RateBeer.com: View Trades

puzzl's Trade History

trade rating
145

Beer Cellar Trade History Leave Feedback

entered	by	comments	rating
Apr 2015	Pailhead	Andy hooked me up with a excellent mix of beers for fantasy football payouts. He sent Midnight Sun Moscow, Singlecut Full Stack IIPA, Flying V, Captain Lawrence Rosso e Marrone, and Almanac Dogpatch Sour. Thanks Andy!
Feb 2015	JCB	Andy sent me a great box of beer for FFL payouts. I received: 1 Bell’s Expedition, 1 Off Color Apex Predator, 1 Off Color Dino Smores, 1 Almanac Devil’s Advocate, 1 Singlecut Full-Stack IIPA, 1 Singlecut Flying V SourLagrrr. Killer packaging too. Thanks!!!
Jul 2014	jdb288	Fulfilled obligation for March Madness tournament challenge by sending a box of beer to me.
Jun 2014	foppa78	Andy sent an awesome box of beer and homemade bread. It was fantastic! Andy is a talented breadmaker. Thanks Andy!
Mar 2014	changeup45	Andy sent me a few highly sought after beers on my want list for winning the Ball for Beer league. Very generous. Expertly packed. A good guy and an asset to ratebeer. Thanks!
May 2013	ksurkin	Andy sent a great box of tasty beers for Ratebeer Brackets! cheers!
Mar 2013	jesus	great trader!
May 2011	tyler_mn	Andy helped me complete one of the few verticals I still have going by sending me an Alesmith Decadence 05. Thanks!
May 2011	CaptainCougar	Andy sent me a box for the NCAA March Madness pool containing Charlevoix Vache Folle Herkules Double IPA, New Glarus Unplugged Cherry Stout, and a Southampton Imperial Russian Stout 2009. Nicely packed inside a fitted cardboard shipper. Thanks again for some great brews!
Apr 2011	hopdog	One of those Trade Partners I’m glad to have! Thanks for the beers!
Mar 2011	StFun	Awesome box from Andy for Fantasy Football. 3 shipper with a Stillwater, Hanssens, and a Milk Stout. Very thoughtful and cool selection of brews that I’m pretty excited about. Thanks man!
Dec 2010	grownfool	Andy came through with a rare Fantome that I didn’t even know I wanted. Thanks so much for the La Gillmoir!
Sep 2010	Boutip	Nice trade with Andy. Easy communication with great delivery. I got some Southamton RIS, Rosso E Marrone and a bunch of others.
May 2010	tyler_mn	Andy sent a nice little box of some NE brews and a couple Kunhenn Bierkraft brews. Thanks!
May 2010	Suttree	Got a Sly Fox Black Raspberry, Winter Warmer, and Saison Vos, and a Captain Lawrence Captains Reserve IPA. Good trade all around, well packed and no problems.
May 2010	tdtm82	Traded an Old Chimneys’ Special Reserve 2007 for a Captain Lawrence Nor’ Easter Winter Warmer beer. Thanks a lot mate. Have a safe trip home.
May 2010	ucusty	RateBrackets 2010! Awesome box from Andy! Leelanau Golden Ale Kuhnhenn 1ltr Simcoe Silly
May 2010	Brewthusiast	A quick and easy trade for some DL. Thanks for the great beer!
May 2010	drfabulous	Andy sent CC Hunahpus plus two bonus beers: Mayfield Pale Ale and Duck Rabbit Milk Stout. Thanks!
Apr 2010	StFun	Face to face, bottle for bottle at DLD. Very cool, and enjoyed hanging out and sharing a few brews. Thanks man!
Jan 2010	Beerlando	As one leg of a 3-way trade between myself, cquiroga, and puzzl.....Andy sent me a very rare brew that I doubt I’d ever come across otherwise, along with two very nice extras. The packaging was fantastic. Easy going. Thanks a ton man!
Dec 2009	bitbucket	Andy sent a Captain Lawrence Cuvee de Castleton and a Flaming Fury, along with a bonus of Au Maître Brasseur Cuvée Spéciale du Dep de la Rive. Great stuff, thanks!
Nov 2009	TheAlum	Andy sent me a nice spread from CL, adding to my Flaming Fury count. He also offered a SFTO Brandy and bonused a Brute. Packed great, arrived prompt. Thanks a bunch!
Oct 2009	pantanap	andy graciously sends me a SFTO brandy along with some cans of duck butter......mmmmmmmmm
Sep 2009	hannont	Andy hooked me up with a sweet box of beer...Castleton, St. Vincent’s Dubbel and Cigar City’s Bolita Brown and Improvisacion. Thanks man!
