CMUBEERMAN (457) - - DEC 23, 2005
Hides the alcohol well. Tastes great. Good balance between chocolate and coffee. Think I’d rather drink a cheaper victory though. GreenDragon (219) - Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA - DEC 22, 2005
Pours a deep brownish black with a dark brown head. Strong molasses, chocolate and roasted coffee aroma. Bitter chocolate molasses taste on a thick body. HumuloneRed (765) - Portland, Oregon, USA - DEC 21, 2005
22 oz. Bottle. It pours pitch black with a brown head and lacing. Served a the right temperature it has an amazingly complex nose of roast, malt and a bit of smoke. The flavor is the same but with some warming alcohol notes to it. Very smooth and creamy texture. Great beer. tlitt2 (58) - Lexington, Kentucky, USA - DEC 20, 2005
22 oz. bomber biatch. Very black, and awesome looking orangeish/ tan head. Very aromatic. Little coffee, a lot of licorice and some alcohol in aroma. Palate is surprising much thinner than expected. Not too sweet and raisiny, but seems nicely balanced in that regard. Licorice and prunes/ or raisins in flavor. Most drinkable imperial stout I’ve had yet. And one of the most p[owerful as well. Maybe I’m just over the initial flavor shock on my palate from bigger beers. Excellent beer. I’d buy this beer just for the description and all the witty little messages on the bottle. Stone brewing kicks a lot of ace. jisaza (2) - New York City, New York, USA - DEC 17, 2005 does not count
Disgusting, from the beginning to end. The after taste was terrible too, I end up dumping it through the drain, I feel sorry for the pipes. No doubts that the person who said that, you will feel like drinking thick oil, was right.
pinkzambia (2073) - Boise, Idaho, USA - DEC 10, 2005
22 oz. Bottle: Thanks to Indiana_Red we enjoyed this at a small stout tasting. Thick, dark, murky black in color. Even the light can’t penetrate this baby when held directly next to it. Rich aromas of roasted coffee are enjoyed as well as tastes of dark chocolate, black licorice, and sometimes, medicine. The feel is oily even though it is pretty thick. jzzbassman (1638) - Arlington, Texas, USA - DEC 10, 2005
Thanks to Secret Santa dhlesq for this goodie from my wish list. Poured a dark black with a tan head that faded to an oily ring. Big wonderful aroma of coffee, alcohol, and smoke. Very rich and smooth, with an almost milky essence, very well balanced with the perfect amount of bitterness for a good finish. A truly great Imperial Stout. julrey (32) - Austin, Texas, USA - DEC 9, 2005
Bottled Summer 2005 DrBayern (1140) - Morehead City, North Carolina, USA - DEC 8, 2005
Jesus. They really didn’t fuck around with this one, did they? Pours black as the darkest of nights, like the deepest corner of hell during a power outage. Smells like alcohol, molasses, a hint of black licorice, alcohol, maybe some brown sugar, then more alcohol.
Mouthfeel is not all that viscous, not too surprising given the amount of alcohol, but the flavors erupt on the taste buds, black coffee, brown sugar, molasses, and of course the alcohol is right up front, all around and dominates the finish. Very similar to the North Coast Old Stock I had a month or two ago. This was obviously intended to be aged at least a year but, this being my first go at this one, I couldn’t bring myself to wait. Big mistake: after a couple of normal strength beers and a dopplebock this one really fucked me up but good. I think I ended up consuming three meals the next day before my stomach even started to cooperate with me, and the rest of my senses were similarly out of whack. I can’t believe this shit is only available in bombers. The only real knock I have against this thing, actually. You really need someone to share this with unless it’s going to be your only beer of the day. I imagine this would rate at least a 4.5 if not a 5 on taste given a little aging, but I have to grade based on what I’ve got in front of me, and fresh off the truck there’s just a bit too much alcohol drowning out the other tastes.
UPDATED: FEB 19, 2006 Early Summer 2005 bottling. I compared this side by side with GD Oak Aged Yeti. It’s a tough job, but someone has to do it. Black as coal without a ray of light penetrating. Big dark brown head that sticks to the side of the glass. Coffee, sweet roasted malt, and just a hint of something floral wafts up from the glass. Wonderfully smooth, rich and creamy. More coffee, dark chocolate, and licorice punctuated by notes of peppery spice and citrus. Pleasant dry finish, not overly bitter or astringent. Makes the oak much more obvious in the Yeti. The two are close, but I give the nod to the Stone for its nearly perfect balance and complexity. acertain (249) - Seattle, Washington, USA - DEC 7, 2005
UPDATED: SEP 4, 2007 I’ve had this beer many times and I’ve been holding off rating it. I want to give it an amazing rating, and I wanted to try a bunch of other ones to make sure that I didn’t blow the scale.
Having now tried a bunch, I have decided that I won’t.
This is an amazing beer. It looks amazing; it has complex flavor and aroma and it feels wonderful in the mouth. Most other beers seem hardly worth drinking in comparison.
I feel very happy to have a bunch in my closet, but I fear it will not be enough to get me through to next summer when the next batch is released.