Uinta Punk’n is the best pumkin beer made by anyone

Reads 4754 • Replies 66 • Started Wednesday, September 17, 2014 7:14:52 AM CT

The forums you're viewing are the static, archived version. You won't be able to post or reply here.
Our new, modern forums are here:
RateBeer Forums

Thread Frozen

Message Frank beers 4561 º places 92 º 11:49 Wed 9/17/2014 Yes, Punk’n is far from my favorite Uinta beer as well but it is better than every single other pumpkin beer w/o exception.
Message boogychillin beers 7 º places 1 º 13:04 Wed 9/17/2014 Originally posted by brokensail Originally posted by boogychillin Far from it. I would not even think of putting it in my Top 10 to be honest. What if Tired Hands brewed a pumpkin beer? They made something as close to a pumpkin beer a year back maybe. I can’t remember if it was sweet potatoe or something that had some spices to approximate a pumpkin. Guess what? It was bad. But I got a kick out of your post, thanks.
Message Ragnampiza beers 751 º places 20 º 13:05 Wed 9/17/2014 Pumpkin beers ? No such thing, here. Now, if we were talking about chestnuts.. #justitalianthings

Message VsXsV P beers 5000 º places 92 º 13:22 Wed 9/17/2014 Pumpkin beers are a was of time.
Message Keir beers 183 º places 1 º 14:07 Wed 9/17/2014 Perennial uses Cushaw Squash. We’ve sampled about 100 different pumpkin beers over the past two years and only a few are good. A couple of personal faves: Schlafly Pumpkin and Hess Magna Curcerbita. Cooking tip: when using "just add water" pancake mix (great for camping), use Schlafly Pumpkin instead of water.
Message Rightcross55 beers 6 º 14:17 Wed 9/17/2014 How about Saint Arnold Pumpkinator....definitely one of my favorites. Point Brewing Whole Hog is pretty darn good also.
Message ContemplateBeer beers 2092 º places 154 º 14:47 Wed 9/17/2014 There is this list available: http://www.ratebeer.com/tag/pumpkin/ The highest rated I’ve had is the Schlafly Pumpkin, but my personal highest is Kentucky Pumpkin Barrel Ale, which makes me seem nuts considering the other ratings of that beer.

Message wchesser beers 2435 º places 44 º 15:06 Wed 9/17/2014 Elysian Dark of the Moon
Message Bitterbill beers 3241 º places 25 º 15:10 Wed 9/17/2014 The best I’ve had is Alaskan Pumpkin Porter.
Message fly P beers 1490 º places 271 º 15:21 Wed 9/17/2014 Originally posted by wchesser Elysian Dark of the Moon This may be the one I tried at GABF so long ago.