As a brewpub, OP does it’s job well, but not superbly. At times it seems to focus more on the food than the beer, which happens to be pretty good. When I lived there, my friends and I would flock there in the fall for the fantastic pumpkin ale. The stout is usually what I go for, but they have (had?) a good hefty double IPA that is quite tempting for dessert. The decor and food are nothing standout, but far from poor. It feels like it could be a chain of regional restaurants. If you can make a second stop in Kalamazoo, make sure it’s here.
Nice comfortable brewpub with some decent brews and pretty good food. Had a couple good stouts, a good cream ale and a decent IPA.
Worth a stop if you have already hit the big boys in town, waiter said a lot of folks eat there on the way to the big beer destinations.
Restaurant vibe on the inside with a bar area towards the middle. Small selection of in-house beers. Decent stuff. Nothing excellent, but solid. Food was pretty good, too, & the service was fine. Priced pretty well. Don’t go out of your way strictly for this place, but it’s around the corner from Bell’s. So if you’re at Bell’s, it’s worth it to stop in for a few if you’ve never been.
Olde Peninsula is going downhill. You can feel it in the air there. The service used to be top notch, and while it is still good, it is no longer exceptional. The beer selection still remains good. They only serve the beers that are brewed at Olde Peninsula, but they make some decent beers and even some specialty beers occasionally. The food has seen the greatest decline. This was one of my favorite places in Kalamazoo to eat, but the last few times I’ve been in I don’t even recognize the food. The BeerBQ Pizza used to be phenomenal with a thick fluffy crust is now made on a cracker crust. The beer is still a decent value, but the food is not. I cannot express the disappointment in having a place that used to be amazing see such a rapid decline.
I’ve been drinking OP’s beers since Gonzo used to brew there, and have been enjoying this place ever since. Their brewer (Dan) is a really nice guy and cranks out very good brews.The staff are friendly and the food is good too. I love me some OP!
Kind of crowded during the weekends but the wait is never significant for an average size party. Menu has some Kalamazoo staples (brewpub dip is a must for regulars and out of towners alike) and really above average meal offerings at a reasonable price. This place really stands out for Dan Kiplinger’s brews. Having been to many similar brewpubs around Michigan (those that do not distribute outside) I can say OP’s beer offerings are rock solid examples of each respective category, both year-round offerings and seasonal specialties. Haymarket Cream Ale, Midnight stout, Pumpkin ale, whatever you choose you cant go wrong.
Rumors of questionable beer quality were greatly exaggerated. Which is good because in a town with great beer places like Kzoo, you can’t be an average brewpub. The IPA and BWB dark strong pale are both excellent beers. Don’t let the tepid ratings fool you.
Not that bad of beer at this place Unfortunately we had a waitress who actually told us to "hold on a second" when she was just chatting casually with the bartender.....take that away from this experience and I would have given a much higher rating!