion Control IPA IPA | 6.5 | 1/21/2024 | Rate | 2.87 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Feathered Serpant Stout - Imperial | 10 | 8/19/2017 | Rate | 3.09 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Festbier 2015 Märzen / Oktoberfest Bier | 5.5 | 8/31/2015 | Rate | 2.92 | | 1 |
| Old Mill German Chocolate Cake Imperial Stout Stout - Imperial | 8.1 | 1/21/2024 | Rate | 3.11 | | 1 |
| Old Mill High Water Mark IIPA DIPA - Imperial / Double IPA | 11.6 | 3/16/2017 | Rate | 2.95 | | 2 |
| Old Mill Hoptimize Strong Ale Strong Ale - American | 7.3 | 12/12/2016 | Rate | 3.02 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Lexington Light Pale Lager - American | 4.0 | 12/12/2016 | Rate | 2.92 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Lost World DIPA IIPA DIPA - Imperial / Double IPA | 8.3 | 11/3/2014 | Rate | 2.87 | | 2 |
| Old Mill Maple 90-Shilling Scottish Ale Scottish Ale | 9.2 | 12/12/2016 | Rate | 3.13 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Mayan Cookies and Cream Stout Flavored - Other | 6.7 | 12/14/2016 | Rate | 3.17 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Miles Finch Belgian Ale - Strong Pale | 8.7 | 1/22/2024 | Rate | 2.89 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Occaneechi Golden Pale Ale Pale Ale - American (APA) | 5.2 | 4/8/2014 | Rate | 2.87 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Off The Grid IPA IPA | 7.6 | 4/8/2014 | Rate | 2.89 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Peanut Butter Stout Stout | 7.8 | 7/12/2014 | Rate | 2.79 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Pineapple Kölsch Flavored - Fruit | 5.5 | 5/28/2014 | Rate | 2.72 | | 2 |
| Old Mill Quilted Kilt Wee Heavy Scottish Red Scotch Ale / Wee Heavy | 8.5 | 4/8/2014 | Rate | | | 0 |
| Old Mill Salted Bourbon Maple Bacon Porter Porter | 6.8 | 8/31/2015 | Rate | 3.02 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Silas Sour / Wild Beer | 6.4 | 3/16/2017 | Rate | 3.04 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Spillway IPA IPA | 5.4 | 7/10/2014 | Rate | 2.81 | | 1 |
| Old Mill The Ghost In The Mill IPA - Hazy (NEIPA) | 7.0 | 1/23/2024 | Rate | 2.81 | | 1 |
| Old Mill Turbine Stout Stout | 4.9 | 4/8/2014 | Rate | | | 0 |
| Old Mill Way Off The Grid IPA IPA | 6.0 | 11/3/2014 | Rate | 2.81 | | 2 |
| Old Mill Weiss Geist Wit Witbier / Belgian White Ale | 5.5 | 4/8/2014 | Rate | | | 0 |
| Old Mill Wild Native Saison Saison / Farmhouse / Grisette | 6.7 | 12/12/2016 | Rate | 3.09 | | 1 |