Sep 2009	fata2683	Andy sent me a 09 Dark Lord and a cool looking 25 cl Mikkeller Sherry BA Black as Hell for a Bush de Nuits. Communication was top notch and he shipped out really fast. Thanks again!
Aug 2009	guerinfbfan	Great trade with Andy. He sent the agreed upon 3 cans of Butternuts Moo Thunder, a can of Oskar Blues Ten Fidy, and a can of Butternuts Porkslap Pale Ale in exchange for a Goose Island Sofie, a Great Lakes Grassroots, and a Great Lakes Glockienspiel Weizenbock. Andy also bonused me a can of Butternuts Snapperhead IPA and a can of Heinnieweisse Weissebier. Andy is a great trade. Will definitely try
Aug 2009	cheap	Knowing that I love sour beers, for a couple of local growlers, Andy sent me a liter of Upland Blueberry lambic and a bottle of Castleton Cuvee. He also threw in a variety six pack of interesting extras in cans, too boot! All packed very nicely. Thanks! Smooth trade with excellent communication.
Aug 2009	MrChopin	Andy ran a contest in which participants predicted the next celebrity death. I accurately predicted the first death so he sent me a bottle of CL Cuvee de Castleton. It was packed safe in crate and arrived quickly. Another great RB experience thanks to Andy’s generosity!
Jun 2009	corby112	Smooth first trade with Andy. In addition to the agreed upon 750ml of Earthmonk he sent me an extra bomber of Fort Collins Barrel Licked Bock! Greta communication and quick shipment as well. Would definitely trade with puzzl again.
May 2009	giarcsr	Andy contacted me about a couple of beers on my haves and offered up a more then fair offer which I jumped on. Very easy to deal with, added a great bonus, and was prompt with everything. Was a simple and great trade! Thanks a lot!
May 2009	Bockyhorsey	Who says good things have to come in big boxes puzzl sent me couple of nice brews for my 3rd place finish in the NCAA pool. Two bottles 750 ml Blue Point Old Howling Bastard (wl) and 750 ml Southampton 10th Anniversary Old Ale (RETIRED). Thanks nice selections
May 2009	VikingHammer	Andy sent a perfectly packed Brandy barrel Old Stock Ale. Thank you Andy I will enjoy this treat on a special occasion.
May 2009	DMRz	Andy sent me the agreed upon 2 bottles of Dark Lord ’09 and a bonus that stopped me dead in my tracks - a 2005 Struise Pannepot Grand Reserva! All 3 bottles were packed perfectly. Thanks a lot for a great trade and your generosity.
May 2009	noncaloric	Wow, just wow. I traded Andy a boxful of New Glarus products for Weyerbacher 12, 13, and Captain Lawrence dubbel and tripel. But then he put Dark Lord in the box, and I’m more than a little flabbergasted.
May 2009	hopdog	Thanks for the Brute and Aracdia beer!
Mar 2009	5000	Who woulda thought I would get Melange #3 for Hard Liver, and from the east coast no less. Andy is a pro, just like all the other times. Also sent out some batch 3 Nor’Easter. Great stuff! Looking forward to both. Something enjoyed in years past, and a newcomer that I hope everyone will enjoy. Thanks again!
Mar 2009	hannont	Wow!!! Andy sent me a box for the ages with some seriously good beers...2005 BA Old Salty(WL)...one of my favorite beers I’ve ever had. He also sent a 2009 Southampton RIS (WL), a Ommegang Biere de Mars and extras of 2005 BA Got Rocks RIS, Sculpin IPA, and a 2005 Goose Island Imperial IPA (WL). I can’t thank you enough Andy
Mar 2009	Schroppfy	A little one-for-one with Andy went extremely well- smooth, easy, quick. Thanks Andy for the Rosso; it was delicious.
Mar 2009	WeeHeavySD	5th trade with Andy, he sent the coveted rosse e marone, a Southampton Scotch Ale, and 2 bonus beers, an 05-06 Brooklyn Chocolate Stout and a Duck Rabbit Baltic Porter. Great packaging and easy communication. Thanks again dude.
Mar 2009	TheBeerSommelier	Andy hooked me up with a Black Ops and tossed in a celllared Mendocino Winter IIPA. Very cool. Thanks again dude.
Feb 2009	sthlm	Puzzl created a contest in which the person that guessed a number between one and 1,000,000 would win a Cuvee de Castleton. I won, and he sent me not only the CdC, but also bonused a Tyranena Dirty Old Man. Thanks again, Andy!
Jan 2009	ygtbsm94	Andy hooked me up in a big way with some superb brews: 1-Brooklyn Black Ops, 1-Southampton Imperial Russian Stout, and a bonus brew: 1-Cascade Apricot. Package arrived in less than a day!!! Again, outstanding communication and one generous dude! Thanks again Andy for this painless trade. “Beer is Good Food”
Dec 2008	doublea	Puzzl hooked me up with a Toronado that I’ve been seeking for months, and a HopSlam to boot. Thanks man!
