Bogus/Fake place reviews

Reads 5216 • Replies 62 • Started Monday, December 22, 2014 7:26:42 PM CT

The forums you're viewing are the static, archived version. You won't be able to post or reply here.
Our new, modern forums are here:
RateBeer Forums

Thread Frozen
 
Marko
admin
beers 17703 º places 866 º 12:41 Sat 12/27/2014

The admin’s aren’t omniscient and omnipresent. If you see somehting that looks really suspicious, send in a bug report. If it doesn’t get settled immediately, it’s likely being discussed and we’ll get to it.

Being a member and complaining about fake users and raters without pointing anyone/anything out is helping nobody. :/

 
weihenweizen
beers 6989 º places 700 º 12:51 Sat 12/27/2014

Do you really want me to send you a message every time I see a fake user?
Obvious Example: erhead64

 
weihenweizen
beers 6989 º places 700 º 12:55 Sat 12/27/2014

This dude: map816

 
weihenweizen
beers 6989 º places 700 º 12:59 Sat 12/27/2014

This guy: cisco_kid. Please tell me to stop.

 
weihenweizen
beers 6989 º places 700 º 13:15 Sat 12/27/2014

jfpython, alexmuckler, and cvon356. All of these guys are just the blatant fakes which reviewed one place.

 
Marko
admin
beers 17703 º places 866 º 13:17 Sat 12/27/2014

No, do continue, list every single one you know of.

Also, erhead64 is legit. Her "contribution" to the site might be a single, perhaps overblown, wordless rating but the person is legit. Logging in once, giving a slightly bloated, useless rating and never logging in again is not illegal.

The only real problem with that is that every place rating counts.

 
weihenweizen
beers 6989 º places 700 º 13:46 Sat 12/27/2014

ASparks, this dude rated a place he works at it seems. The guy is probably legit, but I don’t think RB allows people to rate where they work.

 
Marko
admin
beers 17703 º places 866 º 13:49 Sat 12/27/2014

Almost, everyone’s a legit local person (only cisco_kid is suspect) with no clear direct relations to Sergio’s, apart from cvon356, and that link’s a stretch.

Those are shit reviews, annoying, but, again, technically legit. For now.

 
Marko
admin
beers 17703 º places 866 º 13:53 Sat 12/27/2014

Originally posted by weihenweizen
ASparks, this dude rated a place he works at it seems. The guy is probably legit, but I don’t think RB allows people to rate where they work.


Rating deleted, user warned. Thanks!

 
weihenweizen
beers 6989 º places 700 º 13:54 Sat 12/27/2014

Originally posted by Marko
Almost, everyone’s a legit local person (only cisco_kid is suspect) with no clear direct relations to Sergio’s, apart from cvon356, and that link’s a stretch.

Those are shit reviews, annoying, but, again, technically legit. For now.


If all these are considered ’legit’ place ratings. I would recommend the admins reconsider what is a legit place rating. I think most people would consider these bogus place rates or may be nobody else cares.