Brewdog Chili Hammer - IPA or SHV?

Reads 866 • Replies 11 • Started Thursday, February 23, 2017 4:49:21 PM CT

The forums you're viewing are the static, archived version. You won't be able to post or reply here.
Our new, modern forums are here:
RateBeer Forums

Thread Frozen
 
WingmanWillis
admin
beers 1562 º places 1908 º 16:49 Thu 2/23/2017

Rated this as a Spice Herb Vegetable style and has been changed to an IPA.

Should it be a SHV as it has a strong chilli kick?

Thoughts?

Got to find me a new SHV that some admin doesn’t change the style. Twice now it has happened

 
chriso
beers 7540 º places 736 º 17:51 Thu 2/23/2017

Get yourself some crappy pumpkin beer. You should be safe with that.

Originally posted by WingmanWillis
Rated this as a Spice Herb Vegetable style and has been changed to an IPA.

Should it be a SHV as it has a strong chilli kick?

Thoughts?

Got to find me a new SHV that some admin doesn’t change the style. Twice now it has happened
SpicePA

 
The_Osprey
beers 10591 º places 178 º 00:17 Fri 2/24/2017

Originally posted by chriso
Get yourself some crappy pumpkin beer. You should be safe with that.


Brewdog Pumpk IPA?

 
Gary
beers 2114 º places 4 º 00:21 Fri 2/24/2017

Some of these admins get a thrill from changing styles and sending forum post removed messages . A sense of power lacking in their reality maybe

 
Leighton
beers 33714 º places 1204 º 01:31 Fri 2/24/2017

I changed this one, Dave. It’s part of an elaborate admin plan to try to get you to rate more beers. And I love the feeling of power it gives me when I change a style.

In the case at hand, I would say IPA is the style and that the chili is an adjunct (which in this case I don’t think should dictate the style).

 
WingmanWillis
admin
beers 1562 º places 1908 º 01:36 Fri 2/24/2017

Originally posted by Leighton
I changed this one, Dave. It’s part of an elaborate admin plan to try to get you to rate more beers. And I love the feeling of power it gives me when I change a style.

In the case at hand, I would say IPA is the style and that the chili is an adjunct.


Thanks you for the clarification Leighton.

Will have to rate 2 of each style now. Best dash to the Sahti shop!

 
Gary
beers 2114 º places 4 º 02:09 Fri 2/24/2017

Wingmane is a member of my secret clube so please do what he asks.

 
RichTheVillan
beers 10685 º places 101 º 02:12 Fri 2/24/2017

Originally posted by Gary
Wingmane is a member of my secret clube so please do what he asks.

+1

 
The_Osprey
beers 10591 º places 178 º 02:24 Fri 2/24/2017

Chili beers are more trouble than they’re worth

 
teorn88
beers 7739 º places 109 º 02:32 Fri 2/24/2017

But the real trouble only comes afterwards