brokensail (16645) - Dublin, California, USA - DEC 3, 2012
Quite the treat provided by Andy. Thanks, bro. Copper pour with a very small off-white head. Just an atrocious smell. Liquid smoke, chlorine, pennies, and sugar. Don’t forget the burnt wood leather, and tobacco, either. The flavor is poor, too. Overwhelming smokiness. Tons of metal and chlorine. Sugary sweetness, alcohol, tobacco, and leather. GeneralGao (3614) - Iowa City, Iowa, USA - DEC 2, 2012
Bottle. Poured a clear dark orange-brown color. The head was off white, a few fingers high, and reduced relatively quickly to a thin film. Smelled like a saloon; leather, wood smoke, and tobacco with a whiff of horse manure wafting in from the street outside. Medium bodied and delicately sweet. Plenty of smoke flavor with mild bitterness at the end. A splash of alcohol, subdued fruit, and a bit of toffee occasionally emerged through in the smoke. nuplastikk (6453) - Madison, Wisconsin, USA - NOV 18, 2012
12oz bottle. Cherry brown, unfiltered body. Thin, steady off-white head. Smoky sweet peat aroma. I was really quite scared when I read the two previous ratings, but actually this is quite tasty, an interesting merge of a big excessively smoked Scottish Ale and a Barleywine. There is something meaty about this one, sticky sweet charred BBQ tones. Drinkable for the ABV, clean enough. Unique, well worth a try if you enjoy smoke beers or barleywines. MacBoost (1936) - Victor, New York, USA - NOV 17, 2012
12oz bottle courtsey of PEPSIEDCAN and the great state of IOWA. Pours a cloudy amber with a generous sized head which eventually fades into a ring but still hangs around. Jesus, the nose on this beer is amazing... A dew filled morning after a night of camping... The ashes still smoldering, a few beer cans strewn about. Roasted hot dogs and sunshine... Hangovers and raccoon shit. Honestly, I have high hopes for this beer. First sip... OH MY GOD IS THIS FUCKING TERRIBLE. Way, way overdone on the artificial liquid smoke. Fuck, this beer is like just straight chugging liquid smoke. So fake, so chemical tasting, so repulsive. There is no way in hell I can finish this 12oz bottle, and I can chug some nasty shit, believe me. Holy Hell, this is the worst Barleywine I’ve ever had. Do. Not. Buy. DietPepsican (1589) - @ $13.99, Iowa, USA - NOV 13, 2012
Ruby red pour with a nice sized off white head. Beautiful pour! Aroma of smoked leather shoes, sticky malt, and a bit of earthy funk. Possible ammonia. My nose burns. Sticky sweet malt underneath all that smoke.. Definitely not my thing.