Dec 2008	Miver	Andy hooked me up with a La Face Cachee de la Pomme Frimas and a Newport Storm 03. He threw in Sierra Nevada Pale Bock, Ommegang Biere de mars, and a Wasatch Polygamy Porter. Very nice trade!! Thanks for everything.
Nov 2008	hannont	Andy answered my call for 3 pumkings and a cuvee 1 and bonused me an old herb, and a Schlafly bourbon barrel aged imperial stout....nice It was an honor to be your 100th trade man. Congratulations!
Nov 2008	Sparky	Andy hooked me up with one of my most sought after beers, the Southampton Imperial Russian Stout, then threw in great extras in a Southampton Old Herb Barleywine and a Holy Mackerel Mack in Black. Thanks so much for the Southampton hook-up and great extras Andy!
Oct 2008	DrHomolka	It’s not easy thinking up clever titles all the time. Andy sent me the ageed upon SFTO bourbon, Angel’s Share, and Fred from the Wood for some Upland lambics. He also was nice enough to include an Old Stock 05 (want list) and a SH Cuvee de Fleurs (should be on want list). Looking forward to trying all these great beers. An excellent trader.
Oct 2008	5000	Super quick trade with Andy, sent Brouwer’s Imagination Saison w/Brett for a Smoke from the Oak Bourbon (Captain Lawrence). Wham, Bam, Thank you Bromigo! :-)
Oct 2008	FlacoAlto	Puzzl sent, in a well packaged box, the agreed upon Ommegang BdM, plus a bunch of extras in Cidrerie McKeown Cidre de la Montagne Rouge, St. Ambroise Apricot Wheat Ale and Dieu du Ciel La Complice. Another great trade and I can’t wait to drink the beer/cider.
Sep 2008	hayduke	Puszl was my first trade and he made it very worthwhile. My box came packed with wonderful beers: Southampton Abbot12, McKeown De La Montagne Rouge, Brooklyn Black Chocolate Stout, Complice British Style Brown Ale 2008, Weyerbacher Imperial Pumpkin Ale, Neige ice cider, Southern Tier Unearthly, and Weyerbacher VIII. Carefully packed. He has made trading exciting and I am ready to do it again.
Sep 2008	pantanap	a few captain lawrence bottles, brandy old stock, and a couple southhampton 750s which will be put to good use soon. thanks a whole lot andy!
Aug 2008	JMFG	puzzl sent the agreed upon Ommegang Biere de Mars and Southampton Biere de Garde, plus a bonus SH 10th Anniversary Old Ale. Quick and easy trade, good communication.
Aug 2008	ucusty	Somehow I forgot about this trade and the box arrived today. I totalaly flailed here and hope I can hold too my end of the bargain... Sorry!!! Very generous trader Agreed on an 05 oerbier reserve St CBS, he bonused a CL xtra gold. Very Nice indeed!
Aug 2008	WeeHeavySD	Andy rocks in our 4th or 5th trade I believe. I can’t possibly manage to be as creative as he was with his trade review, so I guess I’m not going to try. CDC Batch 2 Ommegang Biere de Mars, ST Creme Brulee Stout and a bonus Wellington Iron Duke. Andy makes me happy with CDC.
Jul 2008	kramer	puzzl hooks me up with a nice variety of beers, Damnation 23, Scotch Irish John By, a growler of Sixpoint Diesel, a Victory Baltic Thunder, and a few bonus beers to boot. A great trader, puzzl is one of those dudes that I think about when I’m picking up new stuff. It’s always easy and quick. Great trader!
Jun 2008	hellomynameis	Not only did any send me a Amager Barrel Aged Series Imperial Stout, he threw in a Southern Tier Saison and a St Ambrose oatmeal stout. Thanks a ton!!!
Jun 2008	hopdog	Andy sent me a Growler of sixpoint eight days o wheat! Received it a day after we agreed on the trade. Thanks!!!
Jun 2008	KimJohansen	Excellent trade this was. Andy prodvides me with: La Folie, Upland Blueberry Lambic, 96 Stille Nacht, Russian River Deviation, Russian River Beatification batch 002, Russian River Sanctification, Smuttynose Imperial Stout, Stone Old Guardian, Weyerbacher Double Simcoe IPA, Captain Lawrence Smoke from the Oak (Wine Barrel), 90 Minute Imperial IPA and Yulesmith Summer edt. To top that two extras: Pe
Jun 2008	ironchefscott	awesomely packaged shippment from ny containing 1 rasberry eisbock, 1 dark horizon, 1 southampton abt 12 and as extras 1 smuttynose irs and one smuttynose ipa great communication....great trader...thanks!
