muteprint (176) - Olympia, Washington, USA - SEP 10, 2011
22 oz bottle in a frosty glass. Holy cow this is a strong beer. The immediate stand out flavors are coffee and chocolate with a strong bitter punch. Aroma is dominated by malt. Appearance is thick and syrupy black with a dark brown glass lacing head. Mouth feel is as it looks: very thick. Excellent beer. kchampagne (173) - Jacksonville, Florida, USA - NOV 21, 2011
Had it on tap, as well as out of the bottle. Pours pitch black with a thick dark brown head. Aroma is roasted and hoppy. The taste is floral and has slight chocolate notes. Mouthfeel is great with lingering bitterness. One of my favorites. jmarsh123 (163) - Indiana, USA - OCT 3, 2013
Wow this beer is black! Pours a dark motor oil opaque black with a small coffee colored head that died down to a thin layer with lacing.
Smells is very unique. Lots of good citrusy/piney hops but also a lot of roasted coffee as well. Very well balanced.
As far as tatse, there’s the black again. Good citrus hops notes at the front, but in no time the roasted coffee flavor takes over finishing with a very rich coffee flavor and a little dry.
Mouthfeel is pretty heavy, but not as much as expected for the color. Carbonation level is lower than average.
Don’t like it as much as the 14th, but another good annual from Stone. I’ve got a few of these and I’m looking forward to seeing how it ages.
Lorenasa (159) - Florida, USA - OCT 10, 2011
Fresh 22 oz bottle purchase at the brewery. The aroma is of hops. The tast is of chocolate and coffee bu is overpowered by grapefruity hops. Extreme bitterness ruins what coul have been a good beer. v8powered (157) - Las Vegas, Nevada, USA - MAY 10, 2017
Jag har så många öl att betygsätta avyer en stor åldrig öldrinkning med min goda vän Jesse, att jag inte har tid att betygsätta alla dessa och i många fall hade för öl att minnas storheten i dessa öl. Till ära för mitt svenska arv, jag skickar detta på svenska för alla recensioner från den dagen. Tack Gud för god öl !!
---Rated via Beer Buddy for iPhone
omegamike (152) - York, North Yorkshire, ENGLAND - MAR 18, 2012
Pours black with rapidly dissipating tan head. Aromas of apple, butter, some citrus aroma. Flavours are initially very sweet, apples and alcohol burn shoving its nose through. A good bitterness rounds it off. It’s very nice, not an overwhelmingly ’special’ tasting beer, but awfully drinkable and tasty. lukeherinckx (134) - mount pleasant, South Carolina, USA - AUG 28, 2011
stout like color with a thick tan head. very rich malty and piney aroma. Very resinous and grassy hop flavor with a nice malty backing to it. alcohol present on the finish with a nice lingering hop bitterness. Quite tasty. someviking (132) - old bridge, New Jersey, USA - OCT 31, 2011
beer pours as black as night with a small brown head that dissipates quickly. strong hop presence in the nose along with the typical dark malts making their way through. my oh my is this one delicious beer. alcohol hidden well amongst the strong hop and malt flavors it’s no surprise stone makes this fairly new style very well considering the amazing stouts and IPAs they already are known for. superb beer. as it warms up the alcohol pokes through well. Fatalstrike (130) - Cerritos, California, USA - SEP 17, 2011
UPDATED: OCT 31, 2011 Aroma - I get some definite chocolate and roasted coffee notes with the haunty hops following closely behind. Appearance - Ebony like a moonless night with a nice dark tan foam head. Taste - Not what I was expecting! I was thinking this would be a bigger version of the 11th/Self Righteous, but I was in for a shock. This is a full on stout when it comes to dark malt. Rich coffee and chocolate flavors up front. But wait for that awesome wave of hops at the end. Amazing. Palate - Full on assault of dark malts and piney hops weaving together. Thick and juciy. Overall - Pretty much a Russian stout with an insane hop profile. This is awesome. My favorite stone anniv. release since the 10th. Buy a few, drink one, and age the rest! scottyshades (130) - Parkland, Florida, Florida, USA - SEP 20, 2012
Growler from Greenville Beer Exchange
A: Pours and looks like a stout...opaque pitch black color with a beautiful dark brown head. Retention is awesome
S: Wow...seriously was not expecting this. Super west coast hop profile- resinous and piney, but really bright and fresh. All this accompanied by chocolatey malt. Really impressive considering that I am not a huge black IPA guy
T: Again, big time west coast bitterness, resin, and pine. Real big. Slightly bready and chocolatey as well. I like the balance. Why so much alcohol though??? It really cuts into the flavor and drinkability- a big flaw in an otherwise worldclass beer
MF/O: pretty rough on the palate but honestly I don’t mind. Strong resinous and bitter finish-palate wrecker
Notes: honestly, I thought these ratings would be a little inflated, considering I’m not a big fan of black IPAs, but this sets the benchmark for the style. Very impressive