RateBeer

Going to do a macro lager blind taste taste this summer to prove something

read 2714 times • 41 replies •

Thread Frozen
 
allendodd
premium
beers 116 º places 2 º 20:17 Sun 6/23/2013

You know, of course, that theyíll all have to be served at 35 degrees - as recommended by their advertising.

Thatís going to go a long way toward making them impossible to differentiate.

 
joet
premium
admin
beers 2408 º places 100 º 20:57 Sun 6/23/2013

Iíve done this myself and have seen it done. Beer nerds tend to be able to pick out macro lagers quite well.

People who say they prefer one macro lager over another rarely beat chance.

When doing your test be sure to use eight or more macro brands.

 
kdm1984
beers 814 º places 7 º 21:59 Sun 6/23/2013

Ha. I once blind taste tested Bud Lite and Miller Lite. This was at a bowling alley when I was a beer n00b back in 2008. I insisted I liked Miller better, and that I could tell the difference. I picked Bud Lite. Therefore, I would not be surprised if your experiment proves the same of what I experienced.

 
finn1918
beers 231 º places 12 º 11:48 Mon 6/24/2013

There are certainly differences, as Iíve noted by ticking virtually anything I can get for less than $2 a tallboy. I could probably pick out a Pabst, Genny Cream, or a regular Budweiser in a blind taste, since those have more distinctive flavors. I havenít had any of the "light" versions of the big three in several years, so Iím pretty sure I couldnít pick them out in a blind tasting. I did find that the Genesee-brewed brands tend to be the least offensive of the macro lagers, so it would be neat to see how any of those would hold up; either the main brands, or the store-specific ones like Port Republic or Big Flats.

Also, throw in a craft pale lager or imperial pale just to see how it does!

 
graziano85
beers 370 º places 15 º 11:55 Mon 6/24/2013

Originally posted by b33r
Iíve always wanted to do this, but canít find where they sell singles of any of these, and I donít really want like ten 6pks of random pale lagers.


Really itís so hard in USA?
Here in Europe you can buy single bottles or cans everywhere

 
after4ever
premium
beers 6735 º places 251 º 12:13 Mon 6/24/2013

Originally posted by pinkie
I would love to watch this one and the reactions when folks are told what their choices were. =) I would participate even if it was just to see which crappy beer I thought tasted the best.

+1

 
levifunk
beers 12 º 12:15 Mon 6/24/2013

Make sure they are ice cold.

 
Cletus
beers 6355 º places 233 º 12:29 Mon 6/24/2013

Ever let some malt liquor sit out a while and include it in a blind lambic tasting? The results are hilarious.

 
tennisjoel
premium
beers 1231 º places 32 º 12:31 Mon 6/24/2013

We did this at a tasting many years ago. Miller Lite, Bud Light, and Coors Light. You could pick out some subtle differences. I got the Miller Lite correct (most flavor). Coors Light and Bud Light I got switched up. I was assuming Bud Light would have have the least amount of flavor, but it actually was Coors Light.

 
shrubber85
premium
beers 9135 º places 281 º 17:18 Mon 6/24/2013

Did this about 7 years ago with about 10 different beers - several people in the group swore they could pick out Budweiser without a problem. Threw in a Sam Adams just to be interesting. No one could pick out their favorite (except for the Sam Adams which stood out like a sore thumb). Old Style was the highest rated but Milwaukeeís Best was a surprising second.