RateBeer

Unhappy brewer

read 8779 times • 126 replies •

Thread Frozen
 
DuffMan
premium
beers 8041 º places 322 º 12:10 Wed 3/13/2013

I just got chastised in a beermail from a brewmaster (small American brewery, employs 12 people) who was unhappy about my rating for one of his beers. His opening address was "Hey numbnuts" (very professional), and then went on to tell me how the beer in question has won awards and blah blah blah. I responded (rather nastily), then found out that he joined RB today SPECIFICALLY to send me his stern message.

Has this happened to anyone else? Just curious.

 
DietPepsican
premium
beers 1532 º places 56 º 12:14 Wed 3/13/2013

http://www.ratebeer.com/beer/red-lodge-czech-mate-pilsner/60309/

And yes, I’ve been called out before. It happens.

 
DuffMan
premium
beers 8041 º places 322 º 12:16 Wed 3/13/2013

Originally posted by randomgarbage
http://www.ratebeer.com/beer/red-lodge-czech-mate-pilsner/60309/

And yes, I’ve been called out before. It happens.

Holy omniscient!
How’d you know?
For the record I told him to fuck off.

 
beastiefan2k
beers 2861 º places 193 º 12:18 Wed 3/13/2013

Originally posted by DuffMan
Originally posted by randomgarbage
http://www.ratebeer.com/beer/red-lodge-czech-mate-pilsner/60309/

And yes, I’ve been called out before. It happens.

Holy omniscient!
How’d you know?
For the record I told him to fuck off.

now I wouldn’t be so proud of that, two wrongs don’t make a right.

Either way, your rating, while lower, seems to be in line with the previous ratings.

On the other hand, most people on this site wouldn’t know a good lager if it sat on their head.

 
left_bank
beers 89 º places 67 º 12:19 Wed 3/13/2013

it has been more then 30 years since i lived in canada and i am saddened to read that "we" still care so much about what americans think of us.

 
brokensail
premium
beers 13604 º places 1133 º 12:22 Wed 3/13/2013

I’ve had brewers contact me before, yes, but typically they’ve been cordial.

Although one insisted I tried the wrong beer. Even though it was clearly labeled, it was at a very reputable bar, and I’d previously and somewhat recently tried the beer he said I had.

In a sense, I think it’s good that brewers check the ratings on sites like RateBeer. But if you’re going to take things personally and attack/harass people who are rating your beers, that’s garbage. Of course, I could probably also use some more tact when it comes to certain ratings (of particularly unenjoyable beers).

 
DuffMan
premium
beers 8041 º places 322 º 12:27 Wed 3/13/2013

Originally posted by beastiefan2k
Originally posted by DuffMan
Originally posted by randomgarbage
http://www.ratebeer.com/beer/red-lodge-czech-mate-pilsner/60309/

And yes, I’ve been called out before. It happens.

Holy omniscient!
How’d you know?
For the record I told him to fuck off.

now I wouldn’t be so proud of that, two wrongs don’t make a right.

Either way, your rating, while lower, seems to be in line with the previous ratings.

On the other hand, most people on this site wouldn’t know a good lager if it sat on their head.

Didn’t mean to come across as "proud". Just stating the facts.
Right or wrong, if you contact me privately to insult me, chastise me, then boast about your product and company, you get what you deserve. If he bothered to look further, he would see that I actually am fairly complementary toward several of his other brews.

 
HogTownHarry
premium
beers 6278 º places 28 º 12:27 Wed 3/13/2013

Originally posted by left_bank
it has been more then 30 years since i lived in canada and i am saddened to read that "we" still care so much about what americans think of us.


?

Canada? Do we own Montana now? Yay??

 
DuffMan
premium
beers 8041 º places 322 º 12:27 Wed 3/13/2013

Originally posted by left_bank
it has been more then 30 years since i lived in canada and i am saddened to read that "we" still care so much about what americans think of us.

How does this have anything to do with the OP?

 
brokensail
premium
beers 13604 º places 1133 º 12:27 Wed 3/13/2013

Originally posted by HogTownHarry
Originally posted by left_bank
it has been more then 30 years since i lived in canada and i am saddened to read that "we" still care so much about what americans think of us.


?

Canada? Do we own Montana now? Yay??


OP is Canadian

 
left_bank
beers 89 º places 67 º 12:30 Wed 3/13/2013


OP is Canadian