aenima (335) - Askim, SWEDEN - APR 12, 2013
Aroma of raisins and nuts. Taste is similar. Very well balanced. Some belgo yeast in the taste adds complexity. BeerSherpa (10) - Albuquerque, New Mexico, USA - FEB 20, 2011
I think that this is the closest thing that I have seen to an authentic Belgian from any American brewer. The reason I say this is because although American breweries seem to get all the flavors right they never seem to achieve the rich body that the old Belgian brewers have perfected. Grab it while you can! DocLock (10836) - Lower Pottsgrove, Pennsylvania, USA - MAR 10, 2011
Bomber from Capone’s after a long hard week, and AWAY we go! Pours turbid ruby primarily with caramel hints and a 1-finger thick rich well-retained head that says, "Don’t fuck with me, asswipe". Smells of floral spices, rock sugary yeasty malt, red vinous fruit. Tastes rich, a bit chewy, very fruity and hoppy, with caramel, heavy florals, yeasty spice, a late dryness, and a big hop element. I will do this horizontally with the regular version at a later date. This one is great, perhaps a bit less malty but more floral than the regular version, but just dripping with flavor and complexity. This one is delicious, and a testament to great brewing techniques melded with brass balls in experimental design. Braudog (6793) - Yorktown, Virginia, USA - SEP 18, 2011
Bottle. Moody, murky and rusty, this is a surly pour, topped with a nice sudsy head. The aroma is simply amazing -- burly and brusque, laden with tones of yeast, bread pudding and caramel. This drinks with paint-peeling strength, rich with warming, sugary alcohol and a bright, golden grape essence. Perfect for this rainy day of football! (#4260, 9/18/2011) andyhwcinc (1884) - Chicago, Illinois, USA - MAY 22, 2011
Rating of the ’10 version. Enjoyed on tap at Smallbar Division in Chicago, IL while watching the final week of Premier League relegation battles. Appearance very vibrant ruby copper with rich off white head, looks great. Aroma very nice, rich with a fantastic hop/malt mix with a unique yeast backing that is apparent in Stone brews.. Taste is the smoothest barley wine I’ve ever had. Fantastic mouthfeel, rich, has a bitterness attributed to the hops which are of the earthy variety, the smoothness is probably attributed to the yeast or even aging of this brew. I remember drinking the newer old guardian and feeling it was a bit harsh/boozey, but this one is very smooth and probably retains the ABV. One of the best Stone brews I’ve had yet and better than the first OG that I had.
ALIBALI (2316) - Kiel, GERMANY - SEP 24, 2016
Schweres sehr fassig wirkendes Barley Wine Freudenfest. Säure und trockene Rotfuchtflavours gehen eine heilvolle Allianz ein. Besonders der späte Trunk fängt den Komplexiwurm. 0,15/3,30€ vom Fass in der STONE BREWERY Berlin. Tybalt (212) - Colorado Springs, Colorado, USA - JUN 2, 2011
Good ’til the last drop. I had the original Old Guardian about 5 years ago, and I remember it being good (and potent), but I don’t remember it being this lively nor this smooth. Beautiful cloudy, golden pour. Carmel, wood, and spice...grand finish...terrific from lips to esophagus! warhawk91 (302) - Newington, Connecticut, USA - MAY 28, 2014
Bomber. Deep orange amber opaque, thin wispy white head. Aroma is big caramel, toffee and dark fruit. Slight Belgian yeast note but in the background, mild booze. Flavor is off the charts, big dark fruit and caramel notes almost a boozy bourbon sweetness. Some sweet citrus and spice, mild hop bitterness. Big tasty malt bomb, wish I could get another. Pyrmir (6170) - Uppsala, SWEDEN - OCT 10, 2015
650 ml bottle at Mackan, thanks! Amber with off white head. Aroma complex, sugar, toffee, malt, yeasty esters, woody notes and alcohol. Taste is similar, complex, fairly sweet, malty, sugar, wood and yeast in nice harmony. Really nice! Goodgrief (2053) - Middletown, Delaware, USA - APR 2, 2011
I was skeptical of the concept and the ratings on here seemed to be in line with my fears. What can I say? This really worked for me. Aroma of funky belgian yeast and a beautiful orangey amber color with solid one finger frothy head. The Belgian yeast adds a lightness and drinkability to the Old Guardian that makes me want glass after glass. It’s strongly yeasty and the yeast gives a tart, trippelesque twist. I really, really liked it. Will grab more before it’s all gone.