Unhappy brewer

Reads 9548 • Replies 126 • Started Wednesday, March 13, 2013 12:10:47 PM CT

The forums you're viewing are the static, archived version. You won't be able to post or reply here.
Our new, modern forums are here:
RateBeer Forums

Thread Frozen
 
RABinCO
beers 1707 º places 103 º 10:37 Tue 4/30/2013

the thing is, RB doesn’t allow for abiding by "if you don’t have anything nice to say then don’t say anything at all." If you’re rating a beer 0.8 then it’s going to be hard to find anything good, much less nice, to say about it. i’d do the same thing BROcansail did and i think i have on occasion. but i was given the chance to just leave a numerical rating and leave the comments blank, i’d opt for that in a lot of those cases.

 
flabeer
places 2 º 11:08 Tue 4/30/2013

Originally posted by womencantsail
No, that’s not what I’m saying. I have posted multiple times now that I was a dick about it. Most of my ratings are pretty much the same basic format and syntax and I decided to have some fun with this particular rating, that’s all. Was it poor form? Probably.

As I stated before, the reason I even posted about this is because I thought it was amusing the guy was upset at my poor form and then proceeded to lower the bar even more.

From your posts, it seems like you have the correct and professional approach for dealing with raters and customers who gave some of your beers unfriendly/rude/etc. reviews, so I’m not sure why you’re rushing to the defense of a guy who decided he should one-up someone on the asshole totem pole.

Not defending in any way, just understanding where he’s coming from.
As a rater, its all fun and games but to brewers listed on this site, weather they want to admit it or not, are affected by what happens here.. Somehow, much to my amazement, Ratebeer and BeerAdvocate are looked upon by the press as the last word on craft beer. Lazy journalism, but it is what it is.

 
TheHOFF43
beers 2052 º places 169 º 11:36 Tue 4/30/2013

Originally posted by flabeer
Originally posted by womencantsail
No, that’s not what I’m saying. I have posted multiple times now that I was a dick about it. Most of my ratings are pretty much the same basic format and syntax and I decided to have some fun with this particular rating, that’s all. Was it poor form? Probably.

As I stated before, the reason I even posted about this is because I thought it was amusing the guy was upset at my poor form and then proceeded to lower the bar even more.

From your posts, it seems like you have the correct and professional approach for dealing with raters and customers who gave some of your beers unfriendly/rude/etc. reviews, so I’m not sure why you’re rushing to the defense of a guy who decided he should one-up someone on the asshole totem pole.

Not defending in any way, just understanding where he’s coming from.
As a rater, its all fun and games but to brewers listed on this site, weather they want to admit it or not, are affected by what happens here.. Somehow, much to my amazement, Ratebeer and BeerAdvocate are looked upon by the press as the last word on craft beer. Lazy journalism, but it is what it is.


Cumulative, unbiased ratings are a good way to view things. Should we ask the brewers if their beer is good? Should we ask the fanboys if the beer is good?

You’re getting way too defensive of your brewing brethren. I rate beers to kill time at work, at taprooms or for fun. I don’t do it for a living, no one is paying for my shitty reviews. Sorry than every so often I don’t feel like writing that the flavor, aroma and appearance all were sub-par and I’d prefer to prepare it to fucking horrible things like mom farts and band-aids.

 
DietPepsican
beers 1589 º places 63 º 11:43 Tue 4/30/2013

Originally posted by flabeer

As a rater, its all fun and games but to brewers listed on this site, weather they want to admit it or not, are affected by what happens here.


Good. If you brew a beer that tastes like hot dogs and a chemistry set, you’re going to fail. Too much crappy beer out in the world right now thanks to brewers that have no business brewing beer.

Also, I don’t think we have nearly as much influence as you think on most beer brands. Sure, the companies that are catering just to us and producing random one off nerd beers aren’t going to survive with low ratings. I agree with that. The majority of the craft beer sales here at the store don’t come from people on this site or beeradvocate, they come from people who actually drink beer.

 
t0rin0
beers 93 º places 1529 º 11:46 Tue 4/30/2013

Originally posted by khoffman43
You’re getting way too defensive of your brewing brethren. I rate beers to kill time at work, at taprooms or for fun. I don’t do it for a living, no one is paying for my shitty reviews. Sorry than every so often I don’t feel like writing that the flavor, aroma and appearance all were sub-par and I’d prefer to prepare it to fucking horrible things like mom farts and band-aids.


But I think thats the whole point here: it’s too easy to say stuff like that on the internet because you’re more or less anonymous. Look at those facebook people that show up here periodically because they have a hard on for adamjackson. You think any one of those people would act like that if they met him in person?

 
wutangfinancial
beers 204 º places 33 º 14:16 Tue 4/30/2013

Just keep in mind that the beer your rating is the result of someone’s passion, sweat and blood.


I love the whole "Passion" argument. One can have a lot a passion for something, but that doesn’t mean they do it well or have the particular God-given ability to do said activity, and it doesn’t justify them doing it on a commercial level or as a profession. Its like all those people who can’t cook who want to open restaurants or some Wall Street guy wanting to own a vineyard that doesn’t know the first thing about wine making.

I am very passionate about horses and horse racing, and I would love to spend my days at the track training Thoroughbreds, but I know I probably don’t have the right type of mind to go get a Veterinary Science degree.

In the end, regardless of how passionate someone is doesn’t mean that passion will make up for lack of talent and that the person should open a business. That is the definition of the Entrepreneurial Myth (book by Michael Gerber).