May 2008	cheap	For a growler of local beer Andy sent me Kriek Boon, Gueze Boon, Whales Tale, Millennium Brew and Elm City Lager. I sure got the best of this deal! More than I could have ever expected. I would not hesitate to trade with puzzl again. Easy, smooth trade and open communication. Thanks Andy!
May 2008	HailSquishface	Andy sent the agreed upon BA Old Salty, Smoke from the Oak(Wine), and Enigma. As extras he threw in Bear Republic Racer 5 and Fred. All packed up nicely in a styro shipper.
May 2008	StFun	Just got an EXCELLENT box from Andy! We did a small 1-for-1 trade, 2008 DL for a SMTO Wine. But then Andy went beyond and bonused me an Abyss! Everything was packaged like a pro, shipped fast, and kept communication the entire time. Very, very excellent trade. Thanks Andy!!
May 2008	Acknud	Great easy trade. Sent the requested Captain Lawrence Nor’ Easter Winter Warmer, Green Flash 2nd Anniversary Ale and a Shenandoah Chocolate Donut Beer. This gives me another state. Thanks man.
May 2008	Beerlando	As one of my March Madness ’08 boxes, Andy sent me Captain Lawrence Nor’Easter and a Oskar Blues Ten FIDY. Great packaging too. Thanks Andy!
Apr 2008	hopdog	Andy sent me; Captain Lawrence Smoke from the Oak (Wine Barrel) and extra of Bear Republic Red Rocket Ale. Thanks!!!
Apr 2008	sprinkle	My very own Southhampton RIS!!! Nice!!! Even threw in a Marin Raspberry Trail Ale! Love trading with this guy and would do it again and I’m sure we will soon. Perfectly pack and very timely! Highly recommended. Cheers! Mike
Apr 2008	WeeHeavySD	Andy is great, this is 2 trades in one, as he replaced a bottle from a previous trade. This one included a Choklat for that previous trade, another Choklat, and a Smoke from the Oak Wine Barrel. Also this had Yards Saison, Hoppin Frog Wheat, and Lagunitas Impy Red. Additionally the first trade had these bonuses from Montreal: Peche mortel. Bock Emissaire from Bierophiolie, John Roy Imperial St
Apr 2008	5000	Andy answered my call for Hard Liver by offering up 3 Southern Tier Back Burner Barleywine and also 4 Captain Lawrence Xtra Gold American Tripel Ale. Both were hits at the tasting! Great communication, solid packaging. Wouldn’t hesitate to trade with Andy again!.
Apr 2008	deftim13	Andy took care of me with Two Barrel Aged Old Stock Reserves( brandy and Bourbon) and a couple extras. Thanks for the great trade.
Mar 2008	wetherel	Puzzl sent a great rare, well packed, package of: -À l’Abri de la Tempête Corne de Brume -Southampton Imperial Russian Stout -Shenandoah Oak Barrel Millennium Ale -Dieu du Ciel Route des Épices -Flying Bison The Herc C-130 Thanks!
Mar 2008	Enniskillen	1 Michel Jodoin Blanc de Pépin Fort 1 Michel Jodoin Coeur à Tout 1 Verger du Minot Crémant de Pomme du Minot Rosé 1 La Face Cachée de la Pomme Inspiration 2006 1 Les Vergers Lafrance Bouquet sur Glace Thanks Andy!!!
Mar 2008	WisconsinBeer	Puzzl shipped out a superb package of beer that was mishandled by FedEx, and eventually returned, but he was more than happy to re-pack it and send it out again. I appreciate all the effort and am looking forward to enjoying my beers! 1 Westy 12 1 Dark Lord 1 D Carnegie Porter 97 1 Stille Nacht 96 1 Southern Tier
Mar 2008	Sparky	Andy hooked me up with a surprise box after he was gracious enough to change the trade after I had already acquired the original beer we agreed upon. Wow what a box! Andy sent a Smuttynose Impy Stout, a Goose Island Bourbon County Stout, and Southern Tiers Un*Earthy and Gemini – all wants list beers! Shipped fast and superbly packed – just in time for March Madness. Great communication also.
Mar 2008	Glouglouburp	Andy delivered a much sought after Golden Delicious and just for fun added Red Barn batch #1 and a Tyranena High-Class Broad Imperial Brown Ale. Super friendly ratebeerian and I’m happy I was able to share a beer with him. Thanks again Andy.
Feb 2008	kramer	puzzl generously sent off a bottle of Captain Lawrence Golden Delicious as agreed, and in exchange for a bottle I threw in, he sent an awesome 375 ml bottle of Ice Cider from Canada!! Way above and beyond what I expected, I couldn’t be happier. Also a bonus bottle of Dieu du Ciel Corne du Diable. Multiple trades already with him, and I’m looking forward to more.
