Prufrockstar (2259) - Moscow, Idaho, USA - JUN 6, 2016 Westmeister (2127) - Atlanta, Georgia, USA - JAN 14, 2013
3.8 AROMA 7/10 APPEARANCE 3/5 TASTE 8/10 PALATE 4/5 OVERALL 16/20
Bottle (XX version) - Pours a near black with light at the edges with a bubbly yet quickly diminishing head. Smell is rich dark fruits, chocolate and not much of a noticeable hint of the barrel-aging. Taste is licorice, mild old coffee, chocolate, oak, dark fruits and mild oxidation. I thought the flavors where all very nicely incorporated with one another and even the oxidation was not offensive in the least. Very nice.
Bottle at home on our last night in this house in Seattle. This week I’ve gone through XXV, XXIV, XXIII, and finally we’re down to the last bottle. I don’t know anymore why I wanted to buy all of these in the first place, or why I would want to hold onto them for so long, but those questions are irrelevant now. Dark pour with creamy brown head that dissipates to a ring but never disappears. Smells old (faded hops), but once it’s in the mouth it comes to life. Lovely milk chocolate with a surprisingly pleasant coffee backing. Moderately sweet; its age doesn’t detract at all at this point, and I can honestly say this is my favorite of the bunch. The rest ... aging did them no favors. Maybe that’s true here, too, but unlike those I’m actually enjoying this one. I guess they just don’t make them like they used to. kyzr (1602) - Montana, USA - MAR 28, 2016
XXI Pours Black with dirty foam colored medium head. Big nose of roasted coffee. Flavor has dark chocolate, espresso and hints of bourbon. Nice thick body that is made to sip. From Old Notes jredmond (8839) - New York, New York, USA - SEP 16, 2015
[Backlog 2014] Bottle courtesy of Eric at his place for a tasting. Pours a deep blackish brown body with nice thick tan head. Nose is oak, soft vanilla notes, toast, cream and coffee roast. Mouthfeel is medium to full bodied with notes of toasted malt, oak, bourbon, coffee roast, caramel and very faint sharpie marker. drpimento (3814) - La Crosse, Wisconsin, USA - MAY 4, 2015
First of all this is the XX version. Secondly, this is one of the weirdest beers I’ve ever had. Appearance is a short-lived brown head, no lace, and opaque brown black color. Aroma at first is dark ripe fruits, cocoa, coffee, lumber, leather, but soon that goes waaay bad - to a dirty public toilet! And that aroma kind of comes and goes, but it’s nasty. And when I went to take my first sip, my god, that nasty aroma was going into my mouth!! That wasn’t easy. After a bit the flavor gives way to the initial aroma qualities, plus whiskey, vanilla and a bit of tang and bitter. Body is so so as carbonation is on the flat side. Luckily the nastiness don’t persist into the finish. PartyFowle (954) - - APR 3, 2015
Poured from the bottle into a small tasting glass, the first of many beers brought from home and popped open at Dark Lord Day 2011. Espresso brown in color and mostly opaque, save some amber highlights. A frothy, sticky, one-finger head the color of cocoa powder remains in place for a long while. Hints of bourbon and vanilla in the nose, along with tangy dark chocolate and too-old coffee, which may be a result of the beer’s age (close to two years now). A bit of Sourdough tang pops up. Interesting amounts of piney hops remain. When cold, Black Butte tastes like a mouthful of bottlecaps — it’s heavily metallic. Warm is much, much better, exhibiting espresso mingled with sweet cocoa powder and more bitter dark chocolate, as well as a bit of Sourdough bread and some pine. Smooth blend. Extremely light carbonation is all that remains. Silky, creamy, slightly chalky medium body. Alcohol in the nose. Coffee-forward porters aren’t usually the most graceful cellar beers, but Black Butte XXI is still pretty awesome after all this time.
djd07 (16289) - Houston, Texas, USA - FEB 17, 2015
Bottle thanks to Rick, pours a very dark brown with small tan head. The aroma is strong roast, coffee, wood. Medium mouthfeel with strong roast, dark chocolate, wood, vanilla, held up very well. gramity (1684) - Edmonton, Alberta, CANADA - FEB 6, 2015
Pitch black color, light brown head. Charcoal, marshmallows, dark chocolate, big coffee beans, vanilla, dark chocolate, marshmallows, big espresso mouth. WOW, the espresso beans REALLY jump out. Sarlacc83 (2430) - Portland, Oregon, USA - JAN 23, 2015
22 oz bottle of the XX, pulled from my cellar a week or so ago. From notes.
A: Pitch black with a foamy creme head. Lacing.
N: Oxidation, cocoa, molasses, oak, vanilla, intense coffee/espresso, burnt brown sugar, lots of char notes, and licorice.
T: Sweet, breaking down a slight bit, good sweetness.
M: Medium heavy body, prickly carbonation, alcohol is hidden.
O: Doing pretty well - I wanted to drink this before it dissolved, and I think I hit the mark. I would suggest drinking yours soon, if you’ve got it. This has very much calmed since its original release, too. eduardovl (1490) - SWITZERLAND - OCT 14, 2014
UPDATED: DEC 16, 2014 650ml bottle poured in a chalice.
Simply amazing Porter.
A: Pours a dark brown almost black color with a discreet beige to brown head
S: Strong on smoked malts. Hints of coffee, chocolate and dark fruits. Wood. Complex
T: Smoked malts. Hints of coffee and dark chocolate. Dark fruits. Also smooth notes of bourbon barrel. Dry taste and balanced bitterness. Bitterness seems to come mainly from the smoked malts with only small hints of hops. Alcohol is imperceptive
M: Medium to full creamy body and low carbonation. Perfect
D: Easy drinking. Really great stuff
[ BA Review @ 1/30/2011 ] AirForceHops (8026) - Epping, New Hampshire, USA - SEP 14, 2014
22 oz. bottle thanks to BOLTZ7555 on this cellared birthday porter. Label reads best after 10/17/10. No visible signs of oxidation on the cap. Totally opaque brown with thin off white head. Aroma is rich bourbon on top of dark fruits, and cocoa.
The flavor is earth chocolate malt, oak barrel, mild sticky molasses on the tongue. Unfortunately it does should mild cardboard oxidation notes. Good news is the bourbon helps cover it up some. Still a lasting bourbon lingers in the finish without any alcohol burn. Really great flavor but about 14- 15 months past it’s prime. I still was really pleased to try it.