darkguardian (733) - Florida, USA - AUG 19, 2010
750ml thanks to GodofThunder at RL&RL. Pours pitch black. Huge bourbon nose with light fruity undertones (presumably the brandy). This beer will be near perfect in a year. Right now its a little hot. Hits your mouth up front with intense bourbon heat and settles into roasted chocolate, coffee, oat, and molasses. With a massively thick full body this sucker is hard to drink. Gorgeous to look at and possessing of a fantastic finish with cherry, vanilla and roasty grains and dark chocolate this beer is impeccably crafted and in a years time will be absolutely amazing. It just needs a little time for the bourbon to meld with the beer. steelcitybrew (454) - Orlando, Florida, USA - AUG 19, 2010
UPDATED: APR 17, 2011 Pours a jet black with no head. Aroma is chocalate bourbon, roasted malts and nuts. Taste is perfect. Bourbon is strong with chocalate and coffee. Brandy notes are also there. Palate is awesome we’ll balanced and great warming ability. Overall this beer is almost perfect Ibrew2or3 (8808) - Tempe, Arizona, USA - AUG 15, 2010
750mL poured deep dark void with dark mocha head, a bit of legginess along the inner edge of the glass and sparse spotty lacing. The aroma is rich with chocolate, toffee, dark roasted malts, some smooth bourbon like sweetness and caramel covered oak. The taste is smooth and churns up oak and spice and then interspersed with dark to burnt malts, thin dark chocolate like layers, some toffee, caramel, boozy whiskey notes and then aged caramel drizzled oak planks. It gets spicy and a touch hot into the finish. This ends up seeming a bit long on the barrel time for my taste, but not by much. 50belair (3679) - Florida, USA - AUG 15, 2010
UPDATED: MAY 15, 2011 A big tip of the cap to Hopscotch for sharin’ this beast. A bubble-less oil slick of concentrated delight. Doing what Cigar City does best, this complex warlock’s brew has more sacrificial ingredients than the La Brea tar pits! I’m serious, maybe only Dark Lord can compare to the complexity behind the Marshal’s label. Like any sailor entranced by the sweet songs of the Siren, the notes you hear will be specific to you. That being said, I tasted smooth delicious chocolate, molasses, brandy, oak, bourbon, and carmel. A real stunner.... hopscotch (11181) - Vero Beach, Florida, USA - AUG 15, 2010
Bottle… This beer rocks!… Pitch black ale. A very hard pour creates a thin, fat-bubbled, dark brown head. I normally have an ornery sniffer, but this complex brew is easily broken down into modules of caramel, mocha, fruity apple brandy, bourbon and oak. Full-bodied with a fairly thick, creamy mouthfeel and very little carbonation. Burnt and bitter, the flavor is a carbonaceous swirl of charcoal, ash, sweet mocha and dried dark fruits. Warm, comforting finish. I’m not a big fan of apple brandy and would have enjoyed this beer more had half of it been aged in a Cognac or traditional brandy barrel, but it’s a top-notch, world class beer nonetheless.
jseifer (62) - Orlando, Florida, USA - AUG 14, 2010
Great, amazing beer. Everything about this is smooth. I kind of like Bourbon county stout from goose island better. This is an amazing beer. Practically perfect. GAManiac (1944) - Atlanta, Georgia, USA - AUG 14, 2010
750mL yellow-wax bottle from a super generous FL BA.
Pours a viscous oily black with very little carbonation - just a collection of brown bubbles around the edges. It does leave some brownish legs along the sides, almost tinting the glass a bit.
The aroma is complex and fantastic. It’s all in there - bourbon, vanilla, cocoa powder, charred black malts, oak, tobacco. I mean, it’s just a massive nose.
The taste doesn’t disappoint either. The burnt malt character is even more dominant than in the aroma. There is bitter chocolate, espresso and dark fruits. The barrel character hits hard in the finish and the bourbon especially burns going down.
The mouthfeel is where this one falls short of excellent as it’s hardly carbonated at all. I had a regular 2010 Zhukov last week and it had the same issue. It doesn’t completely take away from the beer but does affect the overall impression.
This is a massive, heavily charred impy stout that has a solid but not overpowering barrel character. If the carbonation had been a bit better this one would be a world class beer. It’s still an excellent beer. zathrus13 (1776) - Mount Laurel, New Jersey, USA - AUG 5, 2010
Rating 1400. Bottle, thanks Matt. Pours dark brown/black, with a slight brown head. Aroma is bourbon, dark fruit, brandy, roasted malt, molasses, and a bit of smoke. Flavor is brandy, bourbon, dark fruit, roasted malt, molasses, caramel, and some alcohol. Start sweet and ends somewhat dry and a little bitter. Body is not as thick as I expected or as it looked like when I poured it. Great stuff. mufasa (11) - USA - AUG 4, 2010
This was a fantastic beer. I could not imagine it being any better. Pours pitch black with no head. I love the complexity of this beer, my palate was going crazy with everything going on with this. I can’t wait to try my second bottle once it ages a little more. craftbeerdesign (2254) - Fort Collins, Colorado, USA - AUG 1, 2010
UPDATED: NOV 22, 2010 tasting on 7/30/10. pitch black pour with no head. I get a lot of the brandy barrel throughout this one - the bourbon barrel takes a backseat. dark fruit, chocolate, spice and brandy nose. big round body with lots of spice, roasted malts, sweet dark fruits, chocolate, light coffee and brandy. somewhat hot finish with more roast and a touch of the barrels. great barrel blend of an outstanding base beer.