MrBunn (2826) - The Wet Side of a Dry Town, Pennsylvania, USA - SEP 29, 2007
Bottle. Odd thing about this is that the aroma and the appearance have nothing to do with eachother. I’m looking at this almost black body with a massive tan head, but the aromas I pick up are of pine, grapefruit and pineapple hops. So I’m a little confused on first sip as I pull back and enjoy that hops experience that is so Stone. Reminiscent of last year’s model, the hops are the main focus, and I find it hard to pick up any of the malts. I’m sure that it must be roasty, but with all that hops I can’t pick up on anything much. That said, the hops are balanced nicely and never get out of control. Different, that’s for sure. I would love to have the patience to let one of these sit for a few years to see what it will do. CheesedMan (555) - Saint Cloud, Florida, USA - SEP 29, 2007
Thanks SoLan!!!! Very deep brown, almost black color. Aroma is very hoppy upfront, citrusy and bright. There are some pretty strong malty notes coming out as well. Flavor was hoppy and bold. With some spiciness and roasted flavors that work nicely against the dark malt. Very nice beer. dmtroyer (431) - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA - SEP 29, 2007
22oz. This is one of the most exciting beers I have poured in a long time, having never had anything in this style. Pours coca-cola dark with a dense, almost tan head. Awesome carbonation that leaps up the side of the glass. Lots of bitter citrus in the nose and body that lends itself to grapefruit if you are so inclined. Intense malt and hop that integrates well with citrus, and hides the alcohol extremely well. Fairly original in its flavor profile coupled with such a refreshing body. I personally feel a "richer, creamier" palate would be inappropriate with the carbonation. thinking about buying a case before it disappears. mgumby10 (1856) - Jupiter, Florida, USA - SEP 29, 2007
Courtesy SoLan. Pours a dark brown, with an off white head. Bubbly. Pretty big hop aroma, alot of grapefruit citrus, and some dusty malts in there too. Pretty inviting smelling. The taste was very sharp, pretty big carbonation, fizzled in the mouth alot. There was a mix of grapefruit hops, sweet cinnamon and caramel malts. The hops really stood out in the finish and lingered in the aftertaste with some bitterness. I liked the blend of each of the ingredients. It made for pretty big flavor. Nice. grant (842) - Colorado Springs, Colorado, USA - SEP 28, 2007
Dark brown with impressive light brown head formation and retention. Interesting aroma - some fairly prominent crystal malts light citric hops and a weird wet leaf/pumpkin aroma that I don’t care for. Flavor is much more in line with what I’d expect. Somehow the roasted malt notes stay subdued and integrate with the bright, juicy citric hop flavors fairly well. There are problems with the citric acidity and the roast being a bit overwhelming together .This is sort of the same concept as Drake’s Expedition, only the hops come through more prominently in the flavor here, although the Drakes is more drinkable. I do love this concept though. Sharply carbonated finish; a richer, creamier palate would have helped here.
golubj (1377) - San Mateo, California, USA - SEP 28, 2007
Bottle. Aroma of some roasted malt, some smokiness, citrus hops undertones. The flavor is a mostly the roasted malt up front, followed by piney / fruit rind bitterness and bitter chocolate malt. Lingering bitter finish. illinismitty (2271) - Nashville, Tennessee, USA - SEP 28, 2007
UPDATED: AUG 26, 2008 Bottle from Whole Foods in Vienna, VA. Pours a cola brown with a tan head. Aroma of Fruity hops, nuts, and roast. Medium bodied with average carbonation. Initial flavor of dark malts and sap that transitions to an aggressive grapefruit and pine bitterness. Bitter finish is dry with notes of peanut shells and grapefruit rind. This tastes a little green to me. I am also not a fan of dark roast blended with aggressive bitterness. I hope this will improve with some cellar time, so that the flavors can meld. Now I just need to find another bottle so I can find out. kdrobb2k (24) - Willingboro, New Jersey, USA - SEP 28, 2007
I opened one of these in June 2008, and the hop presence is still there, and the flavors have melded, improving this a bit in my book. I am still not loving the concept of a Black IPA , but one year is better than fresh for me. I wish I had another to cellar for another year, but we do not get many cases in Nashville
CASK VERSION WITH WET SIMCOE HOPS. Totally different beer and should be allowed on a beer database, but I guess Stone is not in the UK. Greg Koch was nice enough to grab me a pint. Pours dark brown with a light beige creamy head. Great fruity wet hop aroma. Medium to light bodied with a creamy texture and soft carbonation. Taste? Wow. All of the flavors melded nicely on this one. The tame malt backbone of milk chocolate and caramel really blends nicely with the mellowed hop bitterness. The finish is semi dry with subtle accents of roast. No alcohol whatsoever. Very British in character, but with a bit more texture and complexity. Outstanding beer, and one of the best ones of RBSG. Too bad this has to be buried in another rating. A-8 A-5 F-9 P-5 O-19
First whiff off the bottle was stunning. Pours a dark black with a short but lasting head. Borders on a porter in appearance. Piney with a mild chocolate flavor. The sweet hoppy flavor comes through along with the smooth IPA type mouth feel. Some pleasant bitterness lingers on the tongue. Stone has out done itself on this one. Better than the 10th. jason (1834) - Easton, Pennsylvania, USA - SEP 28, 2007
Bottle. Pours a deep brown/ light black body with nice head. Aroma is hops, hops, hops. As that smell passes I can smell the coffee, grapes. Flavor is complex. Noticable are the hops which aren’t too strong but more of a dominant flavor with a nice roasty feel one would get from a Stout. Low carbonation with a sweet malt backbone. I think this one would be an intresting one to age. Very good beer. JahNoth (1039) - Rochester, New York, USA - SEP 28, 2007
Tangerine aroma - strong amarilo presence. Dark ruby in color with a thick, creamy head. Explosive hop flavor with a twang of sweet malt and some dark crystal. Rich and creamy mouthfeel. Alcohol builds as it warms. A real nice beverage.