I don’t believe in the word "overrated."
5.0—heavenly: the perfect beer. Not a single thing can be made to make it better.
4.5-4.9—phenomenal: ecstasy in liquid form. It is so good I want to bathe in it. To the extent that I may never find perfection, this is as good as I expect the best beers in the world to be.
4.0-4.4—excellent: an unforgettable experience. It may not even be my style, but God knows it’s good stuff.
3.5-3.9—great: I will happily drink and enjoy one again and ...