The Old Toad | Rochester, New York
Places > United States > New York > Rochester

The Old Toad
Excellent based on 35 ratings
Type: Bar

277 Alexander St.
Rochester, New York United States 14607 [ print map ]
585 232 2626

Hours: m-f 11:30-2am, Sat 12-2am, Sun 5pm-2am

Mayor: Ron (13) | Taps: 18 | Bottles: 90

The Old Toad

Create a free account for these features:
Edit This Place | Add Event Here

Beer Available At The Old Toad (arranged by most recent)
Old Toad 20 66, Dogfish Head Firefly Ale 74, Three Heads Giant Panda Dub Style IPA , Prairie Bomb! 100, Ithaca Sour Pi , Clown Shoes Space Cake 99, Galaxy Andromeda IPA (Dry Hopped with Citra) , Galaxy Andromeda IPA (Dry Hopped with Ahtanum) , Galaxy Andromeda IPA (Dry Hopped with Simcoe) , Galaxy Andromeda IPA (Dry Hopped with Nelson Sauvin) , Elysian 12 Beers of Apocalypse #10 - Omen Belgian Raspberry Stout 92, Greenport Harbor Spring Turning Rye Saison 84, Jackís Abby Wet Hop Lager 62, Captain Lawrence Frost Monster 97, BlackBird OT Estate Blend , Three Heads Wendigo Winter Ale 85, Green Flash Hop Odyssey Cedar Plank Pale Ale 92, Galaxy Improbability IPA , Evil Twin Femme Fatale Noir 97, Boulder Beer 35th Anniversary Imperial Black IPA 90
More Beers Available Here
add beers to this location Sign in to add beer    |    Sign in to edit availabile beers    |    Print Shelftags    |    Customize Shelftags

35 reviews for The Old Toad
 Ambiance  88%
 Service  73%
 Selection  77%
 Food  71%
 Value  66%
 Overall  82%
 Rating  88%
Rating Distribution

