Recipe check

read 552 times • 9 replies •

Thread Frozen
beers 4441 º places 348 º 09:57 Fri 10/5/2012

Hi guys, Iím about to do my first whole grain batch and would appreciate your feedback.

Estimated OG: 1051
Estimated FG: 1016

4.5 lbs Marris Otter
3.5 lbs Pearl Malt
1 lb Crystal 45 L
1 lb Flaked corn

60 minutes 1.5 oz EKG 5% leaf
15 minutes 1.5 oz EKG 5% leaf
5 minutes 1 oz Fuggles 4.5% leaf
5 minutes 1 oz EKG 5% leaf

Wyeast 1968 London ESB

Single step infusion @ 154 F for 60 minutes

60 minute boil.

I wanted to keep my first recipe simple, but I turned to this ESB because I had some already crushed MO and Crystal lying around (I used to do partial mashes with a BIAB technique). Iím curious as to whether or not I should go for a 75 min boil, if my mash temp is right, and if I should add some chalk and gypsum to the mix seeing my water here is pretty soft.

Any input is appreciated, thanks!

beers 12 º places 3 º 10:02 Fri 10/5/2012

Your FG is a little high. Why are you using corn? Because your FG should be lower with it. And do a 90 minute boil. Just get a little more when you sparge to make up for it. And maybe up the EKG to 2 oz instead of 1.5. What is your efficiency?

beers 4441 º places 348 º 10:19 Fri 10/5/2012

Thats what I thought. The FG is the result from beercalculus, but Iíve had 1968 attenuate a lot more than 69% when brewing extract/partial mash brews. The corn is there for easy sugar, should I just remove it? Thanks for the tip on the boil time, I thought maybe an ESB would call for a longer boil. I donít really know what my efficiency is as this is going to be my first run on my new equipment, the calculator used 75%.

beers 12 º places 3 º 10:49 Fri 10/5/2012

If you drop down to 152, you will get enough out of your mash. Are you doing a batch or fly sparge? I do batch, and key is to stir up the mash again and let it rest and do a vorlouf again after draining it the first time. Regularly get in the high 80s for my efficiency doing that.

beers 4441 º places 348 º 11:13 Fri 10/5/2012

Yep, going to batch sparge. Iíll follow your recommendations too, makes sense.

beers 1707 º places 45 º 10:59 Mon 10/8/2012

Simple sugar is fine, but Iíd recommend dropping the corn, too. Lots of commercial English ales include cane sugar, brown cane sugar or molasses, all of which enhance the fruity ale esters, but corn isnít true-to-style.

12:03 Mon 10/8/2012

Recipe looks just fine. A little more complex than it needs to be, but fine none-the-less. Agreed that the FG will be lower than 1.016. That is all.

beers 4441 º places 348 º 18:11 Mon 10/8/2012

Brewed this today, everything went rather smoothly and I was satisfied with my brewday. I ended up with less beer than expected (about 4 gallons without the trub] but Iíll work on waste on my next batches. Thanks for your input.

beers 2160 º places 63 º 19:55 Mon 10/8/2012

Originally posted by JulienHuxley
The FG is the result from beercalculus.

That is probably the least trustworthy number from beercalculus. I tend to ignore it.

beers 4441 º places 348 º 19:30 Wed 10/24/2012

Tasted out of the fermenter today, probably going to bottle this friday. Color is a little light, gold/dark gold color, very clear. Aroma is grainy with just a touch of vegetal english hops, right where I wanted it. Taste is equally nice, canít wait for this one to be bottled and carbed. Measured OG: 1054 FG: 1014

Homebrew Shops - A collection of homebrew shops and supply houses submitted by RateBeer readers

Homebrewing Articles - RateBeer Magazine's homebrewing department

Homebrew Recipes - Experiment, share and post your own homebrew recipes

Until we can make beer come out of your monitor...

Send Beer Over The Net

Free signup now. Even out a trade, keep good vibes alive, say hi with a beer