Feb 2008	hopdog	Thanks for another easy trade!
Feb 2008	FlacoAlto	Wow, what a package! Puzzl sent 2 CL Golden Delicious’ as agreed upon and then included as extras a bottle of La Face Cachée de la Pomme Inspiration 2005 and Dieu du Ciel Corne du Diable. As always good communication, a dedicated styro shipper, and a pure pleasure to deal with.
Feb 2008	pantanap	a nice and quick trade made with puzzl...sent me a golden delicious just like he advertised. we agreed on no extras since this guys is hard to shop for. i believe this is our second trade...can’t wait for the next one. thanks andy!
Feb 2008	toncatcher	Andy answered my call for a short sweet trade for the new CL Golden Delicious. Perfect.
Feb 2008	HogTownHarry	We did a quick in-person deal at Dieu du Ciel in Montreal - I gave him 5 SI John By stouts, a Black Oak Nutcracker and a complete set of 11 tubs of Steelback goodness - he gave me a Captain Lawrence Golden Delicious, an Ottos Red, an Alesmith Wee Heavy (yesss!) and a bonus Doggie Claws ’07 - cheers and enjoy that swill, dude!
Feb 2008	sprinkle	Another great trade! Sent me a Beatification PH1 and a Golden Delicious, then slipped in a Cpt. Lawrence winter brew 750ml as an extra. Great communication and top notch packing. Highly recommended.
Jan 2008	hapjydeuce	Andy sent me a box of goodies! Included were CL Smoke from the Oak (Bourbon), a HOTD Doggie Claws, and extras of New Glarus Smoke on the Porter and a Duck-Rabbit Baltic Porter (sweet!) Great packaging and communication. Thanks Andy!
Jan 2008	johnadam2002	Andy answered my call for a BA Old Salty. Bottle looks amazing. He also added HOTD Adam, Rose, and Ruth as extras! Thats right all wants list!
Jan 2008	kramer	In a sturdy 4 bottle styro shipper puzzl sent an awesome box for his Ball for Beer payout. In it were Southern Tier Oat and Choklat and a Captain Lawrence Smoke from the Oak Bourbon Barrel!! Awesome beers, over and above what was required. Looking forward to my next trade with puzzl!
Jan 2008	nflmvp	I warned him I was shipping in a styro shipper, without room for extras. Told him not to add any. What does HE do? Uh huh, extras. LOL Andy came through with a nice package of goodies (PLUS the bonus beers). I’d trade with him again in a heartbeat. Thanks man!
Jan 2008	maniac	Andy hooked me up with two sake styles that I can’t find anywhere around here. Included were Tenzan (Heavens Mountain) Junmai Genshu Sake, Kamaya Kyuzaemon Junmai Taruzake, and a bonus of Captain Lawrence Nor’ Easter Winter Warmer. Thanks Andy!
Jan 2008	Cryotek	Thank you so much for making my first trade go perfectly! We were able to exchange bottles of Newport Storm and get some bonuses! Thanx so much for the 1790 Root Beet to take off my list and especially for the vintage Old Crustacean from Rogue, wow! I hope we will be trading again in the future! I’ll never forget my first ;-)
Jan 2008	FlacoAlto	A great trade, saw puzzl send me a Captain Lawrence Nor’Easter and a bonus Southern Tier Gemini in a dedicated styro shipper. Nice, easy trade that was a pleasure to do.
Jan 2008	Theis	It arrived in perfect condition – Thanks. I am happy again !!! Alesmith BA Old Numbskull, Captain Lawrence SFTO Rum + SFTO Bourbon + Xtra Gold, DFH WWS + Olde School, Jolly Pumpkin Maracaibo Especial, Ommegang Chocolate Indulgence Stout, Ottos Jolly Rodger, Stone Double Bastard, Thomas Hooker Imperial Porter, Weyerbacher Insanity.
Jan 2008	kmweaver	Andy hooked me up with a bottle each of Southampton Abbot 12 and Unibroue 10 (!). Sweet! He also included a Southern Tier Choklat as an awesome bonus. Great styro packaging, speedy shipment, and a pleasant trade all around. Thanks, Andy!
Jan 2008	kp	Puzzl delivers a growler of the Captain Lawrence Smoked Porter and a bottle of the Southern Tier Pumpking plus a bonus of the new Southern Tier Choklat all well packed in layers of packing. Big thanks to the hoodless pooch!