  AMBIANCE 4/5   SERVICE 3/10   SELECTION 12/15   FOOD 4/10   VALUE N/A   OVERALL 14/20
JoeMcPhee  (529) Toronto, ON, Ontario | June 8, 2015
My wife and I popped in for a mid-afternoon snack, some drinks and some scrabble. The service was pretty spotty when we were in. Took a long time to get beer and to get our cheque. My wife got a sticky toffee pudding that was frankly terrible. In spite of this, I actually liked the place. Service could definitely be improved on - at least on the day we were there. The beer was good though.
  AMBIANCE 5/5   SERVICE 8/10   SELECTION 12/15   FOOD N/A   VALUE 9/10   OVERALL 18/20
UncleMcHoppy  (8) Old Tappan, New Jersey | July 4, 2013
Authentic English Pub (right down to the English people behind the bar) in Rochester, of all places! Good selection, with focus on the British Isles.
  AMBIANCE 5/5   SERVICE 8/10   SELECTION 13/15   FOOD 8/10   VALUE 7/10   OVERALL 17/20
Ron  (109) Rochester, New York | December 19, 2012
Great casual ambiance. I like the varity of beers they have on tap and it changes often. I like they keep their website up to date so that I can see what they have before I head out for the night. I have not had much food here yet. Always a good time.
  AMBIANCE 5/5   SERVICE 8/10   SELECTION 13/15   FOOD 9/10   VALUE 8/10   OVERALL 16/20
UDBeernut  (200) Between JAX and SGJ, Florida | May 23, 2012
dinner last night after searching for a good beer bar in Rochester here. Big restaurant with tiny bar. I sat at the bar. Excellent choice of beer on draft, 3 cask, and a booklet of bottles. I had Victory Saison du Buff, OT Smokin Porter, and Victory Headwaters. Thry did have the dutchess and La Trappe Quad on tap. Service was good. I had the Lemon Chicken sandwich and it was quite tasty. 3 beers and food $24, reasonable.
  AMBIANCE 5/5   SERVICE 8/10   SELECTION 12/15   FOOD 8/10   VALUE 8/10   OVERALL 17/20
ATTWNone  (12) , | January 31, 2012
Classic British pub feel that typically has the most cask selections on tap in the city. I can usually find a couple of excellent hoppy beers on tap, including their own OT20. Order the chips with gravy and have a pint at the bar. Bartenders are usually brought in from the UK and add to the authentic feel.
  AMBIANCE 4/5   SERVICE 6/10   SELECTION 10/15   FOOD 8/10   VALUE 8/10   OVERALL 16/20
johnnnniee  (128) Bedford, New Hampshire | June 2, 2011
8/25/2009 I went here two weeks ago while on vacation with the family. Our visit was on a Thursday evening for a late dinner. We were there at about 8pm and the place was kind of busy. The sign at the door said seat yourself and thatís what we did. 15 minutes later we found someone to wait on us. This place sits on a corner. Walking in thereís a short entryway then a dozen or so tables in a room on the left. Walking straight from the entry way leads to the bar area which also has probably a dozen or so tables as well as some stools at the bar. After we got our order in I studied the bottle menu and the tap list a few more times. 15 or so taps most had an English theme to them, 3 casks! I had 2 of them. Flying Bison cask, Old Engine oil, and something else from Custom Brewcrafters cask. All were very good. Good selection of single malts as well, I had one as a nightcap. I had the stuffed chicken, my wife had the grown up mac and cheese, and the kids had something fried from the tadpole menu. Good solid pub style food. The service was a bit off tonight. First no one came to wait on us, then we had to move because the dining area was to be closed for a private party. After what seemed like hours we were told that someone dropped my wifeís plate on the floor and they were remaking her dinner. They apologized and gave us free desert and such, but we were there for over an hour and pretty damn hungry before our food came out. If I were in the area again I would definitely stop in, great comfort food, and decent beer selection.
  AMBIANCE 5/5   SERVICE 9/10   SELECTION 10/15   FOOD 6/10   VALUE 6/10   OVERALL 16/20
MacBoost  (25) Pouring Bus, New York | December 12, 2010
This is a fun place. Authentic English style pub, complete with staffers who are from England. Iím guessing mostly students of the U of R. Good rotating tap selection, but the real reason to come here is for the ambiance and the 4 "real ale" casks. Good stuff. Bottle selection is good as well. Quite a few Belgian beers available. Food is passable, but not great.
  AMBIANCE 4/5   SERVICE 9/10   SELECTION 12/15   FOOD 8/10   VALUE 6/10   OVERALL 17/20
busster88  (9) Syracuse, New York | September 29, 2010
Very good place to go for a pint. Food is good, just pub food, bust good just the same. Sometimes have deals for food and brew at a good value. Beers range quite a spectrum. Great beer menu comes in handy for selecting your drink, really interesting to see the large assortment. Little run down, but its a pub so who really cares.
  AMBIANCE 3/5   SERVICE 4/10   SELECTION 10/15   FOOD 5/10   VALUE 5/10   OVERALL 14/20
MikeF  (204) Cleveland, Ohio | May 26, 2010
Appears as a somewhat authentic brittish style pub. A bit run down and not all that nice upon close inspection. They had a moderate selection with a regional bias. A couple of casks added to the selection. Service is provided "authentic" British. The service is slow and not the sharpest. The food is all English style -- it is O.K. portions are small and for what you get the prices are high. I suggest sticking with anything that is fried. Overall, as far as restaurants go, above average on the beer scale, but not a world class beer stop.
  AMBIANCE 4/5   SERVICE 6/10   SELECTION 11/15   FOOD 5/10   VALUE 3/10   OVERALL 17/20
Tanker12  (2) | February 3, 2010
Great looking bar on the inside, looks like nothing I have seen in the states. Very good selection on tap that rotates frequently. Staff is very knowledgeable but table service always seems a little slow. The beers are more on the expensive side but to do get quality that is tough to find elsewhere in Rochester. One of my favorite bars.

<< first< prev1-10next >last >>
What's Your Opinion?
Add your review

Checked In

Proximity Map

View Proximity Map
Print Travel Map

Proper Glassware
Real Ales
Edit Info | Add an Event  
Copyright © 2000-2015,
RateBeer LLC. All rights
about us
About RateBeer
New Beers
Advanced Search
Add A Beer
Add A Brewer
Add A Place
Log In
Edit Personal Info
Buy Premium Membership
Your Messages
the best
RateBeer Best
100 Beer Club
The Top 50