Guinness

Reads 5304 • Replies 57 • Started Saturday, January 29, 2011 4:33:51 AM CT

Thread Frozen
 
haddonsman
beers 1234 º places 56 º 12:19 Wed 2/2/2011

I hate Guinness because it made me fat.
I hate Guinness because it took away ten years of my drinking life when I could have been enjoying other beer,
I hate Guinness because it's all about the brand and not about the beer.

Do I still drink it at weddings, funerals and parties when there's not even a sniff of a decent beer available? Course I do. But only if there's no Stella on...

 
dynamiteninja
beers 1872 º places 50 º 12:26 Wed 2/2/2011

Until relatively recently the Guinness Original in the UK was bottle-conditioned and until very recently the Guinness Original in Ireland was bottle-conditioned. <sighs wistfully>

 
FatPhil
beers 16631 º places 627 º 12:36 Wed 2/2/2011

Originally posted by dynamiteninja
Until relatively recently the Guinness Original in the UK was bottle-conditioned and until very recently the Guinness Original in Ireland was bottle-conditioned. <sighs wistfully>


I seem to remember BC guiness, in the tiny (284ml?) bottles, disappearing some time in the late 80s. I wouldn't consider that particularly recently.

 
dynamiteninja
beers 1872 º places 50 º 12:47 Wed 2/2/2011

Originally posted by FatPhil
Originally posted by dynamiteninja
Until relatively recently the Guinness Original in the UK was bottle-conditioned and until very recently the Guinness Original in Ireland was bottle-conditioned. <sighs wistfully>


I seem to remember BC guiness, in the tiny (284ml?) bottles, disappearing some time in the late 80s. I wouldn't consider that particularly recently.


I said 'relatively recently'. Given the 250 year plus history of Guinness it is relatively recently.

 
haddonsman
beers 1234 º places 56 º 12:55 Wed 2/2/2011

Originally posted by FatPhil
I seem to remember BC guiness, in the tiny (284ml?) bottles, disappearing some time in the late 80s.


That was me. I drank them all.

 
Fin
beers 10698 º places 1149 º 13:48 Wed 2/2/2011

Originally posted by FatPhil
Originally posted by dynamiteninja
Until relatively recently the Guinness Original in the UK was bottle-conditioned and until very recently the Guinness Original in Ireland was bottle-conditioned. <sighs wistfully>


I seem to remember BC guiness, in the tiny (284ml?) bottles, disappearing some time in the late 80s. I wouldn't consider that particularly recently.


Are you sure? I'm with the Ninja man on this, I thought BC Guinness disappeared much more recently than that, I haven't had it for many years I'll admit but surely it went on well into the nineties.

 
MagicDave6
beers 1 º places 1 º 01:00 Thu 2/3/2011

Originally posted by Gazza
Originally posted by dynamiteninja
Finally someone who isn't blinded by Marxist ideology

What's wrong with Marxism? He did predict this crap the Capitalists have got us into... and Marxism isn't totalitarianism or demigogue communism, but that's another story.

And Guinness is still shit no matter who makes it or where it's made. It used to be okay, now it's crap... I judge beer purely on what I have in front of me and I don't want Guinness in front of me, thanks.


Completly agree. Anything on nitro keg is a utter mess of a beer anyway, as its designed to ensure you get as little aroma and taste as possible, give you a fake mouthfeel, all so it looks good. Guinness itself is a dreadful drink anyway, its just a roasty flavoured alcopop.

 
Gary
beers 2036 º places 4 º 09:32 Thu 2/3/2011

Some people despite rating a good few beers keep their high scores for beers like Guinness through sentimental reasons. Its surprising to look at some peoples top 10 ,with like 2 thousand beers rated and Guinness is up there as a 5 amongst some great shit .

 
SilkTork
beers 5777 º places 93 º 11:55 Thu 2/3/2011

I think Guinness is trashed on this site rather too much. It's quite a drinkable beer. The main problem is that it is generally served too cold, so the flavour doesn't come through. But when in a cask-less pub, Guinness is a solid fall back with more flavour and character than a keg lager.

 
Gazza
beers 726 º places 164 º 12:54 Thu 2/3/2011

Originally posted by SilkTork
The main problem is that it is generally served too cold, so the flavour doesn't come through

There's a good reason it's served so cold - the flavour is putrid.

When in Dublin a few years back watching a band I had a pint of Guinness for curiosities sake and, predictably, it was pretty awful - although I'd been drinking Wrasslers previously so just about anything would taste like piss after that.

I forgot about it and only remembered when the band had finished so took a gulp... all I can say is I've never had my tongue ripped out by harsh astringent hops that much in years, and the roast flavour was almost absent and, instead, it tasted of metallic caramel.

Disgusting swill, and I shan't be drinking any next weekend when I go scooping Eire craft beer in Dublin!!!