Dec 2007	JohnC	Puzzl sent some Capt Lawrence Smoke from the Oak along w/ a nice berliner weisse. Thanks again
Nov 2007	SoLan	Andy delivered the agreed upon CL SFTO Rum and Bourbon, Southampton Biere de Garde, Weyerbacher Prophecy, and Newport Storm ’03. Extras in the form of St. Ambroise Oatmeal Stout, Goose Island Pere Jacques, and Dark Horse Black Bier. Quick styro shipping, great communication. Thanks!
Oct 2007	ygtbsm94	Outstanding personal delivery here in Brussels, Belgium. Delivery included 1-Alesmith Speedway Stout, 1-Stone RIS, 2-Bells Expedition Stouts, 1-Southern Tier Imperial Oatmeal Stout. Communication was great; would like to trade again with Andy in the future. Thanks for the superb delivery Andy!!
Oct 2007	kramer	Andy sent off a CL Smoke from the Oak Bourbon Barrel to me super quick with two bonus beers to boot! Always easy to work with and a great RBer! Thanks for the trade puzzl!
Oct 2007	ryan	Andy sent me Captain Lawrence Smoke from the Oak Bourbon and Rum and threw in a Bièropholie Impériale Stout (want list). All packed up in styro as neat as a dog in a hoodie. Thanks Andy!
Oct 2007	WeeHeavySD	Great trade with Puzzl. 07 Midnight Sun Berserker, 02 Newport Storm as well as 4 bonuses. Middle Ages dragon slayer, weyebacher 12, troges troegenator and Kapstreiter Land Beer. Thanks for the rarities and all the killer bonuses!
Sep 2007	SamuraiArtist	Puzzl delivers the Hop-15 and Lost Abbey Judgement Day as ordered with great bonuses! Very fast turn around and great communication. Thanks!
Aug 2007	IrishBoy	Andy sent the Shirayuki (White Snow) Nama Sake Draft. Midnight Sun Berserker 2007, Capt Lawrence SFTO Rum barrel, and threw in a Troegenator, Legacy Hedonism, and Clipper City Peg Leg! All in a six styro shipper! Thanks for another great trade Andy!
Aug 2007	sprinkle	Puzzl came to the rescue, even when I feel through with my part of the original offer(my drunken mistake). Sending a perfectly packed Cpt. Lawrence Cuvee De Castleton, he also sent along Cpt. St. Vincent Dubbel 750 ml and a Slyfox Spruce ale. Great communication, speedy delivery. Highly recommended. Cheers! Mike
Aug 2007	BBB63	Many thanks Andy for sending me Weyerbacher Muse, Smutty Farmhouse and ROBD ale, Buffalo Belgian Stout, and the NG Copper Kettle we agreed upon but he includes Siletz Oatmeal Cream and Chocolate Porter bombers as well. Are U kidding me? A bonus bottle of 1996 Stille Nacht, WOW who includes that as a bonus...Andy does! Good communications with someone I would trade with again if given the chance
Aug 2007	IrishBoy	Andy sent the agreed to Newport Storm 02 (Thanks tons), ST Backburner BW, and Ommegangs Rare VOS, Hennepin, & Abbey Ale (X2) and binused a Captain Lawrence St Vincents Dubbel! The big ones in shipper slots and the smalleys in bubble wrap on top! Thanks Andy! Great trade, great communication!
Jul 2007	cquiroga	A "simple" one-for-one-- PP Le Woody (classic) for a Captain Lawrence Smoke from the Oak (Wine Barrel). Andy was on the up-and-up all the while, held onto the gem of a beer as we took a good long while with the trade, and then packed the hell out of it to make sure there were no problems with shipping. And a CL Dubbel to boot! Top notch.
Jul 2007	Stine	Andy sent me a beer I’ve been dreaming about called Xtra Gold from Captain Lawrence, along with an 1809 Berliner Weiss. As an extra he sent a La Bavaisienne, which he knew I wanted. Top notch. Thanks man.
Jun 2007	mkgrenwel	Andy sent me a Cantillon Bruoscetta 1900 Grand Cru and a bonus Captain Lawrence Dubbel. I am a happy man today.
Jun 2007	pantanap	Brooklyn are you in the house.....sorry got carried away with a little ODB. Andy responded to my ISO request and came through big time with a few of new york’s finest. It’d be an honor to do this again some time. Awesome.
Jun 2007	WeeHeavySD	Andy hooked me up with Southampton Abbot 12 and Grand Cru and threw in 2 12 oz bonuses Arcadia Starboard Stout and Ale Asylum Hopalicious. Great Packing easy communication and quick shipping. Thanks for this easy, quick trade.
May 2007	iowaherkeye	Andy sent the agreed upon Cuvee de Castleton and threw in Saranac IIPA and Arcadia London Porter. One of the faster trades I’ve done. Thank you sir
May 2007	bu11zeye	Andy sent CL Cuvee de Castleton and Xtra Gold and then threw in bonuses of Saranac Imperial IPA and New Glarus Unplugged Enigma (a personal favorite). This was my second trade with Andy and would recommend him to other Ratebeerians. Thanks!
