Highly Rated Beers that You thought were Horrible

Reads 13462 • Replies 188 • Started Thursday, November 15, 2012 2:06:28 PM CT

The forums you're viewing are the static, archived version. You won't be able to post or reply here.
Our new, modern forums are here:
RateBeer Forums

Thread Frozen

Message joeneugs beers 6372 º places 240 º 19:49 Wed 2/13/2013 On topic, I just had Dogfish Head Immort for the first time today… Ughh. Peat smoked malt just sucks ass! I couldn’t even finish the 3 ounce sample that was served to me. Nasty.
Message RD400F beers 235 º places 4 º 20:34 Wed 2/13/2013 Three Philosophers. Fuckin sucks.
Message arminjewell beers 9756 º places 10 º 22:47 Wed 2/13/2013 Chocolate Rain = shot of vanilla vodka. Never again.

Message DutchDrebus beers 6996 º places 47 º 08:27 Thu 2/14/2013 I gave Hanssens Oudbeitje a 1.5, weighted avg for that beer is 3.55.
Message radarsock beers 1226 º places 112 º 08:46 Thu 2/14/2013 BAD BEER.
Message GT P beers 10001 º places 672 º 09:16 Thu 2/14/2013 Originally posted by DutchDrebus I gave Hanssens Oudbeitje a 1.5, weighted avg for that beer is 3.55. I actually like that one a lot, but every Hanssens is on the extreme side of acetic.
Message GT P beers 10001 º places 672 º 09:17 Thu 2/14/2013 Originally posted by joeneugs On topic, I just had Dogfish Head Immort for the first time today… Ughh. Peat smoked malt just sucks ass! I couldn’t even finish the 3 ounce sample that was served to me. Nasty. I cellared a bunch because it is called "Immortal(e)", but opened one last week and had to drain pour. Very papery, harsh, watery. Mild toffee and vanilla in the nose. No body.

Message AdamChandler P beers 6124 º places 278 º 09:18 Thu 2/14/2013 KBS...I honestly don’t get it. I didn’t like it after buying 2 4 packs last year. Got a 4-pack in a trade last week as an extra. Planning on giving it away during free beer week. That’s why I’m afraid of CBS..it’s a 750ML I have and going to open it in Belgium with a bunch of guys because I think more than an ounce will be too much.