Minnesota is rating Cigar City

Reads 25029 • Replies 226 • Started Saturday, September 19, 2009 9:00:58 PM CT

The forums you're viewing are the static, archived version. You won't be able to post or reply here.
Our new, modern forums are here:
RateBeer Forums

Thread Frozen

Message JK beers 7296 º places 442 º 21:00 Sat 9/19/2009 Scores are not doing well, but we’re not done yet.
Message JoeMcPhee P beers 12092 º places 543 º 21:04 Sat 9/19/2009 Which ones?
Message MatSciGuy beers 924 º 21:05 Sat 9/19/2009 And I really want to like it. I’m sad.
Message BDR beers 2535 º places 61 º 21:06 Sat 9/19/2009 Cigar City 110K+OT Batch #2 I.R.I.S. Cigar City Big Sound Scotch Ale Cigar City Big Sound Scotch Ale (Bourbon Barrel Aged) Cigar City Bolita Double Brown Ale Cigar City Campeador - Fergus Mor Cigar City Capricho Oscuro Batch 2 Cigar City Guava Grove Cigar City Humidor Series Jai Alai Cedar Aged India Pale Ale Cigar City Improvisación (Oatmeal Rye India Brown Ale) Cigar City Jai Alai India Pale Ale Cigar City Maduro Oatmeal Brown Ale Cigar City Mocha Cubano

Message satan165 beers 1021 º places 102 º 21:06 Sat 9/19/2009 ouch on the batch 2 ratings one of the best beers ive had in 6 months
Message BDR beers 2535 º places 61 º 21:08 Sat 9/19/2009 Originally posted by MatSciGuy And I really want to like it. I’m sad. + 110K+OT
Message gkost beers 1069 º places 32 º 21:12 Sat 9/19/2009 Originally posted by satan165 ouch on the batch 2 ratings one of the best beers ive had in 6 months No joke! Not trying to flame ratings, but that 3.1 rating scores Capricho #2 and Yuengling Black & Tan the same
Message gunhaver beers 1030 º places 13 º 21:15 Sat 9/19/2009 with the homers come the inevitable haters

Message BDR beers 2535 º places 61 º 21:16 Sat 9/19/2009 Originally posted by TampaBrew Originally posted by satan165 ouch on the batch 2 ratings one of the best beers ive had in 6 months No joke! Not trying to flame ratings, but that 3.1 rating scores Capricho #2 and Yuengling Black & Tan the same Yuengling Black & Tan was a better beer!
Message Guerde beers 1297 º places 9 º 21:17 Sat 9/19/2009 Originally posted by TampaBrew Originally posted by satan165 ouch on the batch 2 ratings one of the best beers ive had in 6 months No joke! Not trying to flame ratings, but that 3.1 rating scores Capricho #2 and Yuengling Black & Tan the same The Capricho smelled good, but it didn’t taste good.
Message gkost beers 1069 º places 32 º 21:18 Sat 9/19/2009 Fair enough ... just sayin.