May 2007	hopdog	I asked for a bottle of Captain Lawrence Cuvee de Castleton and he sends me this and 3 other extras! Thanks...
May 2007	zathrus13	Andy sent me the highly sought after Cuvee de Castleton as we agreed. He also included two extras, Dark Horse Tres Blueberry Stout and Saranac Imperial IPA. Everthing was well packed.
May 2007	thebaldwizard	Andy and I swapped Cuvee’s, as I sent him a tomme and he sent me the Captain Lawrence Cuvee de Castleton. He sent the box very quickly, but one bonus bottle did break on the way over. Thankfully it wasn’t the reason for the trade.
May 2007	kramer	Captain Lawrence that is. One bottle of Captain Lawrence Cuvee de Castleton to be specific along with two great bonus beers, Midnight Sun Cohoho Imperial IPA and Saranac IIPA. Great trade, like always. Thanks a ton, looking forward to the next trade!
May 2007	LeopoldStoch	Andy was a class act to deal with on our trade! He sent me a few great beers, and packed them all up in a styro shipper. Great beers and great extras! Highly recommended and a real breeze to deal with on a trade! Thanks again Andy!!
May 2007	Ty5592	This is my 3rd or4th trade with Andy and he always comes thru. Got me a CL Xtra Gold and a New Holland Blue Goat Doppelbock as an xtra. great pack job. Hey, these packing materials look familiar........
Apr 2007	Crosling	A really nice trade. I received a Batch 7000, 2 Nor Easter, 1 Smoke From The Oak and 1 SPH Edible Flower Saison....Then he bonuses me a Growler of Captain Lawrence Double IPA. A fantastic bonus. Thanks, man.
Apr 2007	ryan	Puzzl hooked me up with C. Lawrence Smoke from the Oak and threw in a La Face Neige Ice Cider. Awesome trader. Thanks!
Apr 2007	ryan	Puzzl sent me a Southampton Abbot 12 and Unibroue 10 for the March Madness pool. Amazing! Thanks man!
Apr 2007	TheEpeeist	Opened this box extra carefully knowing what lay within. Captain Lawrence Smoke from the Oak ! ! ! and a bonus from the Captain, Xtra Gold ! Rounds out my CL’s ... at least until the Castleton arrives. Lastly, a ! ! Frimas Ice Cider ! ! Andy was kind enough to part with this gem. Much thanks, super trader!
Apr 2007	markgugs	Wasn’t actually a shipment, I met puzzl (Andy) in person in NYC, since we both work in or near there, traded off our beers (I got an awesome Midnight Sun Berzerker Imp. Stout & a Moylan’s Old Blarney!) and would’ve chatted a bit more but honking horns made us move! Thanks Andy!
Mar 2007	maniac	Puzzl sent out a 2001 Dogfish World Wide Stout an Arcadia Scotch Ale and a Bieropholie Imperiale Stout all carefully packed in a styro shipper.
Mar 2007	hopdog	Andy quickly sent me; Midnight Sun Berserker & Gluttony, La Barberie Imperial Stout & a growler of Captain Lawrence Smoked Porter! What a great selection! Thanks!
Mar 2007	goldtwins	On our second trade Andy sent me 4 beers. Three of which have a combined total # of ratings equal to 1!!!!!!!! Midnight Sun Fallen Angel and Gluttony Triple IPA and as bonuses Captain Lawrence Smoke from the Oak, Bieropholie Imperial Stout. Hell Yeah!
Mar 2007	cbkschubert	Andy sent me two Midnight Sun Bombers. A Kodiak Brown and a Beserker IS (sweeeeett!). He also included a Weyerbacher Quad and a 22 oz. Insanity (a favorite). He also tossed in an Ithaca Double IPA for good measure. All beers arrived safely in a styro shipper. Andy did me right just as he did as my Secret Santa. Glad I was able to help with your BA fix. Thanks again.
Mar 2007	JohnC	Puzzl delivered a fine selction of midnite sun and other brews. It was a very easy trade
Mar 2007	TAR	Andy is a good kid. He sent me lots of Captain Lawrence goodies and included a few bonus stouts (Cooperstown and Mendocino Oatmeal). Cheers, friend!
Mar 2007	drewbeerme	we agreed on Midnight Sun La Maitresse du Moine and he threw in a Midnight Sun BERSKER!! what an extra! thanks a lot, I owe you.
Mar 2007	ogglethorp	Andy sent me the SH Cuvee Des Fleurs and BFM Cuvee 7eme as part of the trade and sent bonus beers of Mendocino Winter and Ithaca IIPA. Great trade, quick and painless, great packaging, the whole nine yards!!! Thanks!!
