Magic Rock Bourbon Barrel Bearded Lady

Reads 1372 • Replies 33 • Started Sunday, July 14, 2013 3:22:05 PM CT

The forums you're viewing are the static, archived version. You won't be able to post or reply here.
Our new, modern forums are here:
RateBeer Forums

Thread Frozen

Message madmitch76 P beers 36870 º places 240 º 00:56 Fri 7/19/2013 Originally posted by Fin Everytime I go on the Magic Rock Website, they always seem to have no beer in stock, does anyone else have this problem? Am I simply to assume that it is probably a bearded Scotsman hoarding the entire stock. Sounds like Sourced Market!
Message Scopey P beers 24165 º places 727 º 01:28 Fri 7/19/2013 Wow this thread has gone on a lot longer than it should have....
Message chriso P beers 7540 º places 736 º 02:32 Fri 7/19/2013 Originally posted by Beersiveknown i aliased it as soon as it came up, I don’t think it should be split either Agreed. But I think we do have precedents for different bourbon barrel treatments giving rise to different entries in some instances.

Message Beersiveknown P beers 5380 º places 180 º 03:25 Fri 7/19/2013 Originally posted by chriso Originally posted by Beersiveknown i aliased it as soon as it came up, I don’t think it should be split either Agreed. But I think we do have precedents for different bourbon barrel treatments giving rise to different entries in some instances. yes, that’s why i wanted to check the bottle, brewer obviously not intending it to be separated by barrel type, even though they give this info on blog, its more of a extra info rather than marketing point
Message Leighton P beers 33700 º places 1204 º 03:42 Fri 7/19/2013 Don’t beers usually stay split until there’s a definitive case for getting aliased or merged? It wouldn’t really bother me either way, mind.
Message Beersiveknown P beers 5380 º places 180 º 03:47 Fri 7/19/2013 merged as its the same beer, no different from any other annual release with same recipe
Message Leighton P beers 33700 º places 1204 º 03:49 Fri 7/19/2013 Originally posted by Scopey Wow this thread has gone on a lot longer than it should have.... It’s always the threads you would least expect.

Message chriso P beers 7540 º places 736 º 04:12 Fri 7/19/2013 Originally posted by Leighton Don’t beers usually stay split until there’s a definitive case for getting aliased or merged? Yes. But I think there’s enough to make a definitive decision in this case.
Message anon84892 beers 3284 º places 21 º 05:09 Fri 7/19/2013 I’m glad we got the bottom of this one. Next on the agenda is Black Tokyo Hrizon. New release has significantly lower abv 15 vs 17 (something like that) also Nogne appear to have released Horizon Tokyo Black, anyone know what the difference is?
Message chriso P beers 7540 º places 736 º 05:13 Fri 7/19/2013 Originally posted by BenH also Nogne appear to have released Horizon Tokyo Black, anyone know what the difference is? No idea. Unverified, but being looked at by Yngwie