Mill St. Tankenstein

Reads 2170 • Replies 17 • Started Monday, February 22, 2010 5:27:41 AM CT

The forums you're viewing are the static, archived version. You won't be able to post or reply here.
Our new, modern forums are here:
RateBeer Forums

Thread Frozen

Message jercraigs P beers 14887 º places 1051 º 05:27 Mon 2/22/2010 Isn’t this just dry hopped Tankhouse? Anyone know different?
Message Radek Kliber P beers 8151 º places 422 º 06:59 Mon 2/22/2010 Yeah I think so, that friday special one offs thay do now , am I right ?
Message garthicus beers 3025 º places 65 º 07:33 Mon 2/22/2010 Can we leave it sit until we speak to the brewery? I’ll be there on Friday at the next cask evening and can ask.
Message jercraigs P beers 14887 º places 1051 º 10:21 Mon 2/22/2010 Originally posted by garthicus Can we leave it sit until we speak to the brewery? I’ll be there on Friday at the next cask evening and can ask. Are they doing it every week Al? I guess I knew that. It would be nice to figure out in advance what is going to be ratings vs. what is not.

Message garthicus beers 3025 º places 65 º 11:43 Mon 2/22/2010 Yes, every Friday. They described it as an experiment to make cask versions and variations of their already existing line ups and that it will be one offs only, not to be repeated.
Message garthicus beers 3025 º places 65 º 11:48 Mon 2/22/2010 Quote "Every Friday we will showcase a brand new beer on cask, something that we’ve played around with, had fun with...each beer will be different. Dry hopping here, extra malt there, different ingredients, unique ingredients - we will have fun with this and the beer will be great" So can we please ensure that we delete we know what exactly was different with each brew before dismissing it as "ah it’s probably just dry hopped"? Cheers.
Message garthicus beers 3025 º places 65 º 11:50 Mon 2/22/2010 Sorry - typo/error. I meant ’before we delete’
Message HogTownHarry beers 9241 º places 28 º 11:59 Mon 2/22/2010 So ... there’s a BOTTLE/KEG Tankhouse; and there’s a CASK/’REAL ALE’ Tankhouse. Ah, if ONLY MILL STREET WERE IN ENGLAND - we wouldn’t be having this discussion, now would we? Because cask/keg is clearly a recipe change. In England.

Message blankboy beers 9700 º 14:01 Thu 2/25/2010 BTW, the actual name was TANKHOUSENATOR.
Message MrManning beers 2009 º places 60 º 14:43 Thu 2/25/2010 Originally posted by HogTownHarry So ... there’s a BOTTLE/KEG Tankhouse; and there’s a CASK/’REAL ALE’ Tankhouse. Ah, if ONLY MILL STREET WERE IN ENGLAND - we wouldn’t be having this discussion, now would we? Because cask/keg is clearly a recipe change. In England. harry, how dare you question this?
Message jercraigs P beers 14887 º places 1051 º 14:56 Thu 2/25/2010 Originally posted by garthicus So can we please ensure that before we delete we know what exactly was different with each brew before dismissing it as "ah it’s probably just dry hopped"? Cheers. Al That works great, and I agree with you but that assumes that Mill St. will always be clear about what changed. Dry hopped Tankhouse is not new, its been at Cask Days etc. (assuming that’s what this new entry is.) I hate to be the one beating the dead horse but it comes up every time something like this gets made, and frankly its kind of annoying to have to debate each one. There are still a couple of entries in there that shouldn’t be if we apply the "no dry hop" rule, and a few that are not there but should if we are going to ignore it.