Feb 2007	Ty5592	Andy delivered to me 1- Captain Lawrence nor’easter 1-Growler of Captain Liquid Gold and added an 05 Perkuno’s Hammer and 1-Ithica double IPA. Well packed and Delivered in one day to my front door. Thanks
Feb 2007	Silphium	Andy sent a nice package with 1 bottle each of Sly Fox Saison Vos, Southern Tier Jah-va Imperial Coffee Stout, Middle Ages Dragonslayer Imperial Stout, Southampton Abbot 12, Ithaca Double IPA, Mendocino Winter Ale, and a well-hidden bottle of 1997 Rogue Old Crustacean! Thanks for the great trade!
Feb 2007	cquiroga	Andy packed up some Southampton Saison Deluxe and lovely extras (SPH Biere de Garde), and was patient enough to deal with my sorry ass the whole way. I offered out of the blue to send him some PP saisons some several months ago, and told him it’d be a long wait before I could promise to deliver, but he was most gracious with delay after delay. Would gladly trade again.
Feb 2007	thebaldwizard	The gem of the trade was berserker, but also recieved Captain Lawrence IPA, Ithica IPA, and Mendocino Winter Ale. Sent on time and arrived in fine condition.
Jan 2007	Ty5592	Lawrence that is, as in his Captains Reserve. A growler I might add. Nick also threw in a bomber of Sockeye Red for good measure. Shipped quick, fast ,and in a hurry. Arrrr, thanks matey
Jan 2007	hellomynameis	Andy kindly sent me a big ’ol bottle of South Teir Jah-va! Imperial Stout. I’ve been looking forward to this for quite some time. Thanks for the awesome score!
Jan 2007	goldtwins	Well that and a growler of Captain Lawrence Captain’s Reserve. I asked Andy if he wanted to pick me up a T-shirt and swap it for one that was too small (yes unworn) for me. He said it would be too big but then he sent me the one I wanted anyway. He may wear a size small but his generousity is huge. He even tossed in a bonus of Arcadia Scotch Ale. Great trader.
Jan 2007	footbalm	Great communication and a very easy trade to get some Heresy X 3, a bottle of Tuckaleechhee Porter and a Saison from Southampton. Thanks Andy for this one.
Dec 2006	hopdog	Andy quickly sent me; Southampton Abbot 12 & Captain Lawrence Extra Gold!!! Thanks for the quick and easy trade!
Nov 2006	holdenn	Awesome trade with quick communication. Puzzl sent 3 - Hair of Dog Adams, went out of his way to get 1 - 04 vintage of Perkunos Hammer and 2 - 05 vintages of Perkunos Hammer, 2 - Southhampton Imperial Porters, 1 - 05 Old Herb (another older vintage beer), 1 - Southampton IPA, 1 - Southampton Grand Cru, and a great bonus of 1 - Southampton Tripel!! And on top of all of it I got a styro shipper
Nov 2006	bu11zeye	Great communication, excellent beers, would certainly trade with again! I received:Allagash 11, Captain Lawrence Dubbel, Southampton Old Herb, Weyerbacher Pumpkin, Heavyweight Saison Spicy, and a few others (a couple of extras). THANKS!
Oct 2006	beerhandy	Lost Abbey Avant Garde midnight Sun La Maitress du Moine expertly packed! Thanks Andy!
Oct 2006	RagallachMC	puzzl sent me the agreed upon ’05 BA Old Salty, and also sent me a bottle of Perkuno’s Hammer, and a Victory Ten YearAlt. Fast shipping would be an understatement. Friendly and easy to deal with, I hope to trade with him again someday.
May 2006	JCapriotti	Got a nice package from puzzl... lots of east coast goodies from Southern Tier and others!
Feb 2006	kramer	Andy sent me my quickest trade ever. Finalized trade on Saturday and I got it Monday at 10am! puzzl sent: Minight Sun Matriesse du Moine, Southern Tier Jav-ah Stout and Porter, and Lost Coast 8-ball. Then bonused me a Stoudt’s Fat Dog, Kumbacher Eisbock, and Otter Creek Stovepipe Porter. Great communication and in a styro shipper to boot. I wouldn’t hesitate to trade again! Thanks!
Nov 2005	SuIIy	Andy did very well in his first trade. Communication was great, packing was great. He sent a bruocsell 1900 and as extras, brooklyn black chocolate and monster ale, stoudts trip and middle ages trip crown. Awesome job

RateBeer Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter, RateBeer Weekly, a must for understanding new people, places and beers in worldwide craft culture.

By subscribing to the newsletter, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Contact us

Add To RateBeer

Manage Your Account

RateBeer Newsletter

Stay Connected