I just cracked a fresh can of Surly Bitter Brewer and the cat urine smell is over the top! I don’t mind it, so it isn’t a bad thing, but I always thought Simcoe hops added the most cat urine aroma. According to Surly’s website, they use Columbus and Glacier hops in Bitter Brewer. |
I’ve personally never associated simcoe with cat urine. I think nelson sauvin can have that kind of aroma, specially if it’s a single hop. |
Simcoe and Citra definitely, Columbus a tiny bit... Citra are probably the hops which smell most like cat’s piss IMO. |
Columbus can be all over the charts from Pine, to Citrus, to Garlic and onion, do ridiculous dank weed, to cat urine. Just depends on the lot/crop they are using. |
Originally posted by Gazza Agreed 100%, Nelson Sauvin as well. |
Simcoe for sure. Pretty consistently this is the hop that exhibits it out of what is popular, and I for one love it in moderation. |
Jay- |
For cat urine, I vote Simcoe as well. I have come to really enjoy Columbus and Nelson Sauvin. Nugget, Centennial, and Citra are some of my besties. |
My favorite. Can’t wait to try some of these... |
I drank a few 4-packs of Bitter Brewer last year and don’t remember this aroma, either. I’m wondering if that aroma fades quickly or not, while some other hop aromas linger. |
I think I remember hearing Amarillo having that association? |
2000- 2024 © RateBeer, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service