Thread Frozen
Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15
Originally posted by Lothore
I really value the fact that this trade forum is not as congested as BAs. It seems that whenever I put an iso up I get replies, even for rare beers and I like not having to sift through 50 "ISO: Darkness FT: Fat Tire" posts like I would have to on the other site. I think the main reason people don’t make as many posts is because more work goes on behind the scenes in this site. Anyway, I just wanted to jump in and say keep up the good work, I will never go back to the other site for trading unless I absolutely have to and I think this forum is working well.
But you WILL use the other site’s forum if you "absolutely have to", right?
"Behind the scenes" trades might help established traders but it seems to do nothing for the public community (I am not denying the value, rather simply observing the facts).
Did you meet your private traders publicly first?
|
Private message 
|
Originally posted by Schroppfy
it’s too late to put it back the way it was, and it’s going to pretty much stay a "my top 50 sexybeer for ....?" fest for the foreseeable future.
I don’t get how this could possible be because of the minor change that was made.
I much prefer the trade forum the way it is NOW. People who use it use it, and others seek behind the scenes, or both.
+1
If BA gets more hits on the same topics, then just trade on BA. Why all the complaining? We’re all drinking tasty beer and having a good time. At least, I am. I am with TBC, I really don’t understand why people keep saying the trading forum is not in good shape here. I understand this is a forum and we should discuss this, but is it really this big of a deal?
|
Private message
|
Originally posted by Sparky27
Agreed. Come to think of it, all five trades that I did this week were behind the scenes, as well as one going out on Monday.
I feel like this shift to behind the scenes trading is due in part to the change in the forums. They are so dead that the only way to really get a trade going is privately BM someone and ask them if they want to trade.
And while behind the scenes trading is good, it is also good to hook different people up with beers and help new traders become acclimated to the trading game.
|
Private message
|
Originally posted by BlackForestCO
[The forums] are so dead that the only way to really get a trade going is privately BM someone and ask them if they want to trade.
Are you saying send a private BM instead of posting a trade, or after posting a trade and getting no responses?
|
Private message
|
Originally posted by BlackForestCO
Originally posted by Sparky27
Agreed. Come to think of it, all five trades that I did this week were behind the scenes, as well as one going out on Monday.
I feel like this shift to behind the scenes trading is due in part to the change in the forums. They are so dead that the only way to really get a trade going is privately BM someone and ask them if they want to trade.
And while behind the scenes trading is good, it is also good to hook different people up with beers and help new traders become acclimated to the trading game.
A lot of times I’ve traded with new folks who posted on the forums (with reasonable requests, which is becoming increasingly rare) and no subsequent posts were made.. but they got what they wanted. I’ve also had good luck with reasonable ISO posts in both the distant and more recent past.
I think the biggest problem is that most people are just asking for uber-rare stuff.
|
Private message
|
Originally posted by spacecoyote
Originally posted by Lothore
I really value the fact that this trade forum is not as congested as BAs. It seems that whenever I put an iso up I get replies, even for rare beers and I like not having to sift through 50 "ISO: Darkness FT: Fat Tire" posts like I would have to on the other site. I think the main reason people don’t make as many posts is because more work goes on behind the scenes in this site. Anyway, I just wanted to jump in and say keep up the good work, I will never go back to the other site for trading unless I absolutely have to and I think this forum is working well.
But you WILL use the other site’s forum if you "absolutely have to", right?
"Behind the scenes" trades might help established traders but it seems to do nothing for the public community (I am not denying the value, rather simply observing the facts).
Did you meet your private traders publicly first?
Exactly. This change doesn’t hurt established traders nearly as much as new folks.
It really doesn’t bother me anymore as I have used other options, but I will still voice my opinion that it was a bad move...for the third or fourth time.
|
Private message
|
They are so dead that the only way to really get a trade going is privately BM someone and ask them if they want to trade.
Jake, do you have evidence to back this up? This could not be further from the truth. I just think it’s like TBC said, the community is changing and more people are gaining access to more beers so the trading threads that used to get a lot of hits may not get as many.
|
Private message
|
Originally posted by kp
Originally posted by BlackForestCO
[The forums] are so dead that the only way to really get a trade going is privately BM someone and ask them if they want to trade.
Are you saying send a private BM instead of posting a trade, or after posting a trade and getting no responses?
I am saying that with such a low traffic flow most users are abandoning even making FT or ISO threads, and have begun just sending BM’s instead to get trades worked out.
It’s a shame to me, because I liked the FT/ISO threads that seemed to get more people involved in trading.
So to clarify, in most cases, I am in favor of posting it to the forum and seeing what happens.
|
Private message
|
Originally posted by TURDFERGUSON
Jake, do you have evidence to back this up? This could not be further from the truth. I just think it’s like TBC said, the community is changing and more people are gaining access to more beers so the trading threads that used to get a lot of hits may not get as many.
Sam, the only evidence I have is the users that have to continually bump their threads day after day in hopes of getting some sort of response.
Aside from that, no, I don’t have any substantial evidence. I am just trying to call it as I see it. I am not sure why I am even too worried, considering I won’t be trading for a while after finishing some up.
|
Private message
|
Originally posted by BlackForestCO
Originally posted by Sparky27
Agreed. Come to think of it, all five trades that I did this week were behind the scenes, as well as one going out on Monday.
I feel like this shift to behind the scenes trading is due in part to the change in the forums. They are so dead that the only way to really get a trade going is privately BM someone and ask them if they want to trade.
And while behind the scenes trading is good, it is also good to hook different people up with beers and help new traders become acclimated to the trading game.
As mentioned above, many behind the scene trades were brought about from public trading with them in the past. I still monitor the trade forum all the time too.
|
Private message
|
|
