RateBeer
home Home > Forums >
Beer Talk | Site News | Beer Trade | Beer Travel | Food/Beer | For Sale | New Here | Homebrew | Non-US | Industry | OT - Lite | OT - Medium

Fake Westvleteren?


read 12324 times • 65 replies • posted 6/14/2011 11:36:36 AM

Thread Frozen
Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7

premium
RD400F 177:3
Well, if you live in Vancouver BC and donít know already, you can pick up "Westvleteren 12" and "8" at Brewery Creek and Firefly, albeit for astronomical prices.

The question is...are they the real deal?

I threw out $50 like a kid in a candy store yesterday on three bottles...two 12 and one 8, intending to try a 12 and an 8 and cellar the last 12. I whipped a 12 open, poured it into a trappist glass, etc., and wasnít too impressed.

The reason I say that is because it reminded me of a Rochefort 8 a bit too much. In fact, it made me doubt whether or not it was real because the similarity was way too close for my liking. Not only that, but it seemed to me like it was missing something and itís...boozy...even though many have mentioned magical transparency. Maybe Iím taking it too literally? If this is the real meal deal, then itís definitely way over hyped. Itís very nice, but not spectacular.

Anyway, has anyone else here in Vancouver picked one up and tried it, only to come to the same conclusion? I lost sleep because of this.
Private message Send the author a private message


CapFlu 4469:204
We had a 24 show up yesterday at Cascadia Liquors in Victoria. The Westy12 are selling for $16 each; while the Westy8 was $15.

When I opened it and first sampled the Westy12 - "I donít remember this tasting so much like Trois Pistoles".

Iíd love to know if it isnít authentic as I have another 5 bottles cellaring.

The caps are real. Anyone know if the bottles are the same ones used? And most importantly, the contents?

The last time I sampled a Westy12 was circa 2003 so I donít have much memory to compare to...
6/14/2011 11:42:59 AM

Private message send the author a private message


premium
JoeMcPhee 8314:502
Who was the importer? That would be a huge coup to bring that in through legal channels. Iíve seen Westy in several different types of glass, so itís hard to know what is authentic. Maybe post a picture and see if people can help you out.
6/14/2011 11:44:56 AM

Private message send the author a private message


premium
RD400F 177:3
Originally posted by CapFlu
We had a 24 show up yesterday at Cascadia Liquors in Victoria. The Westy12 are selling for $16 each; while the Westy8 was $15.

When I opened it and first sampled the Westy12 - "I donít remember this tasting so much like Trois Pistoles".

Iíd love to know if it isnít authentic as I have another 5 bottles cellaring.

The caps are real. Anyone know if the bottles are the same ones used? And most importantly, the contents?

The last time I sampled a Westy12 was circa 2003 so I donít have much memory to compare to...
I thought Iíd be crazy to mention the caps, but if you compare to those on the net...they donít look real.

Iím aware thereís several revisions, but look at the colour...itís more of a dull gold, not yellow like the real ones.

And, yeah, the bottles are identical to the Westmalle. Apparently Peacock and Martin were responsible for importing these after visiting the abbey, but now I wonder if they were really imported at all. How many people get to see the inside of that place? Not many...why were they allowed?

So many questions.
6/14/2011 11:47:08 AM

Private message send the author a private message


premium
douglas88 5812:204
Those are low prices for the cost of bringing them in which would almost certainly be without the Breweryís support.
6/14/2011 11:47:59 AM

Private message send the author a private message


premium
phredrik 1010:31
Originally posted by RD400F
Originally posted by CapFlu
We had a 24 show up yesterday at Cascadia Liquors in Victoria. The Westy12 are selling for $16 each; while the Westy8 was $15.

When I opened it and first sampled the Westy12 - "I donít remember this tasting so much like Trois Pistoles".

Iíd love to know if it isnít authentic as I have another 5 bottles cellaring.

The caps are real. Anyone know if the bottles are the same ones used? And most importantly, the contents?

The last time I sampled a Westy12 was circa 2003 so I donít have much memory to compare to...
I thought Iíd be crazy to mention the caps, but if you compare to those on the net...they donít look real.

Iím aware thereís several revisions, but look at the colour...itís more of a dull gold, not yellow like the real ones.

And, yeah, the bottles are identical to the Westmalle. Apparently Peacock and Martin were responsible for importing these after visiting the abbey, but now I wonder if they were really imported at all. How many people get to see the inside of that place? Not many...why were they allowed?

So many questions.

I once had a genuine bottle that had Westmalle shape with "trappist" written around the collar. So that doesnít necessarily mean that itís a fake.
6/14/2011 11:53:56 AM

Private message send the author a private message


CapFlu 4469:204
Originally posted by RD400F
Originally posted by CapFlu
We had a 24 show up yesterday at Cascadia Liquors in Victoria. The Westy12 are selling for $16 each; while the Westy8 was $15.

When I opened it and first sampled the Westy12 - "I donít remember this tasting so much like Trois Pistoles".

Iíd love to know if it isnít authentic as I have another 5 bottles cellaring.

The caps are real. Anyone know if the bottles are the same ones used? And most importantly, the contents?

The last time I sampled a Westy12 was circa 2003 so I donít have much memory to compare to...
I thought Iíd be crazy to mention the caps, but if you compare to those on the net...they donít look real.

Iím aware thereís several revisions, but look at the colour...itís more of a dull gold, not yellow like the real ones.

And, yeah, the bottles are identical to the Westmalle. Apparently Peacock and Martin were responsible for importing these after visiting the abbey, but now I wonder if they were really imported at all. How many people get to see the inside of that place? Not many...why were they allowed?

So many questions.


Iíll post some photos when I get home.

Again, Iím working off memory so I may be gravely mistaken (re: caps et al) ... Iíd hate to think that our Liquor Stores have been had - but I must admit my "wow-factor" wasnít anything like I remember from 8-years ago.
6/14/2011 11:55:20 AM

Private message send the author a private message


premium
RD400F 177:3
Yeah, Iím aware the bottles are the same in some cases.

Looking closely at the caps seems to be backing this up...
6/14/2011 11:56:02 AM

Private message send the author a private message


CapFlu 4469:204
These 33cl bottles have the "trappist" collar.
6/14/2011 11:56:31 AM

Private message send the author a private message


CapFlu 4469:204
Originally posted by RD400F
Yeah, Iím aware the bottles are the same in some cases.

Looking closely at the caps seems to be backing this up...


Post a pic of the bottle and cap.

It would be funny if the bottles have been re-used and weíre drinking someoneís kick-ass homebrew
6/14/2011 12:00:07 PM

Private message send the author a private message


premium
JoeMcPhee 8314:502
Originally posted by CapFlu
Iíd hate to think that our Liquor Stores have been had - but I must admit my "wow-factor" wasnít anything like I remember from 8-years ago.


Youíve probably just forgotten what "rare" tastes like.
6/14/2011 12:00:51 PM

Private message send the author a private message

Home > Forums > Beer Talk

Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7
Copyright © 2000-2014,
RateBeer LLC. All rights
reserved.
about us
About RateBeer
FAQ
Contact/Feedback
New Beers
add
Advanced Search
Add A Beer
Add A Brewer
Add A Place
Events
membership
Log In
Edit Personal Info
Buy Premium Membership
Your Messages
the best
RateBeer Best
100 Beer Club
The Top 50