| Buckeye Lake Amber Red Ale / International Amber Ale | 5.5 | 8/4/2012 | Rate | 2.88 | | 2 |
| Buckeye Lake AmeriStop Mt. Pleasant IPA ISA - Session IPA | 4.9 | 8/6/2016 | Rate | 3.15 | | 3 |
| Buckeye Lake AmeriStop Sherman's Stout Stout | 5.7 | 3/18/2017 | Rate | 3.18 | | 3 |
| Buckeye Lake Bang-N-Go Back IPA - Black / Brown / Cascadian Dark | 7.8 | 6/30/2015 | Rate | 3.19 | | 2 |
| Buckeye Lake Black IPA IPA - Black / Brown / Cascadian Dark | 7.8 | 3/16/2013 | Rate | 3.39 | 46 | 9 |
| Buckeye Lake Blonde Blonde Ale / Golden Ale | 5.1 | 3/20/2012 | Rate | 2.87 | 34 | 12 |
| Buckeye Lake Blonde - Blueberry Pie Blonde Ale / Golden Ale | 5.4 | 4/24/2019 | Rate | 3.04 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake Blue Goose Cream Ale Cream Ale | 5.1 | 6/3/2015 | Rate | 3.03 | | 4 |
| Buckeye Lake Blue Goose Cream Ale - Juice Cream Ale | 5.1 | 4/24/2019 | Rate | 3.02 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake Brown Porter Porter | 6.3 | 9/20/2012 | Rate | 3.21 | | 5 |
| Buckeye Lake Buffalo Lick ISA - Session IPA | 4.9 | 6/30/2017 | Rate | 2.98 | | 2 |
| Buckeye Lake Cherry Street Cream Ale Cream Ale | - | 12/28/2015 | Rate | 2.95 | | 2 |
| Buckeye Lake Christmas Ale (alias) Flavored - Other | - | 1/30/2013 | | | | | |
| Buckeye Lake Coconut Stout Stout - Milk / Sweet | - | 11/8/2013 | Rate | 2.81 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake Coffee Stout Stout - Flavored / Pastry | 5.7 | 11/3/2013 | Rate | 3.15 | | 4 |
| Buckeye Lake Dam Imperial Stout Stout - Imperial | 9.0 | 2/8/2017 | Rate | 3.02 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake Dark Saison Saison / Farmhouse - Dark | 8.0 | 6/7/2016 | Rate | 3.09 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake Double Raspberry DIPA IIPA DIPA - Imperial / Double IPA | 8.7 | 12/18/2017 | Rate | 3 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake Dublin Irish Red Ale Red Ale - Irish | 5.7 | 2/19/2012 | Rate | 2.99 | 44 | 12 |
| Buckeye Lake English Mild Mild Ale | 3.8 | 7/4/2017 | Rate | 3.12 | | 2 |
| Buckeye Lake ESB Bitter - Ordinary / Best | - | 9/4/2013 | Rate | 2.99 | | 8 |
| Buckeye Lake Freaky Tree Pumpkin Chocolate Stout Flavored - Pumpkin / Vegetables | 5.7 | 12/18/2017 | Rate | 3.19 | | 2 |
| Buckeye Lake French Toast Blonde Blonde Ale / Golden Ale | 5.4 | 7/21/2020 | Rate | 3.09 | | 2 |
| Buckeye Lake Fresh Hop Pale Ale (alias) Pale Ale - American (APA) | - | 9/6/2013 | | | | | |
| Buckeye Lake Glorious Hazy IPA IPA - Hazy (NEIPA) | 5.6 | 4/28/2021 | Rate | | | 0 |
| Buckeye Lake IPA IPA | 6.4 | 5/6/2012 | Rate | 3.21 | 39 | 12 |
| Buckeye Lake Lake Water IPA IPA | 5.6 | 12/22/2014 | Rate | 3.12 | | 2 |
| Buckeye Lake Legend Valley IPA IPA | 6.5 | 6/30/2015 | Rate | 3.23 | | 7 |
| Buckeye Lake Legend Valley IPA - Key Lime IPA - Flavored | 6.5 | 5/23/2018 | Rate | 3.12 | | 2 |
| Buckeye Lake Millersporter Porter | 6.3 | 7/4/2017 | Rate | 3.14 | | 2 |
| Buckeye Lake Nut Brown Ale Brown Ale | - | 1/3/2013 | Rate | 3.06 | | 5 |
| Buckeye Lake Oatmeal Stout Stout - Oatmeal | 5.8 | 3/20/2012 | Rate | 3.25 | 42 | 14 |
| Buckeye Lake Oktoberfest Märzen / Oktoberfest Bier | 5.7 | 9/10/2014 | Rate | 3.18 | | 3 |
| Buckeye Lake Orange Vanilla Creamsicle Cream Ale | 5.1 | 5/27/2017 | Rate | 3.15 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake Padfoot Pils Pilsener / Pils / Pilsner | - | 8/7/2017 | Rate | 3.06 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake Pale Ale Pale Ale - American (APA) | 5.7 | 3/20/2012 | Rate | 3.12 | 42 | 9 |
| Buckeye Lake Passion Fruit Wheat Flavored - Fruit | - | 6/7/2016 | Rate | 3.06 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake Paw Paw IPA IPA - Flavored | - | 8/1/2013 | Rate | 2.84 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake Pontoon Pale Ale Pale Ale - American (APA) | 5.3 | 2/9/2016 | Rate | 3.03 | | 4 |
| Buckeye Lake Raspberry Stout Stout - Flavored / Pastry | - | 2/9/2016 | Rate | 3.09 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake Robust Porter Porter | - | 9/4/2013 | Rate | 3.26 | | 2 |
| Buckeye Lake Shovelhead IIPA DIPA - Imperial / Double IPA | 8.3 | 2/21/2014 | Rate | 3.42 | 38 | 9 |
| Buckeye Lake Shovelhead - Key Lime IIPA DIPA - Imperial / Double IPA | 8.3 | 2/9/2016 | Rate | 3.09 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake S'Mores Porter Porter - Flavored | 6.3 | 4/24/2019 | Rate | 3.09 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake Somerset Style Summer Wheat Ale | 5.4 | 6/8/2017 | Rate | 3.06 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake Strong Scotch Ale Scotch Ale / Wee Heavy | 10 | 2/7/2014 | Rate | 3.28 | | 8 |
| Buckeye Lake Tart Cherry Saison Saison / Farmhouse - Flavored | - | 2/17/2018 | Rate | 3.02 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake Thousand Dollar Bill Black Lager Schwarzbier / Black Lager | 5.2 | 12/13/2019 | Rate | 3.06 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake Vanilla Porter Porter - Flavored | 6.0 | 3/16/2013 | Rate | 3.34 | | 5 |
| Buckeye Lake Wheat Wheat Ale | 4.9 | 6/7/2012 | Rate | 3.03 | | 3 |
| Buckeye Lake Winner IPA IPA | 7.0 | 2/8/2017 | Rate | 3.02 | | 1 |
| Buckeye Lake Winter Shanty Flavored - Other | 5.7 | 12/7/2014 | Rate | 3.28 | | 5 |
