George999 (462) - Colorado, USA - SEP 18, 2015 cblado (298) - Washington, USA - AUG 27, 2007
3.3 AROMA 8/10 APPEARANCE 3/5 TASTE 7/10 PALATE 3/5 OVERALL 12/20
Bottle, purchased from Good Harvest in Waukesha, WI. Very malty for an IPA, also had an almost fruity taste. Lots of head on this. Would try again. (Also used it in a delicious beer bread recipe, superb!)
From the bottle the pour is clear auburn to orange with a light head, the aroma is light hops and a little lavender, the taste is malts and bitter hops, the finish lingers and is slightly roasted malts almost burnt. GreatDane1632 (1169) - North Dakota, USA - JUL 11, 2015
Rated based on notes taken 27 July 2012 -- Good brew. Brought back from San Antonio. ChadPolenz (1847) - Lakeland, Florida, USA - MAY 14, 2015
It’s always been my policy not to review beers I know are old. However, if I’m not entirely sure – due to an illegible or non-existent freshness code – I’d say it’s fair game. Based on my experience with Butte Creek’s Pale Ale the other day, as well as many years of experience with old beer, I’m inclined to believe this bottle of their IPA is out of code. Had I bought it at a bottle shop or supermarket that would almost be understandable, but I bought this at the brewery’s taproom. Old or not – any beer sold at a brewery’s taproom deserves scrutiny. Let’s just say I’ll bet this beer is pretty good when drank as it’s supposed to be tasted.
njager246 (697) - grand rapids, Michigan, USA - DEC 4, 2014
I poured a 12oz bottle into a tulip glass. It appears to have been bottled on 8/28/14 (the code is difficult to decipher) and cost $3 ($0.25 per ounce).
Appearance: Dark brownish/orange color; translucent with particulates in suspension. Pours to a two-finger, white, frothy head which laces and retains surprisingly well.
Smell: Mostly sweet golden malt. Some lemon lollipop (usually indicative of old/oxidized beer).
Taste: You can always tell an IPA is old because the hop character has really faded (though I’ve never quite understood where the hops go – it’s not like they evaporate in the bottle!). Quite malty for sure – a palette akin to that of an amber ale. Sweet caramel and slight toffee notes, along with yellow lollipop. A mild, but noticeable and consistent bitterness lurks in the background through. It becomes slightly dry and sharp at the apex, but otherwise has no citrus, piney, or floral flavors and features. For what it’s worth, this is tolerable but not really enjoyable.
Drinkability: Butte Creek Organic India Pale Ale weighs in at 6.5% ABV, which is about average for a single IPA these days. Though the palette is uninspired, the actually deliver is passable. Low carbonation provides for a slightly thick/tepid mouthfeel. The hops linger and leave a dry, pasty/starchy aftertaste. I even get some alcohol warmth on the finish, but at least it’s smooth going down.
Malt aroma with some sweetness... taste is a little mild sweet... not one of the better organic beers I have had shrubber85 (11570) - Greenville, Indiana, USA - OCT 26, 2014
Bottle. Orange peel/quinine and orange malt aroma. Hazy amber with small head. Sweet orange malt and moderately bitter lemon peel/quinine flavor. Drinkable but only just.
Patrickctenchi (6690) - Cox’s Knob, columbus, Indiana, USA - OCT 10, 2014
Nearly clear amber with a whipped beige head.
Bread, vinyl/faux-leather aroma.
Taste is watery caramel malt, bark....grainy, piney bitter.....orange peel.
Taste like a non-alcoholic beer (cornflake water) with a touch of inept IPA bittering.
Not good, not good at all. slowrunner77 (12581) - Reno, Nevada, USA - OCT 1, 2014
"not exactly a "liberal" hop presence when you take into account where this same from. as with all their beers, it’s a little on the thin and prickly side, but fresh - the hops are pretty well represented with a nice citrus backbone." BeerdedDave (1853) - Beckley, USA - JUL 16, 2014
cloudy amber color; mild, floral hop aroma; bitter with a good deal of citrusy, piney hops on a medium bodied, bready malt base; overall a decent IPA boozedude (2228) - Des Moines, Iowa, USA - MAY 26, 2014
bottle shared with my pal josh at club w, cloudy prange pour with white head, hoppy, weird taste some orange fruit, decent, but kibda akward ttoadee (1550) - Austin, Texas, USA - OCT 26, 2013
Light copper pour, thin but thick head to start. Nose is faint grapefruit. Somewhat bitter. Middle is caramel malt. Finish is lastingly bitter. Would have liked a few more hops at the end of the boil, just me.