Latest reviews from Northbabylon

“In just comparing this place to the other Superstars I have visited, I would say this one has the best growler fill selection (compared to Huntington and Melville). The bottle selection is comparable, though I would say Huntington is slightly better, and Melville is slightly worse. The growler selection is probably the main reason to come here.
The recent ratings before me seem to be one time sign-up users who came on here just to complain about this store, I personally didn’t experience any of their issues, the two guys working were friendly and helpful enough. I’d say ignore those reviews.“

ben4321 3485 days ago

“Shady mothers running this joint. I was ’tising the season with a pumpkin ale fix...brought what I thought was a magic hat pumpkin 6 pack to counter along with another 6 pack pumpkin ale & 2 22oz and $42 later...got to friends house only to be called "punked" because my magic hat container contained no magic hat but some weird German "nitzel" beer. I’m now driving back giving them benefit of doubt that some punk customer did this to save a buck. I get to counter and Wolfman like dude behind counter is all oh I told you this when you bought it. Um NO you didn’t why would I be buying a slew of pumpkin beers in pumpkin cartons if I wanted German schnitzel beer! He says "they don’t always give us cartons for beer so we have to put in WRONG MISLEADING cartons" So low and behold they don’t have any LEGIT magic hat pumpkin cold so I ask them to suggest another. They do, I take. & wolf behind counter has nerve to tell me I owe him $2.17. I say really!? You guys are selling trickery, I’m driving all over deer park tonight & I OWE YOU!? He says " yes it’s more $" I say ok, I will be leaving some nice reviews for your place then on internet. He says without a sorry or twitch, "ok" I say are you the owner? He says "nope!" With a smirk. Great business! Owner should be proud that he’s proudly cheating his customers where he can and supports having smug employees that support bad customer service.“

Legitrater 3497 days ago

“You can go to a supermarket and get beer for the same pricer or cheaper. The service in the North babylon one is horrible and the guy named Frank is a crook. Stay away from this place!!!!!!“

secretshopper 5104 days ago

“A lesser known store in the Superstar chain. The selection may not be what you see in the huntington store, but is still substantial. Most of the prices aree at or below average. The service is outstanding. The two guys who were working there this evening were very helpful, and very knowledgeable in beer. The store is clean and well lit. Definitely worth a stop if you are nearby. They also maintain a very up-to-date website on what they have on tap and in bottles. Nice place.“

tgncc 5156 days ago